We welcome thoughtful comments and respectful opinions that help make the case for the restoration of Marshall Field's to State Street and elsewhere. Off-topic, obviously incorrect, disrespectful or abusive posts will removed at the host's discretion, although an attempt will be made to contact the author, assuming a valid email address is provided with the post. The ethos is conversational--corrections are welcomed. Differing or opposing views are welcome and such posts should respect that this is a blog for opinions of Field's supporters. Due to problems with spam attacks--some even from those opposed to our cause--during certain periods, posts are moderated. As a result, it may take up to seven days for your post to appear, but usually it will take less than a day, and sometimes even immediately. Thank you for your patience, support, and written contributions.

HOME | Enewsletter | Leaflets | About This Site

A 21st-Century Marshall Field's For A 21st-Century Chicago

Review why a revived and reinvented Marshall Field's make more sense than ever today and in the century to come..

Our latest survey shows 78% want Marshall Field's--14% prefer Macy's.

See our 2012 Survey Page for complete details including survey results.

Date: Sun, April 30, 2017, 01:04
Posted by: mikea,

It is hard to imagine what is happening now in2017 compared t the 80's when all of the great stores, Gimbels, Macy's hudson' Dayton's, Kaufman's, Famous Barr, bullock.s Broadway, Hecht's Ivey;s Gayfers, etc werea round. The discount chains and especially the cancer of all retail AMAZon killed the shopping experience.

Date: Sat, April 29, 2017, 19:19
Posted by: dave andrews,

Don't breathe a sigh of relief quite yet, Chicago! The management at macy is just blowing smoke--this is the same thing they said in Pittsburgh and Minneapolis. Oh, we're just gonna downsize to make the store "productive" and we definitely want to maintain a presence here. Once the initial announcement has been made, various options will be proposed then a buyer will appear who wants to purchase the entire building and macy will bail out.

I previously posted a link to a Business Insider article on how macy is transitioning to a discount operation. Their flagship store is a disgraceful mess and macy is going even further downmarket to compete with TJMaxx and Marshall's.

They are NOT interested in maintaining a vintage building and paying high city taxes. Has the Field's building has become rundown and worn? They will say it's cost prohibitive to bring it up to current standards. macy is following the same path as Sears--invest nothing in the stores, stock lower quality merchandise, sell off the assets to keep the stores afloat, cut staff and services, announce various turn around strategies. Everything EXCEPT giving shoppers what they want.

Date: Sat, April 29, 2017, 12:28
Posted by: gle,

I heard the announcement on WBBM Radio last night. While Landmark status protects many traditional aspects that Field's fans hold dear, I certainly hope someone worthy gets those upper floors. This is a nailbiter like when the CUBS played World Series last fall, but THEY came back. Let's hope Field's can come back!

Date: Sat, April 29, 2017, 02:14
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

The cast iron stairs, the first floor column capitals, the Tiffany ceiling, v the walnut room are all protected chicago landmarks. They cannot be compromised.

Remember Macy's wanted to put big signs on the top of the store and landmarks said no. Parts of Fields can never be compromised.


Date: Sat, April 29, 2017, 01:12
Posted by: Eric B.,

The just-announced downsizing of State Street doesn't seem so extreme in comparison with how Macy's has decimated flagship-caliber stores in other cities. The furniture, rugs, etc. can certainly be moved elsewhere. But we should be concerned about two historic features of the 8th floor that might now be in limbo. First, the viewing gallery overlooking the Walnut Room atrium, together with elevator/escalator access, may be compromised. Viewing the Great Tree from above is a part of the Walnut Room tradition, and eliminating this feature would be painful.

Second is the spectacular grand staircase with gilded ceiling between the 8th and 9th floors on the Washington Street side. Dating to 1907, this element was beautifully restored in the 1990s. I'm unsure of its original purpose, but what a splendid setting for fashion photography back in its day.

Date: Fri, April 28, 2017, 21:28
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

Whew, I feel like we dodged a bullet. It could have been way worse. Since state street is one of their top 3 doors, it made no sense to me to compromise it.Macy's abandoned the interior and fine furniture business, so 8 doesn't have a purpose, 6 is highly compromised since Macy's doesn't sell fine China or crystal, so that floor could be folded into the housewares in the first basement.

Smartest thing was to not cut off food service on seven from the store. And after closing food service in former Field's stores, the new ceo is talking about bringing dining experiences into the stores. Moron.

Date: Fri, April 28, 2017, 20:19
Posted by: Timothy E,

I won't even begin to open my mouth, because what I might have to say would be entirely unbecoming and beneath the dignity of Field's....

Date: Fri, April 28, 2017, 19:53
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Reporters seeking contact with us may call or text me at 312.927.4424

Jim McKay



Date: Fri, April 28, 2017, 19:52
Posted by: Jim McKay,

I will concur with Michael Dannhauser.

It could be much worse. Also, keep in mind they have been shopping floors nine and higher for different uses for at least 20 years. And, as the Trib pointed out, they will have to take one of the rooms on the main floor and upwards above it to get people to the upper floors. Based on the way elevators are currently laid out, I suspect that would probably be middle Wabash. (South Wabash, the section that Harry Selfridge was involved with for 1893, does not go all the way to the top floors, although it could.) There's some other factors which, if they don't move the Walnut room or take over some significant parts of floor 8, won't make this such a bad thing. At the same time we still want to get Marshall Fields back. As usual, I plan to go to the stockholders meeting in three weeks. Can youy come with me? If you are a Chicago Tribune subscriber, please write a letter to the editor.

Date: Fri, April 28, 2017, 19:52
Posted by: Michael D,

As hurtful as this is, only 8 is currently used for retail, so it could have been much worse. Still sad.

Date: Fri, April 28, 2017, 19:51
Posted by: Roberta M.,

Wow. I literally have no words.

My Grandma worked in the Employee Cafeteria at Fields for years (I have her retirement certificate). She would be disgusted as am I. 😢

Date: Fri, April 28, 2017, 19:51
Posted by: Roberta M.,

Wow. I literally have no words.

My Grandma worked in the Employee Cafeteria at Fields for years (I have her retirement certificate). She would be disgusted as am I. 😢

Date: Fri, April 28, 2017, 19:51
Posted by: Matt M,

They had better tread lightly. And Furniture is on eight, too! Hmm.

Date: Fri, April 28, 2017, 19:50
Posted by: Susan C.,

What a sad day. I really hate Macy's more than I hate Dayton Hudson's.

Date: Fri, April 28, 2017, 19:50
Posted by: Jennifer A.,

I loathe the M-word even more now.

Date: Fri, April 28, 2017, 19:49
Posted by: Jack Kenney,

What a sad day.

Macy's puts State Street flagship up for sale at least, top half of it

Macy's Loop flagship is for sale or, to be more precise, the top half of the building is available to potential buyers or joint venture partners.

Date: Mon, April 24, 2017, 22:05
Posted by: dave andrews,

Well, folks--the retail genius has accomplished his dream of dismantling America's iconic department stores (like Field's, Lazarus, Burdine's, Kaufmanns and other market leaders) and creating a chain of discount outlets to compete with TJMaxx and Marshall's. For those who study retail history, trying to beat an established retailer at their own game can have disastrous results; remember what happened when Kmart tried to beat Walmart on lowest price. That ill conceived decision was a big part of Kmart's epic fail. Surely the board at macy can't believe that going discount will save the day.

Clearly macy has no sense of direction or purpose. Let's take over and make the stores all the same--because EVERYONE just loves New York and is thrilled by "the magic of macy." Now let's localize the assortment. There are too many coupons. How about a weekly One Day Sale with the lowest prices of the season. How about we bring better merchandise to our "top doors." Now the new guy wants to add eateries to the stores--after the great one closed most of them. Let's sell off assets to make the shareholders happy (that really worked out great at Sears). Let's cut the staff to save money. How about putting deep mark down clearance merchandise right next to the newest arrivals. Let's bring in stuff we don't normally carry and offer it in a special area. How about closing loads of stores to make ourselves even MORE irrelevant to shoppers.

It's hard to imagine how the board allowed him to spin aimlessly while the stores continued to lose market share. The past few years at macy have truly been a "comedy of errors."

Business Insider visited the "flagship" macy store in New York. If this is their best, macy is definitely on its way out!

Date: Tues, April 18, 2017, 01:08
Posted by: Eric B.,

The Chicago History Museum, in cooperation with Getty Images, posted a number of historic photos of Marshall Field & Co. online. Prints may be ordered for non-commercial use. Here is the link:

The photos appear in random order. The most practical way to view these is to scroll through all 23 pages, one at a time. Photos of other Field's stores and warehouses are included in the mix. Most of the photos date to the 1940s.

These images are - in one word - incredible. They depict the State Street flagship as it then appeared - gorgeous and immaculate. All merchandise displays were neat as a pin; aisles were not crammed with tables and racks, and garments were not piled helter-skelter as in Macys stores of today.

Regrettably, this set of photos appears incomplete; views of several areas within the flagship store are absent. But you will find photos of office and work areas seldom seen by the general public (and did you know that Field's once had a gun department?).

Sadly, much of the building's original interior apparent in these photos was obliterated through subsequent remodelings. And now, we are apprehensive about just how Macys intends to "repurpose" portions of the building to accommodate new tenants. Landmark protection? Don't bet on it.

Does Macys need to downsize this venerable flagship store and emulate TJ Maxx's business model in order to survive? Heck, no! State Street is already saturated with discount stores renowned for banal merchandise, central checkouts, and zero customer service. What State Street DOES need is a unique, upscale, world-class store, one that functions as a magnet to draw in tourists and local shoppers who might otherwise have no reason to shop downtown. In other words, we need our Marshall Fields back.

We observe that luxury retailers including Selfridge's, Bergdorf-Goodman and (closer to home) Von Maur and Nordstrom are currently outperforming Macys and other major discount chains. The merchandise quality and luxurious ambience of the aforementioned stores are truly closer to Marshall Field & Co. as depicted in the 1940s photos than to any Macy's stores of today.

Date: Mon, April 17, 2017, 16:05
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Fox32 accidentally let folks slip a peek at their new news set coming later this month. The Great Marshall Field's Clock is shown in the background. Channel 9 news also features the Great Clock in its rotation of background images. It's unclear if the clock image will be a stationary image or part of a number of images on rotation. And oh yes, the clock is historic because of Marshall Field's--not Macy's.

Date: Fri, April 14, 2017, 19:09
Posted by: A State Street Spectator,

I worked downtown during the "Great Chicago Flood." I remember busy State Street suddenly transformed into a ghost town, with just a few curious people wandering about. The stillness reminded me of photos from after the Chicago Fire. Field's windows appeared suspended in time, with perky pastel-covered mannequins and "Fling into Spring" signs--oblivious to what was going on outside the windows. Field's soon added mops to the hands of the mannequins. A machine with large hoses pumped water from the north driveway of the building for several days. Filene's around the corner had a similar contraption. The buildings made me think of people in an emergency room all hooked up to tubes. I remember orange metal boxes labeled "aggreco" laying all over outside the store. Eventually life returned to normal and Field's again opened for business. Everyone was relieved.

Date: Fri, April 14, 2017, 00:46
Posted by: Stephen F,

Field's Santa since 1980, Jim Roetheli, passes away

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 20:14
Posted by: Jim ,

Ha! I didn't even know that was out there.

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 20:14
Posted by: Chris R.,

Fun photo I found [in the Chicago Tribune Archives from 11/25/2017].

Return to Marshall Field's

Jim McKay holds signs with Marshall Field's logo in front of Macy's store on State Street in Chicago on Nov. 25, 2016.


Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 20:12
Posted by: Claire O.,

There's a Field's Chicago Flood Commemorative shirt that Jeanne mentioned on eBay right now for $60!

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 20:10
Posted by: Jeanne S,

I read a recent article that the State Street store was only closed for a week because of the Great Flood of 1992, but I think it was longer like 2 or 3 weeks, it sure seemed like forever!

A year later, Field's gave out T-shirts commemorating the flood. I didn't work there, but they must have had signs up in the store that they were going to give a limited number of these away and I was there when they opened and got one.

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 20:08
Posted by: Susan C.,

I cannot believe 25 years have past. I worked in luggage in the basement when the flood hit. The smell for months afterward was awful.

When the store reopened I got sick from the smell and went outside to the State and Randolph corner for fresh air. Linda Yu from Channel 7 was out there and approached me to ask questions. When I told her what was wrong she left me alone.

On the first anniversary of the flood the store had a little party for the employee's in the 3rd basement. The display people painted the doors to look like your were looking out a window of a ship under water. For refreshments we had blue punch and fish cookies. The employee's were also give a commemorative t-shirt. I still have mine somewhere.

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 20:07
Posted by: Claire O.,

I picked up a framed newspaper page of the Marshall Fields ad from the flood at an antique store in Naperville a few years ago. I think State St. was closed.

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 20:06
Posted by: Jim,

It was nice to see Marshall Field and Company --not Macy's--on the front page of the Sunday Sun-Times yesterday, even though it was because of the great flood of 25 years ago. If you scroll down a bit in Neil Steinberg's story, you can see a larger version of the photo.

By the way: sometime back, I posted a really cool image of a full-page ad Field's had in the Chicago Tribune. The ad thanked Field's customers for their loyalty during the problems associated with the flood and shows the Marshall Field's logo all kind of warped in water with some fish swimming around it.

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 20:05
Posted by: Jim,

Was just looking at the WWD interview of Terry Lundgren on 3/22/2017 again.

Quote: "The performance was lifted to the point where from 2010 to 2012, Chicago was Macys top performing city."

Thinking in the same vein as Sara A and the credit card example. Given that Chicago has two tourist stores and to the best of my knowledge no other city has that, would that mean, that Chicago was a top performer with sales from State Street plus Water Tower combined? Sure, that's possible. But how did that compare with the two stores as Field's? Or, moreover, did he mean Macy's, Inc. which would include Bloomingdale's at 900 Michigan and Medinah too?


Aaron: Regarding promises to Daley, the Frangos weren't a certain deal. The promise was that no jobs would immediately be lost in the city--and that promise was kept. I would have to check but I also believe promises included upgrading the building--replacing the windows and some other improvements.

The Frangos promise was based on an issue as to whether confectioner workers qualified to make Frangos could be found. Ebert made a big deal out of Lungren saying that Frango production **might** be returned to Chicago. Ebert compared it to a mouse being made to go through a huge maze only to get a small or partial peanut.

I'm sure that you know, production was returned on a limited basis a couple of years later via Cupid Candies on the Southwest side. According to some posts by other fans here, an ABC7 interview with a Macy's exec, something to the effect was mentioned that Cupid even managed to eventually get the taste right. On air, supposedly the staff asked after the story something to the effect, "You mean they don't know the recipe?"

Simply my opinion, but through the years, it appeared to me in photos and the media that Mayor Daley looked less and less happy around Lundgren.

As far as I know, Rahm and Lundgren have only been at one public event together; a spring 2011 Chicagoland Chamber Commerce meeting. Rahm was on the bill as the new mayor. Lundgren was put on the bill as well. I wonder if Lundgren was added because PNC bank was involved in the event and at the time PNC was effectively one of Macy's biggest stockholders through a significant stake in Blackrock. The Sun-Times made a deal about Rahm and Lundgen being together. I've never heard another report placing them in the same room together since.

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 19:46
Posted by: Sara A,

I don't have access to however I'm always skeptical of what Terry Lundgren says.

One, I've read many interviews with Terry Lundgren. He often selectively manipulates the facts, in my humble opinion. For example, when he decided to switch to the Macy's name, he said one reason was that the first 200 Marshall Field's credit card accounts he pulled up had not been used in ages. OK--but how did that compare with the first 200 Macy's credit card accounts? He didn't answer. 200 accounts out of how many? If out of 400 then that would be pretty bad. Out of 1 million? That's nothing.

Two, Macy's has been extraordinarily promotional, much more so than Marshall Field's. If they spent half, or even a third, of what they spent pushing Macy's on Chicago on Marshall Fields instead, I'm sure it would be doing much better in Chicago then it's doing as Macy's.

There's more to this, but I have not seen the article. I just think Lundgren engages in a lot of spin. Personally, I wouldn't be surprised if someday it came out that things could've been a lot better if Lundgren had left Marshall Field's alone, or better yet nurtured it, in Chicago.

It's amazing how much people still lament the loss of Marshall Field's in Chicago and how much they loathe Macy's.

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 19:45
Posted by: Aaron M,

I think Mayor Daley's only stipulation was to bring Frango production back.

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 19:45
Posted by: Jim M,

As Roger Ebert pointed out, Lundgren never revealed specifics about methodology. Ebert said something like, "and if the survey really did show that he'd fire the survey company because Chicagoans really don't think that." Now when I presented our own survey results in 2009, 2010 & 2011, I did present our methodology and they showed between 78% and 80% wanted Field's. 2,300 uniquely surveyed on Michigan Avenue and State Street between 2009 and 2012 n the spring., etc. Lundgren and staff did not dispute.

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 19:44
Posted by: Michael D.,

Would love to see the survey referred to in the article, showing that Chicago supported a name change to Macy's. As everyone in this group likely knows , based on the polls this wonderful group has done, it's so far from the truth it would be laughable, if it weren't so sad.

Date: Thurs, April 13, 2017, 19:44
Posted by: Michael D.,

[ On March 22, 2017, the last day of Terry Lundgren as CEO pf Macy's, ran an interview with him. He discussed many things including the switch from Marshall Field's to Macy's.

Below is the link to the actual words, but the gist is that it was OK to do because Richard M. Daley was OK with the switch.

Moreover, Lundgren says that Chicago was Macy's top performing city in 2010-2012 thanks to changes he made.

The full story is at


Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:47
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Michael: Then again, they did something similar at Portland, OR. Eventually it closed because, according to some, the store didn't even look special after the rehab.

Moreover, when it was Field's, we never had to look for a silver lining--it was all silver--and gold, platinum and diamond, too, even almost to the end. Ever since Federated/Macy's took over, the media and of course Macy's keeps telling us to look for silver linings as the linings get thinner and thinner. Department stores can't do well? Then how come you see stores like Von Maur expanding? Because they use Marshall FIeld's ethos.

Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:45
Posted by: Michael D,

Looking for the silver lining, at least they're spending millions on renovating/restoring the remaining store. Let's hope it's mostly restoring.

Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:45
Posted by: Timothy E.,

Regarding Brooklyn:

Yuck, yuck, yuck. Architecturally speaking, I loathe 'modernizing' older, traditional styled buildings with tons of steel and glass. It's become as cliched (and boring) as those ubiquitous drum-shaped ceiling light fixtures that are seen installed everywhere for the past ten years. Yuck.

Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:44
Posted by: Aaron M.,

Let's hope [they don't do to State Street what they are doing in Brooklyn.]

Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:43
Posted by: Jim McKay,

"Downtown Brooklyns Macys will sprout a 10-story creative office hub

The redevelopment of Macys Brooklyn flagship store will bring 620,000 square feet of office space to the neighborhood.




Tishman Speyer is also the same group that is working on plans for redeveloping the State Street store. Could this be the similar to what they have in mind?

Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:38
Posted by: Michael D.,

"Macy's CEO Jeff Gennette: Acquisition rumors are not reality"

Cincinnati Business Courier

Macy's new CEO told a business publication that rumors that the retailer may be acquired aren't based in reality...

Continues at:

Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:36
Posted by: Ken A,

An interview with Macy's new CEO,


Macy's New CEO Has a Plan to Get the Retailer Winning Again - Here's What It Is

With stores closing and in-store retail tanking, Macy's new CEO has a big job ahead....


Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:32
Posted by: Aaron M.,

Apparently it's now just an event space? Not exactly a private area. Everyone heading to the Walnut Room from most escalators will be walking by!

Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:31
Posted by: Michael D.,

I did find some irony in Macy's talking about tradition. And noticed a State Street tradition not a Marshall Field tradition. I believe the Frango Caf was added as part of the 1990s renovation when 7on State was also added but I don't recall for certain.

Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:31
Posted by: Timothy E.,

The sign for having an event at the Frango Cafe says, "A State Street Tradition" - ??? Oh really? Since when- 2014?

Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:29
Posted by: Michael D.,

A couple of weeks ago on March 22, I wrote on Facebook that it appears the Frango Cafe on Seven is permanently closed and that Macy's always treated this as a stepchild.

Now Macy's has a sign up that one can "Host your next family gathering, business lunch, or company celebration right here at the Frango Cafe." along with contact info.

Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:27
Posted by: Christy W,

I just noticed Soucek's Marshall Field's book at the Rosemont Target as well. Ironic given the past relationship with Target/Fields.

Date: Thurs, April 06, 2017, 19:26
Posted by: Jim McKay,

I was a bit surprised in a good way to see that Chicago area Target stores are now carrying Gayle Soucek's book along with books on Wrigley Field, the Chicago Cubs, River View, State Street and Chicago Blues. How come Macy's doesn't realize they have something special--that even their competitors carry books on what they own. A fun coincidence: the particular Chicago Target where I saw the Marshall Field's book is on Broadway and Sunnyside, located about 500-1000 feet away from Mr. Marshall Field's grave in Graceland Cemetery.

Date: Wed, April 05, 2017, 22:56
Posted by: Pete,


I respectfully disagree. The new CEO is basically talking about Terry Lundgren's "localization" initiative which we've been hearing about since 2008 or 2009. And that was something other chains had been doing for years. While they localize a few areas of merchandise, I hear nothing about having distinctively localized chains of department stores brought back. And I certainly don't hear anything about bringing back Marshall Field's even though it was more valuable than all the other dust-binned department store names combined.

I'm not encouraged. Perhaps next Christmas will be bad enough that they will finally get the message, hopefully before it's too late.

Date: Wed, April 05, 2017, 21:52
Posted by: dave andrews,

New CEO at macy clearly "gets it:"

This observation by Mr Gennette was certainly NOT understood by his predecessor:

"I've noticed there's a big difference in customers and how they engage with apparel, accessories and the home department, depending of what part of the country they're from."

Perhaps if more reasonable minds had prevailed 10 years ago, the macy board and executives would have realized that one size does NOT fit all and their emphasis should have been on developing the strength of the regional department stores rather than slapping red stars everywhere while expecting shoppers to be excited by some elusive "magic."

It's a bit early in his tenure, but one wonders if Mr Gennette would be willing to bring back some of the iconic department stores and give shoppers what THEY want.

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:19
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Blues museum opening in 2019 in Loop

The privately run, 50,000-square-foot facility is slated to open in spring 2019 near Millennium Park. The group behind it has raised $25 million.

( This will be in the former Marshall Field's Men's store. The building at the SW corner of Washington and Wabash. )

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:15
Posted by: John C,

RE: story on Genntte:

Back in the 70s when I worked for Macy's in Kansas City, all their stores had a department called the Budget Shop with off-price clothing with labels cut out. Sounds like they may be rethinking getting rid of those departments.

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:15
Posted by: Timothy E,

RE: story on Genntte:

As long as Chicago gets back it's Marshall Field's - in name, quality, and service - Mr. Gennette can do whatever he likes with Macy's - and I'll wish him all the best.

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:14
Posted by: Jim H,

RE: story on Genntte:

Another TJ Maxx? That is his vision? No thanks

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:14
Posted by: Michael D,


Can This Man Save Macys?

The new CEO of Macys discusses his plans for the iconic department store to stay atop a shrinking market.


Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:12
Posted by: Timothy E,

The Field's clock motif (on flags or bags or boxes and so forth....) is (well, *was*) relatively recent. Historically, Field's utilized the Field Crest much more commonly, right up until the 70's. At about the same time that the name was changed from "Marshall Field & Company" to just "Marshall Field's" they also stopped using the old family crest and began using the clock face in it's stead. It's certainly no deal breaker for me - I love them both - but I actually prefer the old crest over the clock as a signature design motif for our favorite store.

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:11
Posted by: Michael D.,

Or even Selfridges yellow flags.

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:11
Posted by: John R.,

Now if all those Macy's flags on State Street were the wonderful MF logo with the clock motif and the *green* background, it could work. This definitely does NOT.

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:10
Posted by: Michael D.,

Macy's has replaced all flags on the State Street store except the ones above the great columns with Macy's flags, white star on a red background.

As tacky as the merchandise inside!

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:07
Posted by: Michael D.,


"Macy's lures shoppers with coupons and shoes as takeover fizzles

In a sudden turnaround this month, Macys appears to be free to find new ways to grow after a key investor has pulled out and a potential rival is shopping"

Continues at

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:05
Posted by: Michael D.,

It appears it's not only Minneapolis that lost the annual Macy's flower show, but Philadelphia too. It's understandable having closed downtown location, although it could've relocated it at least in part to one of the suburban stores, I find no explanation why they canceled Philadelphia, but it's missing from the website. It's great events like this generate traffic that flagships need.

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:04
Posted by: Susan C.,

Regarding the Cincinnati Business Courier's story from March 17, 2017: I hope the whole building is being sold to another retailer to restore Marshall Field's. Our activist activities did get a mention and that is good.

Date: Mon, March 27, 2017, 19:03
Posted by: Pamela C.,

If this store goes away entirely, I will never visit Chicago again. I miss MF a lot, but I still go in to visit the Walnut Room, admire the Tiffany ceiling, and appreciate the art deco elevator detail and wish that Macy's care enough to polish the brass and repair the floors.

Date: Fri, March 24, 2017, 21:08
Posted by: dave andrews,

The new CEO at macy has a difficult task ahead:

Online shopping has indeed taken away business from traditional department stores, but much of the damage here has been self-inflicted. Too many nondescript stores stocked with bland, boring merchandise.

Date: Fri, March 24, 2017, 01:46
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

The rumor is that Macy's decided to abandon Minneapolis is the building was l Iloaded with asbestos and was not worth the cost of renovations.

Date: Sun, March 19, 2017, 23:50
Posted by: Jim ,

TOMORROW, MONDAY, MARCH 20, 2017, IS A DEADLINE: Want to comment to Macy's Executive Chairman Terry Lundgren, CFO Karen Hoguet, CEO Jeff Gennette, the Board of Directors, and other stockholders on Marshall Field and Company and what will happen to the State Street store at Macy's stockholder meeting? Monday morning, March 20, 2017 is a deadline if you wish to participate in a critical Macy's stockholder meeting in Cincinnati at 11 AM on Friday, May 19, 2017. All Macy's stockholders as of this Thursday, March 23, 2017, are eligible to be admitted and to offer questions and comments up to 2-3 minutes upon the adjournment of Macy's annual stockholders meeting, usually in Cincinnati. Since it takes 72 hours for all stock purchases to be official, you need to make your purchase of at least one share of Macy's, Inc. stock first thing this Monday morning. At current prices, that would be under $31, plus a small fee paid to your broker. (My broker charges about $7.) it is true that you can represent somebody else who owns stock at this meeting, provided you present a notarized proxy statement from the stockholder. However, Macy's officials have given a hard time to some people who have traveled and presented such a proxy statement. In the end, they have despicably delayed entry past the start of the meeting so as to prevent entry to the meeting. So it's important that you just buy stock by Monday morning.

Date: Fri, March 17, 2017, 15:33
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Scary news, given the horrible track record macy has had with it's "crown jewels;"

Somehow evil and destruction are the motivating factors for a certain despicable, vile, power mad despot!

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 20:44
Posted by: A State Street Spectator,


Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 20:42
Posted by: gle,


Since Macy's doesn't want to serve customers anymore (never did in my opinion) I can just try on shoes at Payless. OR go to the shoe shore in Andersonville where a former Field's employee works, and you still get good service.

And if Starboard pulled out of Macy's, let's hope whoever they sold their interests to is worth it!

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:59
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Last Saturday was the day of Saint Patrick's day parade here in Chicago (six days early because it's always the Saturday before the actual St. Patrick's Day).

That said, we were out on State Street from about 11:30 am to 1:30 pm (the parade was three blocks east starting at noon until about 2:30 PM). Support for Marshall Field's and Company's return continued greater than ever.

Special thanks to John, Lucie, Aaron, Gail, Gayle, Gloria, and Alfred, among many others, who offered support in one way or another.

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:52
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Selfridges Oxford Street opened March 15, 1909.

Link to store photo provided by Official Selfridges Instragram. It's Marshall Field's architectural sibling:

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:48
Posted by: Paulette, Re: Chris D's post about Macy's Self Serve Shoe Depts,'s like getting your shoes at the bowling alley.

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:47
Posted by: Chris R, Re: Chris D's post about Macy's Self Serve Shoe Depts,

Yeah, because you know everyone's willing to go out of their way to get the same kind of service they get at Target, Walmart, or Payless shoes---SARCASM!Good God, as a Macy's stockholder, I think my investment is screwed. These people supposedly leaving Macy's have no idea what they're doing. The CFO, who was voted one of the best by the Wall Street Journal, is full of it. She needs to go. Too bad she'll making money

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:46
Posted by: Susan C, Re: Chris D's post about Macy's Self Serve Shoe Depts,

I was in a Payless on State St. about a half a black from a Macy's and they helped me.

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:46
Posted by: Marty B, Re: Chris D's post about Macy's Self Serve Shoe Depts,


Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:46
Posted by: Susan C, Re: Chris D's post about Macy's Self Serve Shoe Depts,

this is why stores are closing. When they do not have something they tell you to order it online. Some stores will ship to store but want you to pay for it up front and tie up your money until you try it on. I want to take my shoes home with me.

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:44
Posted by: Michael P, Re: Chris D's post about Macy's Self Serve Shoe Depts,

My wife tried yesterday. She's a size 11. A) No one bothered to help her at all, she had to find someone. B) Macy's never carries a woman's size 11 in the stores even though the shoe comes in a size 11. Their response was she could order the shoe on line. Went over to Nordstrom, sales person came over when she was ready. One of the shoe's she wanted was not in stock in her size (the carry 11 just was sold out) and offered to order them for her if she wanted. The other shoe she wanted was in the store in her size. We bought it and left happy. That's how you run a successful retail store, Macy's should take note.

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:44
Posted by: Natalie R, Re: Chris D's post about Macy's Self Serve Shoe Depts,


Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:44
Posted by: Donald M., Re: Chris D's post about Macy's Self Serve Shoe Depts,

Are the self chekouts next? I don't go places that make me do their work unless I get a discount for doing so. I haven't seen a discount on self checkouts yet

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:41
Posted by: Aaron M.,

It's not good for the retail sector, that's for sure. I see NM and Saks as direct competitors, although at the Fashion Outlets today, when I couldn't find a specific shirt (replacing one I was wearing), most stores said to try Last Call. No one suggested Off Fifth, Bloomie's Outlet, or Nordstrom Rack. FWIW, Last Call has distinguished itself at least among employees at that mall!

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:41
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Looks like Hudsons Bay is looking at some other deal other than Macy's (and Marshall Field's)... not necessarily a bad thing. I've been hearing from some Field's retirees they think Hudson Bay would have made State Street even more about real estate Simply their opinion.

Hudsons Bay in Discussions to Buy Neiman Marcus

The private-equity firms that own Neiman Marcus are in discussions to sell the struggling retail chain to rival Hudsons Bay, which could create a luxury powerhouse.




I wonder how that works when they have the Saks and N-M flagships kitty-corner on Michigan Ave...not to mention off-price stores at the like of the Fashion Outlets at Rosemont...???? Will they really close one?

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:39
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Exclusive: Activist investor Starboard exits Macy's stock - sources

Reuters, Yahoo Finance

The move gives Macy's incoming Chief Executive Officer Jeff Gennette more space to execute on the company's turnaround plan. It also comes after an acquisition approach by Canada's Hudson's Bay Co (HBC.TO), the owner of the Lord & Taylor and Saks Fifth Avenue retail chains, failed to...


Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:37
Posted by: Sara B, Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

At best they will be like Kohl's. At worse, Walmart.

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:37
Posted by: Aaron M, Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

Amen to that! :-)

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:37
Posted by: Timothy E, Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

They have a nice Corelle Boutique at the local Goodwill - and better prices and service than M@cy's... ;-)

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:36
Posted by: Aaron M, Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

You can't do self-serve shoes and keep it high-end. Stores that implemented this ended up with a Kohl's selection. Then again, they also had "Corelle Boutique" in their china department. I believe it was Spring Hill Mall where I saw this. :-(

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:35
Posted by: Steve G, Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

Your post, Jim, is spot on!

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:35
Posted by: Sandy W, Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

Can you even imagine? In his flagship store! Inside the very walls!

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:34
Posted by: Susan C, Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

OMG, Marshall Field is rolling over in his grave at that one.

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:34
Posted by: Sandy W, Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

I stood in the middle of a department at State Street after waiting to check out for 15 minutes and yelled loudly "Does anyone work here?" They came pretty quick after that.

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:34
Posted by: Susan C, Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

Well said.

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:33
Posted by: Timothy E Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

Yeah, seriously. How can we persuade Selfridges to make Macy's an offer they can't refuse for those locations, along with all rights to the Marshall Field's name / brand?

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:33
Posted by: David K, Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

Is there a way we could petition that?

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:33
Posted by: Linda A, Re: Jim & CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Changes,

Hawthorn in Vernon Hills also.

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:32
Posted by: Timothy E, Re: Jim and CNBC story on Macy's New CEO 5 Big Change,

Agreed, whole-heartedly. Sell off State Street. Oakbrook, Old Orchard, (and Woodfield?) to Selfridges, and let them do it up right.

Date: Thurs, March 16, 2017, 11:30
Posted by: Jim McKay,



Less reliance on sales associates is a new concept? Golly, by most accounts here, they've implemented that about 10 or 11 years ago. Less service, clearance racks, self-service cosmetics Big stores like Marshall Field's on State Street don't fit that concept. People who shop at a store like State Street want service. They want experience. Sell off State Street now to someone who does like Selfridges. They could use the money from the sale to remodel the rest of the Macy's to be more Target-like.

Date: Wed, March 15, 2017, 14:33
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

So here are the "big changes" planned by the incoming CEO at macy:

Let's see--The Bon Ton stores have had self serve shoe racks for years; all of the old school department stores had "bargain basements;" macy stores have operated on a barebones staff for years; many retailers have had long term leased departments (Walmart has had leased optical, hair salons, Subway and McDonald's restaurants to serve their customers); JCPenney stores have been operating and expanding Sephora cosmetic departments--and offering coupons similar to what Mr Gennette is proposing.

WOW! Those "big changes" will certainly recapture all the lost shoppers!

Date: Tues, March 14, 2017, 22:38
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

If Macy's wants to maximize 111 north state sell the store and the nameplate to someone that wants to operate a unique experience, something millenials seek.

Hudson's Bay perusing niemans makes sense. Richard Baker prefers better to high end retail. Macy's made little sense, first thing he did when buying Hudson's Bay was dump their discount chain, Zellers on Target. Macy's has been targeted as a take over by off price retailer ross stores, which is still expanding and has twice the market cap as Macy's and a pretty good fit with Macy's statements about mimicking off price retailers rather than being a real department store.

Date: Tues, March 14, 2017, 17:01
Posted by: Jim McKay,



Less reliance on sales associates is a new concept? Golly, by most accounts here, they've implemented that about 10 or 11 years ago. Less service, clearance racks, self-service cosmetics Big stores like Marshall Field's on State Street don't fit that concept. People who shop at a store like State Street want service. They want experience. Sell off State Street now to someone who does like Selfridges. They could use the money from the sale to remodel the rest of the Macy's to be more Target-like.

Date: Tues, March 14, 2017, 10:54
Posted by: KPOM,

The WSJ is reporting that Hudson's Bay is turning its attention away from Macys and toward Neiman Marcus.

Date: Sun, March 12, 2017, 20:02
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Business Insider analyst depicts what this blog has warned would happen since the macy*fication of America's department stores:

The picture of an outside macy entrance is representative of how run down and neglected the stores have become.

Somehow missing from all the discussions about the many problems at macy is the fact many of the failing stores were converted from popular regional department stores into a nationwide retailer that never gained traction with the communities it entered. Perhaps if Federated/May had recognized and capitalized on the strengths and popularity of the regional stores, the corporation would not be in serious trouble. Also amazing is the "mastermind" who orchestrated this debacle is not held responsible for this massive destruction.

The "mastermind" has caused irreparable harm across the nation. Somehow it's too far gone now to bring back the cherished shopping venues customers loved. His parting shot will be to downsize, divide, demolish and develop the State Street store so no semblance of Field's could ever be restored.

Date: Fri, March 03, 2017, 14:23
Posted by: Jim McKayj,


Report: Hudson's Bay Co. struggling to finance Macy's takeover - Cincinnati Business Courier

A news wire service reports that a Canadian company currently in a bid to take over Cincinnati megaretailer Macy's Inc. is having trouble lining up funding. More...

Date: Thurs, March 02, 2017, 22:32
Posted by: Pete,

Rating Action: Moody's downgrades Macy's Inc. senior unsecured rating to Baa3

Global Credit Research - 02 Mar 2017

New York, March 02, 2017 -- Moody's Investors Service, ("Moody's") downgraded Macy's, Inc., senior unsecured rating to Baa3. Its senior unsecured commercial paper rating was downgraded to P-3. The outlook was changed to stable from negative.

Christina Boni, VP Senior Analyst. "Weak 2016 holiday results highlight the need to accelerate efforts to stem market share erosion."

Date: Wed, March 01, 2017, 22:21
Posted by: Rich,

I Have to say it--- I do not trust red star-- They could arrange and agree with "partners" that the Walnut Room will remain -- and perhaps there could be a certain set of elevators that will take you to 7 for the Walnut room --- and that is the ONLY thing accessable on 7 --and perhaps the retail store is only lower level 1 - 3 and the Tiffany ceiling remains --also through special negotiation and accomadation in terms and agreements ---but above 3 - the building is then offices --or hotel--or condo's -- or whatever the "partners" see fit to do with it !!!I remain very concerned and worried about State Street -- Unfortunately it has been proven that red star does not have the ability --or vision--- to see WHAT Sate Street IS --or can be -- and they seem desperate at this point to commoditise all of their property----- Very concerning and Very scary!

Date: Mon, February 27, 2017, 19:41
Posted by: Natalie R,

NBC5 Chicago Reports:

Amid Speculation, Macy's Says Walnut Room is 'Staying'

No, the Walnut Room at Chicagos flagship Macys store isnt going anywhere, a company spokesperson said Monday, but questions surrounding the future of the State Street location remain unanswered.

Despite speculation on what might happen to the iconic restaurant following Macys announcement that it plans to downsize its Chicago location, spokesperson Andrea Schwartz said the company has no thoughts of closing our Walnut Room.


Date: Sat, February 25, 2017, 16:04
Posted by: Beth Walsh,

Do they not realize that the Walnut Room is the one thing that keeps even the Field's supporters coming into the store? I know I'm preaching to the choir, but could the execs at macy's seriously be that stupid or out of touch?

Date: Thurs, February 23, 2017, 22:50
Posted by: Paul Gambrowski,

Macy's State Street Flagiship Could Be Headed For A Big Downsizing


Last year, Macy's announced plans to close 100 stores nationwidean ongoing move that local Marshall Field's diehards championed at the time ...

Date: Thurs, February 23, 2017, 22:00
Posted by: dave andrews,

Sad news about the Walnut Room, but somehow not surprising. The comment "to keep the tradition of the Walnut Room" seems to imply the iconic eatery will not remain as is. The executives at macy care nothing about long term planning, just short term profits. It wouldn't be too far fetched for them to open a suburban chain type restaurant in the store and name it "The Walnut Room," perhaps throwing around a Marshall Fields few artifacts here and there.

Some may remember the famous Higbee's store at Tower City in downtown Cleveland. That iconic department store housed the popular Silver Grille. Higbee's was taken over by Dillard's, the store was downsized to five sales floors, and the tenth floor restaurant was closed. Fortunately the restaurant was not dismantled after it was shut down. Years later Dillard's pulled out of downtown Cleveland and the building subsequently was converted into a casino. The Silver Grille was beautifully refurbished but it is currently NOT open to the public; it is operated as a private banquet venue by the adjacent Ritz-Carlton Hotel.

Date: Thurs, February 23, 2017, 13:05
Posted by: Kathy Sue W,

Response at DNAinfo:

[Many of us already don't go or boycott, but] the Walnut Room is the only thing that keeps me coming back every Christmas. I absolutely love the room, the views, the ambiance (not so much that dumbass wine bar.) If they move the Walnut Room, or get rid of it, I won't go there anymore at all, I'll have no reason to.

Date: Thurs, February 23, 2017, 13:03
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Macy's won't confirm or deny that it will move the Walnut Room as part of a major redevelopment.

DNAinfo Chicago

Would you visit a Walnut Room II?

Is A Move Coming For Macy's Famed Walnut Room?

Macy's wants to redevelop the top of its State Street store, home to the old Marshall Field's holdover.

Date: Wed, February 22, 2017, 17:37
Posted by: dave andrews,

When will HE finally GO AWAY!!! The same marketing and retailing "genius" who destroyed cherished regional department stores now states that macy will transition away from coupons and gimmicks:

Wasn't HE the one who transitioned to the coupon and discount format in an attempt to recapture the customers who abandoned the New York store which replaced their favorite emporiums.

Why can't the analysts admit that his failed strategy caused the loss of hundreds of stores and thousands of jobs! Instead of publicizing his opinions on how macy can be profitable, analysts should hold him accountable for his arrogance and poor judgement. How about comparison of money saved on purchasing shopping bags to the money lost when shoppers abandoned the stores. How about salaries and tax revenues lost when stores closed. It has become painfully evident that shoppers don't want macy!

Indeed online shopping has had a significant impact on brick and mortar stores. One wonders if the situation would have been this drastic had HE not worked his "magic" in taking away what were once unique shopping venues.

Date: Wed, February 22, 2017, 00:25
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

I have said this before, they should re open the frangos kitchen on the upper floors ala willy wonka. It would be a huge traffic driver into 111 north stat

Date: Tues, February 21, 2017, 22:30
Posted by: Jim,


@Macys CEO Terry Lundgren on sale rumors:

Company will do 'the right thing for our shareholders'

He didn't rule out a deal...‬

Date: Tues, February 21, 2017, 19:01
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Crains Chicago Business has more extensive coverage. The comments are less than favorable. Sure, the upper floors aren't used, but office space is so mundane compared to what Macy's COULD do to increase business on State Street. These floors should be repurposed to drive traffic to this store so it is an international destination as it was when it was Marshall Field's. What sort of repurposes? A world class hotel, along with a department store museum. Everybody's wonky about their favorite deparment store. How about a world wide department store Mecca in the Marshall Field and Company Building which is the precedence for all other MODERN department stores world wide but especially in the UK, Europe, and North America. They want entertainment? That it would be, maximized in a world class department store known as Marshall Field's. (The casino proposed a few years back for the upper floors would be a bit over the top although it worked at Cleveland's former Higbees.)

Offices atop Macy's State Street flagship?

Date: Tues, February 21, 2017, 13:39
Posted by: mikea,

I did not hear the entire conference call and questions, but Macy's says they want to downsize State Street like they did in Seattle. how much can they downsize the store without loosing its character and customers, and appeal?

If they go below the 7th Floor the eateries and the Walnut Room will close. Without the Walnut Room and the tree they might as well close the store since that brings in the customer base for Christmas shopping season. They could move the offices from 11 to 8 and rent out floors 9-12. Floor 13 has no windows and would be hard to lease out. Since the building is landmarked I don't think the city would allow structural changes to it. Currently 9-10-12-13 are pretty much vacant and unused. Target tried to lease out space in the upper floors and could not do it yeas ago.

Still a merges or somewhat merger with Hudson's bay could happen and the Macy's Inc . plans would most likely change

Date: Tues, February 21, 2017, 10:29
Posted by: Jim McKay,

During the conference call, Macy's CFO says that State Street will be downsized similar to Seattle store where upper floors were redeveloped as office space.

Date: Tues, February 21, 2017, 09:59
Posted by: Jim McKay,

No, he's not gone 3/23. Am I missing it? Says nothing about when he will also step down as Chairman of the Board. Maybe after the May Stockhokder meeting? Listen for more information on real estate sales and other deals, senior management, etc. during the 9 AM conference call which you can listen to via the links from

Date: Sun, February 19, 2017, 17:41
Posted by: Mary Fordham,

We miss Marshall Field's so much. Macy's does not compare.

Date: Sun, February 19, 2017, 10:24
Posted by: Pete,

Was just reading through the Sunday papers. It sure seems like Macy's does a lot less advertising in the newspaper on Sundays. Maybe it's just that they advertise on the Internet more or on Thursday and Friday before the weekend. Or it could be that they're in trouble.

Date: Sat, February 18, 2017, 11:41
Posted by: Louis E,

A decade after homogenizing America's regional icons of department store retailing into a JC Penney clone with older buildings, it looks like Macy's, Inc. (really Federated without the federation aspect) looks like it may be folding into NRDC's Hudson's Bay Company operation.

I was grateful that Lord & Taylor,unlike Marshall Field's,was able to escape the Macification. After its sale to NRDC it was joined under NRDC control by Hudson's Bay and by Saks Fifth Avenue. I note that the L&T and Saks flagships just 11 blocks apart on

Fifth Avenue have not been merged into one brand,and I hope the Hudson's Bay 350th and Lord & Taylor 200th anniversaries in the next decade happen with operations still being carried on under those distinct nameplates.

Perhaps NRC/Hudson's Bay should be petitioned to "re-regionalize" Macy's if they buy it?...Strategic Marks pried loose a number of historic brands Lundgren's regime had abandoned, but others are still in the portfolio and could be reused,with Marshall Field's the best example.

I see former 40-year Marshall Field executive George G. Rinder died last April at 95...he may not have lived to see a rebirth but I guess other old employees survive.

Have members of the Marshall Field family (I know there's a Marshall Field VI, did he have a VII?) been involved in the movement to restore Marshall Field's?


The World Trade Center towers MUST rise again, at least as tall as before...or terror has triumphed.

Date: Sat, February 18, 2017, 11:03
Posted by: Melissa S,

From Houston:

Bring Back Marshall Field's & Selfridges Come Home To Chicago!

Date: Sat, February 18, 2017, 11:02
Posted by: Tony C,

Field's was the best. We loved it even here in West Virginia.

Date: Sat, February 18, 2017, 10:59
Posted by: Dorothy,

I grew up with Marshall Fields. Also from a town with many connections to the Marshall Field family. We miss Fields.

So dissatisfied with Macys!

Date: Wed, February 15, 2017, 16:04
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Macy's, Inc. (parent of Bloomingdale's, Macy's and Bluemercury) will have their 4th Q and year end 2016 conference call this Tuesday, February 21 at 9 a.m. Chicago time. You can listen by following the links from

There's a decent change that they will announce some deals perhaps even about the fate of State Street.

Date: Mon, February 13, 2017, 19:17
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Ralph Hughes, Macy's VP retired in the past year. Last Thursday, the Chicago Loop Alliance made him a Director Emeritus. Mr, Hughes came from Atlanta's Rich's and was at Marshall FIeld's in the early 1990s, and stayed into the Macyization.

While more than a couple Field's supporters sparred with him over the conversion to Macy's, more than a couple of former Field's employees have spoken warmly of working under his direction.

Based on last Thursday's presentation, it seems Mr. Hughes no longer lives in the Chicao area.


Date: Mon, February 13, 2017, 19:09
Posted by: Jim McKay,

A few more articles on the possibility -- or improbability -- of a Hudon's Bay Buyout of Macy's (including former Marshall Field's locations and Bloomingdale's).


A Hudson's Bay buyout of Macy's could end badly

If the owner of Saks acquires Macy's in a debt-heavy deal, it'd do about as much good as all those IOUs did Tribune when real estate mogul​ Sam Zell bought the media company in 2007.


Barron's, WSJ's sibling publication, has high hopes today for and acquisition by Hudson's Bay despite the fact that Macy's is much larger.

Macy's could be acquired by Hudson's Bay, retail expert Kniffen claims

Macy's shares could have 50% upside if it gets bought, Barron's said on Sunday.



Macys Could Have 50% Upside in a Sale

Investors have many ways to win with the beleaguered retailer, including a takeover and real estate spinoff.


Updated Feb. 11, 2017 2:01 a.m. ET

Macys is known for promoting marked-down merchandise with bright red tags. After...

(Even if you don't have paid access to Barron's, the comments after the article are interesting and accessible.)

Date: Mon, February 13, 2017, 19:03
Posted by: Michael D,

Department store restaurants: Marshall Fields

In 1890 Harry Gordon Selfridge, manager of Fields in Chicago, took the then-unusual step of persuading a middle-class woman to help with a new project at the

Continues at

Date: Sun, February 12, 2017, 16:59
Posted by: gle,

The Chicago History Book Discussion Group reviewed "The Marshall Fields" by Axel Madsen yesterday at Edgewater Library. Several participants were former Field's employees. Hearing their stories could have created another book. The group was very interested in the impending fate of the State Street store and also in what Field's Fans is doing. I never saw our buttons and leaflets disappear so fast. It was a great group of people. I hope we can meet again as customers of a restored Marshall Field's.

Date: Fri, February 10, 2017, 13:35
Posted by: mikea,

The future of retail is going down. Nordstrom sales down along with Sears almost ready to file chapter 11, Kohl's, JcPenney, Bon-Ton, Dillard's and of course Macy's.

The worrisome thing is that if Hudson's bay does somehow manage to leverage a Macy's buyout, the State Street store will be very vulnerable. Even if the activist investors take control, I fear for State Street. I do not know how the building can be preserved if it is turned into a office/residential use. The floor spaces are very large and expansive with limited windows that would make it difficult for a hotel or residential units. Also since the building is landmarked , I don't think they could change the exterior of it or add floors to the top of it.

Hudsons' bay stores are very nice kinda like a upscale Macy's or similar to Macy's best stores In fact in 2012 the Toronto flagship sold green dog, first impressions , style & co, INC, Hotel to name a few Macy's brands. They are so similar that images show Hudson's bay stores having a clearance area like Last Act in Macy stores.

I heard a commercial that now Last Act is going to carry home items, maybe <Macy's should just bring back the bargain basement that they got rid of in the 70's.

Date: Fri, February 10, 2017, 12:43
Posted by: Jimmy gimbels,

Hello everyone. Let's get into the way back machine and travel back to those days when the wacky folks at Macy's said Marshall Field "failed" because they were too. promotional. Back to today, Macy's has a "one day sale" every weekend, the sales really run for three days (huh?) and lots of mailings. And still their business continues to sink.

True story

I was in one of the newer Macy's stores to return a gift. Outside of cosmetics ( who will not assist with general merchandise), I walked the entire store and could not locate a single sales person. Nice! So I went to the executive offices for help. The woman at desk said I was lying. So I challenged her to find someone to process the return. She couldn't. Macy's had an entire store void of sales help. The few people scheduled all went to lunch. Good employee management.

Date: Wed, February 08, 2017, 22:19
Posted by: Arnie. ,

NY Jewish Voice article on the possible deal, its rationale....

Date: Wed, February 08, 2017, 22:07
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Another bit of info from Andy Brownfield and the Cincinnati Business Courier. Here is what Macy's senior execs make if they sell Macy's Inc.

Terry Lundgren, CEO:$80 million

Karen Hoguet, chief financial officer:$15 million

Jeff Gennette, president:$12 million

Jeffrey Kantor, chief stores and human resources officer:$14 million

Date: Mon, February 06, 2017, 20:44
Posted by: Facebooker,

I cannot wrap my head around this relatively speaking tiny company buying a giant company. Even though this is a much different scenario, I'm frighteningly reminded of KMart buying Sears. And as far as Macy's highly valuable real estate, I always shake my head because in most cases, who else wants it? There's no line of department stores waiting to take their vacated spaces. Apparently mall owners are still willing to pay high just to acquire the land and knock the facilities down and start over; a lot like buying a 50's ranch home only to knock it down and replace it with a McMansion.

Date: Mon, February 06, 2017, 20:40
Posted by: James M,

A Bloomberg article republished in Crains Chciago. This one's not that cheery. HBC doesn't have to be the only solution...

Macy's takeover by Hudson's Bay would end retail star

Visit Crain's Chicago Business for complete business news and analysis including healthcare, real estate, manufacturing, government, sports and more.


Date: Mon, February 06, 2017, 20:38
Posted by: Chris R,

TJ Maxx could buy just to get access to Macy's clearance items for TJ Maxx. But just maybe TJ Maxx would sell Bloomingdale's and Field's to Selfridge. Selfridge runs Primark too.

Date: Mon, February 06, 2017, 20:38
Posted by: Sara B,

I dont agree. Hudson Bay has largely gone down hill in recent years. The Toronto store might be an exception. Let them but all of Macys including the old Daytons and Hudsons. Doesnt anyone remember that D-H dragged Fields down? Let Hudson Bay take all of the Macys and Hudsons and Daytons and let someone else have Fields be a stand alone store.

Date: Mon, February 06, 2017, 20:37
Posted by: Susan C,

Just buy the Marshall Field's and Dayton Hudson stores and leave Macy's with everything else.

Date: Mon, February 06, 2017, 20:37
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Barron's is a respected sister publication of The Wall Street Journal.

Macys: Too Big To Swallow?

Last week, news broke that Macy's (M) has begun takeover talks with Hudson's Bay, helping to send its shares up 6.4%. At the time, Cowen's Oliver Chen concluded that "a deal would be difficult," though Stifel's Richard Jaffe wrote that "crazier things


Date: Sun, February 05, 2017, 15:10
Posted by: gle,

Everything is happening so fast it is nail-biting. I would so love to see the State Street store purchased by someone who values Marshall Field's in quality and service, and is willing to restore it.

Date: Sun, February 05, 2017, 10:37
Posted by: Jim,

ICYMI: From Andy Brownfield's column in the Cincinnati Business Courier:

A @Macys competitor made a takeover bid today that temporarily halted the stock's trading


Date: Sun, February 05, 2017, 00:27
Posted by: Alfred,

The New York Times story on Hudson's Bay and Macy's deal:

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 16:57
Posted by: Susan C,

Seeing Marshall Field's State Street back in-operation would be truly wonderful.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 16:51
Posted by: Jim McKay,

In response to my earlier question, Jerry Storch is the person I was looking for. Check out the link below.

Storch is CEO of HBC. He was with Target where, for part of that time, he headed Dayton's/Hudson's*/Marshall Field's. (*Note that Hudsons Bay and Hudson's are two completely different entities that have never had a relationship.) Also note towards the bottom of this page where they describe HBC's stores. In terms of sheer numbers of stores, the combined number of Hudsons Bay, Lord and Taylor, Saks Fifth Avenue, and outlet stores are less the size of Bon Ton (Parent of Carson Pirie Scott, among others). In other words, Hudsons Bay is about 1/3 to 1/2 the size of Macy's/Bloomingdale's. I'm curious as to when Jerry Storch was heading Target's department store division and if it was when they started emulating Selfridge's (real high point) or when it was controversial like around 1990 when they introduced to Brown Marshall Field and Company bags. Another article I can't find seems to suggest a Terry Lundgren and others will get a huge package deal if they exit Macy's at this time. If you find out her article, please post.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 15:26
Posted by: Timothy E,

I always appreciated Field's demographic approach of marketing to the up-scale crowd, but also to the (much larger) 'aspirational' crowd - those who aspire to luxury and affluence. Upon first arriving in Chicago in the 1850's, Marshall Field himself, under the tutelage of Potter Palmer, quickly recognized the social and material aspirations of the ladies of Chicago who wished for a lifestyle that was significantly above that of a muddy western 'cow town.' By catering to that yearning for elegance, Field was able to successfully grow his firm into a retail - and cultural - force to be reckoned with. It's time to take that approach again, by creating an over-all retail experience that flatters the aspirations of the Chicago consumer.


The merchandising approach is to showcase the high-end merchandise, but then to also have available similar items of high quality but at a significantly more 'modest' price (the secret of Field's various house brands). Provide good value to the aspirational customer by making available well-designed quality goods at an affordable price.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 15:23
Posted by: Jim McKay,

You have to wonder what the general price point would be for a revived Field's under either HBC or Selfridges/Weston.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:51
Posted by: Frank F,

The Bay in downtown Toronto has all been updated and very upscale.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:49
Posted by: Timothy E,

So long as they restore Marshall Field's to 111 N. State - in name, quality, ethos, and service - I'm all for a Weston / Selfridge's buy-out.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:48
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Some have been asking about Hudson's Bay Company(HBC). Here is a link to the corporate site. If you shop at Lord and Taylor, Sak's Fifth Avenue or Sak's Off Fifth, you already shop HBC. If you have a Lord and Taylor credit card (like I do) or a Sak's credit card, you already have a credit card that's good at Hudson's Bay department stores in Canada. In fact, the Hudson's Bay logo appears on the back of the credit cards I mentioned if you received the card in the past couple of years. I have never been a to Hudson's Bay store--perhaps some of you here can comment and confirm your impressions. Sometimes I hear people say that Hudson's Bay stores are like Canada's version of Macy's. I've heard others say that the flagship store is gorgeous and shared with a new Sak's. I understand that one of the most senior execs with HBC is a former Marshall Field exec who is familiar with State Street. I would love to hear your impressions of all this. One piece of information that is interesting is that while HBC also has a significant real estate investment trust (REIT), HBC is also significantly smaller that Macy's/Bloomingdale's/Bluemercury which may complicate a merger. I look forward to comments about your first-hand experiences with HBC.


Selfridges Group is another department store operator that Field's Fans have expressed support for Field's stewardship. It not only operates Selfridges in London but other stores in the UK, Europe, and Canada. What impresses me is how much they try to retain and restore the ethos of the historic department stores of which they take stewardship. The company is largely controlled by Galen Weston Limited of Toronto which also owns Loblaws, Canada's largest grocer. You know Loblaws if you remember National Tea grocery stores which was based here in Chicago and then Rosemont until about 20-25 years ago. So the family that effectively "owns" Selfridges actually is familiar with Chicago and Field's. Here's a link to Selfridges Group:


And here's the site for for Galen Weston Limited:

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:47
Posted by: James P,

They'd be wise to spin off a portion of what was the Dayton/ Hudson/ MF division and let it RE-evolve into something better.

- Restore Burdines to FL

- Restore Richs to Atlanta.

Those are at least areas they can grow brand identity beyond Macy's.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:46
Posted by: Timothy N,

HBC has shown success in running big city flagships. And having no decent mid-,to upper-range department stores here in the Pac NW, I shop L&T online constantly. One part that concerns me is the size of this take over and if HBC can manage it.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:46
Posted by: James P,

Hopefully this starts the process to restore Marshall field's to Chicago!

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:46
Posted by: Steve G,

Macy's shares reopen, surging more than 6 percent, after report that Hudson's Bay may bid for the company

Macy's shares surged more than 6 percent, after being briefly halted, as takeover



Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:44
Posted by: Susan C,

Macy's Receives Takeover Approach From Hudson's Bay

Canadas Hudsons Bay has approached Macys about a takeover, people familiar with the matter said, as the biggest U.S. department-store chain grapples with disappointing results and restive shareholders. Continues...

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:44
Posted by: James J,

Hudsons Bay owns Saks fifth Avenue and Lord and Taylor. One of their top two or three executives is a former senior executive with Marshall Field and Company.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:43
Posted by: Jennifer J,

Hhhhmmmm... Hudson's Bay???

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:43
Posted by: Timothy E,

Well, let's pool our pennies...;-)

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:43
Posted by: James M,

Another thorough story by Andy Brownfield.

Macy's is looking for a buyer, report says - Cincinnati Business Courier

Cincinnati-based retail giant Macy's Inc. could be shopping around for a buyer, according to a published report.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:42
Posted by: James M,

This was a big topic of discussion five years ago here.

J.C. Penney, Macy's end 5-year feud over selling Martha Stewart products - Dallas Business Journal

J.C. Penney and Macy's were granted dismissal this week of a lawsuit that claimed J.C. Penney violatedcontinues...

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:41
Posted by: Rich W,

Prediction: Hudsons Bay Will Try To Buy Macys in 2016


Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:41
Posted by: Rich W,

I recall reading about a year ago how Hudson Bay had an eye on Macy's because they felt the Herald Square location had an understated value, making the chain an attractive buy.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:40
Posted by: James M,

If Terry Lundgren wanted Marshall Field's to survive as part of the deal, my opinion is that he probably would not have done a deal with Frango. Still, let's fight the fight to bring back Marshall Field and company.

Also, another inside track for Hudson Bay is that it has sold some of Macy's private brands in the past.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:39
Posted by: Rich W,

Wonder if Hudson Bay will make an offer

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:39
Posted by: Jim M,

Macy's shares jump after report says CEO seeking buyer

Departing Macy's CEO Terry Lundgren is open to offers in an attempt to avoid a board shakeup that could stain his legacy, the New York Post reports.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:38
Posted by: Jim M,

BATUS owned Gimbels, Saks, and Field's in the 1980s. They closed Gimbels in the 1980s and then sold off Saks and Field's by the end of the decade.

Carson's became part of Sak's Norther Department Store Group. Then Saks became Profitts and then the two separated with Dillard's acquiring a lot of Profitts but Parisian stores in Detroit went to Bon-Ton with the rest of the Northern Departement Stores Group...golly, I'm losing track...

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:35
Posted by: Aaron M.,

Saks was a stand-alone company at the time, and they purchased Proffitt's, the parent company of Carson's at the time (within the last 20 years or so).

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:34
Posted by: Susan C,

The sale to Carson's must have happened a long time ago because at one point in time BATUS owned Sak's

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:34
Posted by: Jim M,

HBC has Sak's on Michigan Avenue. (I am underwhelmed by the architecture of that store.) One rumor I heard a couple years ago was that they would like all the Chicagoland Lord and Taylor stores branded as Sak's. I even heard a rumor that HBC would lease the Marshall Fields name and use it for their Lord and Taylor and Sak's stores in Chicago. Sounds crazy--but too complicated to explain here in Facebook.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:33
Posted by: Aaron M.,

HB lost out on it's Water Tower Place Lord and Taylor (I realize this is way oversimplified), so they would probably love to get a footprint in the city.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:32
Posted by: James McKay,

Barbara: that would be interesting. Hudson's Bay and Selfridges are huge rivals in Canada right now. Selfridge's operates Holt Renfrew. personally, I think would be a great thing if Hudson Bay ended up with Macy's and Selfridges ended up with the A list locations of Field's plus Bloomingdale's. [ According to what I have read, Hudson's Bay is much smaller than Macy's/Bloomingdale's.]

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:32
Posted by: Barbara J,

If Hudsons Bay becomes the new owner, perhaps the selling off of Fields will make some sense to them.

Date: Sat, February 04, 2017, 13:31
Posted by: Jim,

Based on my study of the building and some media stories, I think State Street will continue to have a major department store but it will be reduced to the State Street side and go up to the 8th floor. Wabash side will be used tor other purposes, with one room on the main floor used as a lobby to all the other floors, especially floors 9 and up which would belong to someone else, including the State Street side. But the building has maximum value when it is connected with Marshall Field's.

Date: Fri, February 03, 2017, 12:57
Posted by: Carolyn Cullen,

Maybe there is another chance, for Hudson's Bay to do the right thing and bring back Marshall Field's?

Date: Thurs, February 02, 2017, 13:24
Posted by: mikea,

The whole problem with Macy's is their stock shot up way high in 2015 and the activist investors made a poor decision to jump onboard. They now want t heir money and do not care if the company is forced to liquidate all of their properties and go out of business. They have no caring for any of the operations let alone the names of the regional stores and of course the CUSTOMERS!!!!

Looking back in the 80's that is the reason why MF&CO sold out to BAtus activist investors out for short term profits which sold it to Dayton/Hudson to May to FDS.

Maybe Bloomingdale's might be sold first and then Macy's. Also The Gap on State Street is closing this month. It seems so many retailers are having problems, especially the mall stores. Off Price TJX Companies are doing very well. They have a surprise format in their stores. The worst that could possibly happen would be for the activist investors to get seats on the board and force the company to sell off State Street and the store portfolio. GREED AT ITS WORST

Date: Thurs, February 02, 2017, 10:14
Posted by: James M,

Macy's Jumps On Talk Of PE-Structured Real Estate Deal

Another story. Yes, we have contacted all of Starboards execs to remind them that State Street's value is maximized when the store is reunited with the Marshall Field's name.

Date: Thurs, February 02, 2017, 10:11
Posted by: Aaron M,

[ BTW:

These are the poll results form the story just cited:

Do you agree that much of Macys recent struggles can be linked to the companys decision to consolidate regional nameplates under one national banner?

Strongly agree (57% Votes)

Somewhat agree (20% Votes)

Somewhat disagree (7% Votes)

Strongly disagree (9% Votes)

Not sure/no opinion (7% Votes)


Date: Thurs, February 02, 2017, 10:10
Posted by: Aaron M,


(Field's gets mentioned in the article.

Should Macys have never gone national? RetailWire

Date: Thurs, February 02, 2017, 10:08
Posted by: Jim McKay,

YouGov Article | Macy's hits eight-year perception low

"Macys hit its lowest consumer perception score in eight years in the middle of January, the result of a sharp drop right after New Years Day..."

(YouGov is a regarded pollster which I believe is based in the UK.)

Date: Thurs, February 02, 2017, 10:07
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Aaron Mosesbro, Michael Russell Totally agree. I think this is make or break time. We did contact some of the activist investors and are making attempts again now. All they care about is money but there are a couple of parties I'm thinking of -- Selfridges Group (for reasons we have discussed) and Hudson's Bay as well (who would be good stewards).

Hudson's Bay, owner of Sak's and Lord and Taylor, has a former senior Marshall Field's exec in one of the top positions. Selfridges Group operates Holt's in Canada.

Contributing to all the uncertainty is the tumultuous US political circumstances are making it idea for something bad (or good) to happen because politics, not stores are not a central focus these days.

Date: Thurs, February 02, 2017, 10:04
Posted by: Aaron M,

Those activist investors are really just looking to sell off the property and earn a tidy sum. They care not about Macy's, much less Marshall Field and Company. Correct me if I'm wrong.

Date: Thurs, February 02, 2017, 10:04
Posted by: Michael R,

It will be interesting to see if Lundgren is forced to step down or if he tries to sell the company and steps down to preserve his "legacy".

Date: Thurs, February 02, 2017, 10:03
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Do keep in mind that Terry Lundgren will still be chairman of the board until further notice. So he will still have a role in Macy's and Bloomingdale's operations.

Date: Thurs, February 02, 2017, 10:02
Posted by: Kevin H,

New York Post

Macys sale rumored as long-time CEO steps down

By Lisa Fickenscher, Josh Kosman and Claire Atkinson February 1, 2017 | 10:33pm

Date: Thurs, February 02, 2017, 10:00
Posted by: Jim McKay,


Some of our regulars now prefer to post at our Facebook group. Whenever it seems to translate well to this forum, those Facebook posts will be cross-posted here. The posts here will show the poster's first name and last initial. The time stamp here may be the time it first was crossposted here rather than its original Facebook time stamp.

As always, those Facebook posts remain solely the opinion of the original poster on Facebook, are presented for discussion and even disagreement and request for correction by anyone who might read the post. The posts do not necessarily represent the opinion of those who operate

Thank you.


Date: Wed, February 01, 2017, 02:03
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

Selling frangos makes no sense the sales price is a fraction of Macy's problems. Plus they just gave away a very good private brand.

This only makes sense if Macy's is getting ready to shut down

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 4:14 pm Ct
Posted by: dave andrews,

Just as selling off the Craftsman brand is one less reason to bother going to what's left of Sears, getting rid of Frango is one less reason to bother going to what remains of Marshall Field's. The major issues are quality and distribution. The Craftsman tools sold at Sears today are nowhere near what were sold there years ago; one wonders about the Craftsman tools which will be made by Black & Decker. With no quality control or standardization, the name will surely mean nothing. In fact, many tool buyers have found better items at Lowe's or Home Depot and have totally abandoned Craftsman. In many cases, the husband might go to Sears specifically to look at tools while the wife and children would come along to purchase other items.

The fine quality of Frango has declined greatly since macy took over. One wonders if the new owners will make the brand into a "commodity" which will sold everywhere and no longer anything special. Just like macy did to the stores it took over. There's not much reason to shop at macy now, the mass production and distribution of Frangos will make them available at Walgreens and the neighborhood grocery store.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 3:57 pm Ct
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Re Dave Andrews:

The reporter who wrote the story you cite does a really fair and balanced job of covering Macy's, Field's, etc.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 3:2 pm CT
Posted by: dave andrews,

Seems that macy is becoming more like Sears as stores and other assets are sold off. After iconic stores have been destroyed, the few remaining valuable brands are sold to raise money:

Perhaps the Frango brand isn't worth much since Marshall Field's is no longer in existence--and who deserves the blame for that! Hard to believe the board of directors would allow one egomaniac "genius" to make such poor decisions.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 2:02 pm CT
Posted by: David H,

Garrett's has stores in like 10 countries

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 2:00 pm CT
Posted by: Michael D.,

Haven't seen a price mentioned. And I wonder for how long Macy's will carry Frangos (and whether it's part of the contract. ) And most importantly will Macy's continue to offer it on sale every other week!?

Didn't realize only some Macy stores sold. Guessing where MF, BM and Ohio stores, where they sold before.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 1:22 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Michael R:

Agreed. The Segment on 780/105.9 that just aired interviewed a food marketing expert from L.A. I was skeptical at first but he turned out to be very astute. He totally "got" the Marshall Field's and Frango brand, pointed out that MF&Co did a much better job of promoting Frango and then said that this seemed as if Macy's was starting a firesale.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 1:21 pm CT
Posted by: Michael R,

Jim H,: as long as the quality was the same.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 1:21 pm CT
Posted by: Jim H.,

Sears was known for Craftsman tools, while Marshall Field's had Field Gear. At a bare bones minimum, it would not be ideal, but it would be "ok" if I could buy Field Gear clothes again - regardless of who owns the brand.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 1:20 pm CT
Posted by: Michael R,

They are selling things off like Sears. They'll never be able to sell off their house brands though..........nobody wants that crap! I am wearing a Field Gear Cashmere sweater today!!!!!! Jealous?

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 1:20 pm CT
Posted by: Mike P,

I believe Garrett's is a Chicago company....and I don't think that they have too much of a reach outside the Chicago area. This potentially extends the brand outside the area...and perhaps also brings Garrett's to places like the West Coast.

Far as MF&CO? I like to think that Garrett's is keeping it local and if our beloved MF&CO comes back, perhaps Garrett.s can be a part of that.Exactly. Good for Frangos, per se; not so good for M.F. & Co.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 1:19 pm CT
Posted by: Timothy E,

Exactly. Good for Frangos, per se; not so good for M.F. & Co.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 1:19 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

I think you are right, Timothy Eischen. If Frangos everywhere, why special? On the other hand, we tend to forget that Frangos have been sold in the Pacific Northwest as well all these years. I have heard that Garrett's owners are good.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 1:19 pm CT
Posted by: Timothy E,

Potentially good for the Frango 'brand'; not good news for the future return of Marshall Field's.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 12:59 pm CT
Posted by: Chris R,

So sad. And Field's could come back. As some have pointed out, cars have come back. Stores have come back. They are trying to separate State Street from the Field's legacy.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 12:59 pm CT
Posted by: Michael T,

And so Macy's follows the path of Sears...

Sad sad sad.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 12:58 pm CT
Posted by: Sara B,

Anyone who thinks this is a good thing for Chicago is seriously misguided. Macy's is setting things up so Marshall Field's does not come back in any recognizable form. No, it's not awesome. It's a tragedy.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 12:58 pm CT
Posted by: John K,

Haven't set foot in a Macy since the takeover. Just think that this might be an opportunity for someone to pick up the MAFCO tm and run with it.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 13:57
Posted by: Marty B,

Reminds me of Sears selling off their assets such as Craftman and Kenmore.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 12:57 pm CT
Posted by: Kathy Sue W,

I'm not sure how I feel about this. I think I will have to wait and see what exactly they do with it.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 12:54 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Please go to the original articles and try to leave comments.

Marketwatch on the sale of Frango to Garrett's

And perhaps the most thorough -- via the Chicago Tribune:

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 12:48 pm CT
Posted by: mikea,

This latest announcement by Macy's is probably the road of one of two things for the company

1) selling off assets real estate and closing stores to make the company more attractable for sale

2) enable the company to go private

If bloomingdale's is sold or spun off then for sure the company will go private or a buyer is in the works.

They are trying to raise cash in a big way.

Frangos will now be sold in the Garrett shops, but now maybe at higher prices which can in turn hurt Macy's sales and the affordable for customers.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 12:41 pm CT
Posted by: Eric B,

The one positive aspect of Garrett buying Frango is that it returns the brand to local ownership. Otherwise, this smacks of Sears selling the Kenmore brand, which amounts to buying a little more time to keep a doomed company afloat.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 11:29 am CT
Posted by: Anna,

Sickening to watch Macy's dismantle the very valuable and much beloved Field's brand by selling off Frango's. A Travesty.

Date: Mon, January 30, 2017, 8:06 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Not good at all. Means less of a reason to ever shop these stores. Sadly, I believe this is one of the first moves of the new CEO. Basically dismantling Field's. Will you be ready to picket when they attempt to close State Street?

Date: Fri, January 27, 2017, 4:44 am CT
Posted by: Pete,

Put Marshall Field's in Bloomingdale's locations?


Bring back Field's to State Street, Water Tower, Old Orchard, Oak Brook, Orland Park.

Date: Thu, January 26, 2017, 11:30 pm CT
Posted by: Rich Ionozze,

I have not posted in a L O N G Time -- But STILL with the cause !!!!

Every time I visited a red-star store over the holidays (not to purchase--just as a walk through to the rest of the mall)- I put a card into Santa's mailbox saying "Please bring back Marshall Field's"

This article was interesting -- I read it today --

Pretty much it states what we all already know and understood 11 years ago when this whole debacle of the destruction of the local stores and the wonton dismantling and destruction of Field's occurred -- they probably could have asked ANY of us at that time and we could have told them the problems that would develop- it is NOT ok - but what is there to do about it ??? we can only do what we have been doing and perhaps someone in power will realise the way forward (red star STILL Owns dozens of nameplates and rights to those names and can potentially use them --- they would need to un-do the dismantling--I don't believe they know how - or would want to - even with a sinking ship----

Truly a sad situation and a mess

Date: Thurs, January 26, 2017, 3:29 am CT
Posted by: Mary Ellen Connor,

Exhilarating to read that the fight continues for Marshall Field's. I saw this link after the Crain's Chicago article. I really agree with the counter opinion that mentioned this site.

Below, the person who is Mike, who focuses on Fox Valley and saying that Marshall Field's should move into the old Bloomingdale's locations doesn't really know much. (Maybe they are a former Macy's employee?) The Water Tower Place and State Street stores are so intertwined with Marshall Field and Company brand experience. Putting Marshall Field's in the Bloomingdale store would just make things worse. It's the same kind of crazy Macy's thinking that had us lose Marshall Field's in the first place. I'm sure Macy's insists on having a Michigan Avenue store. Let them move Macy's into Bloomingdale's on N. Michigan Ave. and have a home store over at Wabash Avenue. I don't think people are so concerned at all about what happened at Fox Valley.

All the horrible things happening in our world, bringing back Marshall Field's would be a sweet respite.

Mary Ellen

Date: Wed, January 25, 2017, 5:47 pm CT
Posted by: Robert ,

Mikea I'm glad to hear you say that Marshall Fields should be brought back to Chicago. However it MUST come back to its state street flagship. The Fields brand and that location go hand and hand. Other current bloomingdales or macy's locations can follow but if it doesn't came back to state street I don't see the point of bringing it back.I would love to see MF back at Old Orchard and Oakbrook as well!!!

Date: Wed, January 25, 2017, 2:57 pm CT
Posted by: David S,

I can't help but be moved today by the passing of Mary Tyler Moore, who threw up her hat in front of the Dayton's Flagship, later Marshall Fields in Downtown Minneapolis.

I'm sure everyone knows the Dayton's Flagship is in the process of being closed, and now the iconic store and the person who gave it visibility to the whole country is gone as well......

A Sad Day

Date: Wed, January 25, 2017, 12:59 pm CT
Posted by: mikea,

I agree with the Crain's author somewhat. Macy's big mistake was to end their service departments ie gift wrap close in store eateries ie Old orchard Fox Valley. They also stopped the localization program of my macy's in favor of a more amazon like approach which is failing.

They could have expanded their my macy's program more and made the flagship stores take on the flavor of the regional stores they once were even co naming them. Instead they closed some and shrunk others only to retreat and take the real estate value and alienate the customers.

Macy's should in Chicago close the three bloomingdale's stores, they are empty and a waste on the company. They should be rebranded Marshall Field's and run by Bloomingdale's. Maybe Macy's should split off blomingdales' or sell them.

They do not even respond to their online tell us what you think anymore. It just shows they no longer care for the customers.

Date: Tues, January 24, 2017, 3:13 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Crain's Chicago Business is reprinting an opinion piece that originally ran in Advertising Age. It is by Rance Crain, president of Crains Communication and editor-in-chief of from Advertising Age. If you have Crains login, please consider leaving your comments afterwards or even submitting a letter to the editor at,

January 24, 2017


The demise of the department store experience

Comments Email Print


My response:

"Regarding the Marshall Field's brand and experience, at the time of the Federated/Macy's-May Department Stores merger, their own official SEC 10K filings listed Marshall Field's tradenames as $419M. At that same time, Macy's/Bloomingdale's tradenames were valued at $377M. (Yes, less.) A dozen other department store tradenames, including Lord and Taylor, Filene's, Hecht's, Famous Barr, and others had a COMBINED value of less than $190M. 5-8 years ago, the grass roots group, Field'sFansChicago surveyed 2,300 Michigan Avenue and State Street shoppers. Surveys consistently showed 78%-80% -- about 4 out of 5 -- preferred Marshall Field's over Macy's and wanted it to return to the two tourist shopping destinations and shopped Macy's less. When Macy's says that Marshall Field's was losing money, that division included about 40 out of 62 stores which were Dayton's and Hudson's stores. (Target still owns those two store names.). Of about 10 stores closed by Macy's in the former Dayton's/Hudson's/Field's division, only Lake Forest and Bloomingdale/Stratford were Marshall Field's stores in 2001. The rest were Dayton's or Hudson's--those stores were doing poorly and among recent closures. Stockholder reps from Field's Fans Chicago have spoken at the conclusion of annual Macy's stockholder meetings in Cincinnati every year since 2008. After speaking, other stockholders have responded to FieldsFansChicago that they agree, that they think it's been a mistake to get rid of Marshall Field's at key Chicago locations and/or that Field's would have been a stronger brand in Chicago than Bloomingdale's. Support for the Field's brand and experience continues to be very strong. A few weeks ago during the holidays, Close to 250 posed for photos pleading for Field's return to State Street. This is documented in about 200 of these photos which can be viewed at Shoppers and stockholders aren't asking to have all 20 Marshall Field's stores to come back. They probably overbuilt in the 1980s. But it makes so much sense from the perspective of stockholders, shoppers, and even tax payers who could realize greater sales taxes to restore Marshall Field's in name AND EXPERIENCE to at least State Street. Perhaps a few other locations like Old Orchard, Water Tower, Oak Brook, Woodfield, Mayfair should also be considered for restoration to the Field's brand and experience. And no, it shoudn't be co-branding--"Marshall Field's by Macy's" would sounds as great as "Cadillac by Chevy." If there's not enough room in Chicago for Bloomies, Field's, and Macy's, they should make Bloomingdale's Michigan Avenue Macy's and restore Field's to it's former location. Bloomingdale's is really just regional, doing best in the Northeast, Florida and California."

Date: Fri, January 20, 2017, 14:03
Posted by: mikea,

I agree with Tim's post. Department stores need to stop chasing Amazon. Macy's especially thinks this. In the last two years their my macy's localization program has fallen apart in favor a more amazon like approach. Instead of closing the profitable downtown stores, they should have capitalized on them for more localization in merchandise and promotions. Pittsburgh, Portland and Minneapolis are cities with a rising downtown office and resident populations.

The stores can keep the Macy's name, but change the merchandise to reflect local flavor, tastes, traditions, the regional stores had.

it is still not to late to do that to STATE STREET, Water Tower, Seattle, Miami, Boston, and San Francisco. The stores all cannot be alike.

They need new management that understands that localization will differentiate them from online retailers and bring customers back to them as destination stores. Stop cutting back on promotions events ie Glamoarama, departments, staffing just to save money and think the customers won't notice.

Date: Tues, January 17, 2017, 6:35 pm CT
Posted by: Authored by Tim Parry on Linked In ,

Department Stores Need to Stop Chasing Amazon and Become Destinations Again

Date: Sun, January 15, 2017, 11:11 pm CT
Posted by: Sarah W,

All those photos are amazing! Macy's continue to ignore?????

Date: Sat, January 14, 2017, 5:39 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,

To follow up on and thank Dave's post from yesterday:

Since before the takeover of Field's, Sachse was one of Terry Lungren's closest, and a huge supporter of Macyization of everything including Field's. In one sense it could be a good sign; yet, there's an unknown quantity with Gennette who becomes Macy's CEO in February. Lundgren is slated to still continue as Chairman of the Board after that. Regardless, I will be at the stockholders meeting on Friday, May 19, 2017 to stand up for Marshall Field and Company.

Here's another couple of more links to typically decent sources to more information:


Macy's fires top executive in charge of growth

Struggling department store operator Macy's said Friday that it has fired its chief growth officer Peter Sachse.

The Street

Date: Fri, January 13, 2017, 5:17 pm CT
Posted by: dave andrews,

So it appears that macy identified a scapegoat for declining sales:

Again, the REAL culprit still occupies his seat in the executive suite. Had there been some oversight or HONEST market research 10 years ago, one wonders how many of the 200 plus shuttered stores would still be operating and how many of the thousands of laid off employees would still have a job. Granted, online shopping and declining mall locations would have necessitated SOME store closures but not to the magnitude seen the past few years. How many successful stores rapidly lost business and went downhill once converted to macy? Guess a vintage holiday movie and red stars everywhere didn't equate to retail success.

Date: Tues, January 10, 2017, 1:26 pm CT
Posted by: mikea,

I agree with Dave's post . Macy's big problem is lack of leadership and cost cutting. Before FDs bought May Company, Macy's was a great store with great values, merchandise and traditions. Even the first few years after absorbing MAY THEY WERE GOOD< HOWEVER THEY BROUGHT IN SOME OF THE CHEAP TACKY May merchandise and that brought down the quality.

The last two to three years the bottom is falling out. Constant cost cutting with staff and confusing sales and deals, lack of merchandise that is special, merchandise that the web says is at a store and then is not there. not only does this confuse the customers, but the associates too.

What does Macy's Inc do fire another 6,000 managers planners, buyers and back office support people. Do they actually think that service and sales will not suffer. I cannot believe they had 6,000 useless people working at the company. Still they do this after two to three years of cost cutting in staff. The real problem is the top executives and executive committee. However like all US companies those at the top responsible for a company's performance never take the blame only those who do the actual work.

Macy's needs new leadership and goals, continued store closings unless it is a dead or dying location and layoffs will not solve the core problems!!!!!!!!!!!

Date: Mon, January 09, 2017, 10:49 pm CT
Posted by: dave andrews,

This analyst calls out macy for lack of leadership:

Not only is macy lacking in creativity and innovation, they have destroyed valued services and traditions offered by the department stores they consumed. Simply stated, there is NO compelling reason to visit a macy store--nothing special, same old same old, nondescript. Closing stores will not solve the problem of declining sales and decreasing stock values; the cause of the problem must be addressed and corrected. Perhaps the NEW leadership will look back at what was successful and give the shoppers what they want! Ten years later and macy is still an epic fail.

Date: Mon, January 09, 2017, 3:03 am CT
Posted by: Phil Eichler,


You are correct, the carsons store at Springhill was built as a prototype chas weisse store and is a real step from Fields.

Date: Fri, January 06, 2017, 5:37 pm CT
Posted by: Pete,

I mostly agree with Phil. I also think Joliet is a closure candidate. The fixtures and store is in bad shape, not to mention in 1980s mauve/dusty pink in places. It hasn't been remodeled in a while. Then again, I haven't been in there a while. Spring Hill is a troubled mall. They better do something. The now-Macy's is actually kind of old, opened in 1980/81 as Field's. 36 years ago or so. The Carson's there is actually nicer than Field's/Macy's. The stores have moved around there, but if I recall correctly, it was originally P.A. Bergner/Weisse. It's still a nicer store than Macy's. JCPenney pulled out a couple of years ago. I see Macy's pulling out of SPring Hill, just my opinion as a customer.

Date: Thurs, January 05, 2017, 8:31 pm, CT
Posted by: mikea,

Once again Macy's is thinking shortsighted. Closing of the downtown Minneapolis store may bring in short term revenue, but at what cost. Consider the goodwill and customers they will loose from the closing.

Some of the store closings ie Eastland Mission Valley are in dead malls and need to be closed. I was surprised to See River Oaks, Horton PLaza and Glenbrook not on the list.

Also the announcement of many management positions being eliminated, is this going to mean even less customer service!!!! Also what about merchandising is this going to mean more just hohum basic stock merchandise that seems to have permenated the stores in the last two years.

The first years Macy's performed well good merchandise at good pricing, however ever since they became investment grade and the investor activists have taken over, the company is spirling downward.

Sales are not even real sales anymore just trying to confuse customers, Decorations and events in the stores are going downward, merchandise is becoming very basic no pizazzz etc. The company needs to be sold and taken private. Bloomingdale's needs to be spun off and sold. Bluemercury was a big mistake for the company. The investor activists need to be disposed of or the company will continue to downward slide and be liquidated in 10 years or less.

Date: Wed, January 04, 2017, 10:15 pm CT
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

As far as store closings go, Macy's usually closes old stores

Of the former Field's stores, the oldest are Mayfair, old orchard, Oakbrook and river oaks. Other than River oaks, all very very profitable. Stratford was always a dog and too close to Woodfield. Springhill is at the edge of the sticks, pretty much new and the mall is under 45 million redevelopment. I think Northbrook could be a closure candidate, too close to old orchard. Northbrook Neiman's is a top producer, but the Neiman's client never enters the mall

Date: Wed, January 04, 2017,  5:28 pm CT
Posted by: Kevin C,

I wonder what will move into the Stratford Square store?

I thought maybe Mayfair and Spring Hill would be on the list.

(Comment from Jim McKay: I think Mayfair is one of their better performing stores.)

Date: Wed, January 04, 2017,  5:24 pm CT
Posted by: Michael D,

The saddest news is the loss of yet another downtown flagship- Dayton's Minneapolis. :-( :-(

Date: Wed, January 04, 2017,  5:23 pm CT
Posted by: Timothy E,

Ah, the "Magic of Macy's" - making things disappear into thin air....

Date: Wed, January 04, 2017, 5:17 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

They sure are closing a lot of former Hudson's and Dayton's stores (four). They closed Northland about two years ago. Of course, all five stores were branded as Marshall Field's for about 4 years, 2002-06.

Former Hudson's

- Lakeview Square Mall, Battle Creek, MI (102,000 square feet: opened 1983; 51 associates);

- Eastland Center, Harper Woods, MI (433,000 square feet; opened in 1957; 121 associates);

- Lansing, Lansing, MI (103,000 square feet; opened in 1979; 57 associates);

- Westland, Westland, MI (334,000 square feet; opened in 1965; 106 associates);

Former Dayton's:

- Minneapolis Downtown, Minneapolis, MN (1,276,000 square feet; opened in 1902; 280 associates);

- Columbia, Grand Forks, ND (99,000 square feet; opened in 1978; 53 associates);

- Valley View, La Crosse, WI (101,000 square feet; opened in 1980; 57 associates)

There's also one in Ohio that used to be Field's in the 1990s but it became a Kaufmann's.

Date: Wed, January 04, 2017, 3:10 pm to 5:13 pm CT
Posted by: Susan C,

Closing the former Dayton's flagship is so sad. What a loss for Minneapolis. I ran into one of my Marshall Field's co-workers on the 6th floor on the bus shortly before Christmas. I told her about the rumors for this store and she has no idea what is going on with the company she works for. I told her about this page and the up to date information. I will right the page information down and go into the store and give it to her. She also worked for Marshall Field's when Dayton Hudson bought it.

Date: Wed, January 04, 2017, 5:08 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

At about 3 pm Chicago time today, Macy's announced which additional 68 stores would close as part of the 100 closures announced last summer. The other 32 have already been announced.

Stratford Square store is only former Chicagoland Field's location to close. Downstate Bloomington (-Normal) and Alton, IL stores, formerly Famous Barr, will also close.

As of 5:00 pm, WGN TV News' Facebook page has about 200 posts on the topic with dozens saying they wished Marshall Field's would come back.

Macy's also revised its guidance. It said recent comp sales were down 2.1% overall.

Of the 100, three are former Dayton's locations, including the former flagship, and four are former Hudson's locations.

I thought for sure they would close River Oaks and bring the Woodfield and Oak Brook furniture stores back into the main stores. Joliet and Spring Hill always look shaky to me as well.

These are the links to Macy's press releases from today:

Store closures:

Revised Guidance for Nov/Dec:>

Date: Wed, January 04, 2017, 2:12 pm CT
Posted by: Aaron M.,

Macy's is officially announced the sale of the Dayton's building in Downtown Minneapolis and the closing of its store there.

An era ends: Macy's sells downtown Minneapolis store, will close it in March

Macys Inc.


Date: Wed, January 04, 2017, 11:11 am CT
Posted by: Chris R,

Actually, since you are considering precedents, later today could be the day. After the bell. First Wednesday of the first full week of the new year. For example, Wednesday, January 7, 2015, Wednesday, January 9, 2013, Wednesday, January 4, 2012. All days when they announced. Maybe today?

Date: Tues, January 03, 2017, 12:15 am CT
Posted by: Jim,

If past years' precedents are any indication, it's very possible that we will hear TODAY (Tuesday) or at least sometime this week as to the full list of 100 Macy's, Inc. stores that are closing.

I have no idea if any stores in Chicagoland are among those. At the same time, I think it's 99.9% likely that State Street, Water Tower Place, Woodfield, Oak Brook, Old Orchard, and Orland Park Macy's locations, along with Bloomingdale's at 900 N. Michigan Ave., are safe. Remember that some of the criteria include that in the store makes more money as another purpose instead of being run is a department store and also terms of leases. And, according to Macy's, Inc. conference calls in the past, all of the stores that are closing in the United States are all currently profitable but just could be more profitable if use differently.

In the past, under the category of "pure speculation", posters here have speculated that River Oaks/Calumet City, Louis Joliet, Spring Hill, Stratford Square, and even perhaps either Northbrook Court or Hawthorne might be among the hundred stores closing. Others have speculated that Bloomingdale's at Old Orchard or at the Wabash home store could be candidates, as could the two Macy's home stores at Oakbrook and Schaumburg. Of course, there are two other Macy's that are never on our radar because they never were once Marshall Field stores. Those are Bolingbrook and Gurnee Mills. Those are pretty new but you never know.

Date: Fri, December 30, 2016, 8:13 pm CT
Posted by: dave andrews,

This retail analyst feels that macy might be acquired by Ross Stores in 2017:
For those who don't know, Ross Dress for Less is a closeout/clearance store, a few steps BELOW TJMaxx and Marshalls. Whereas the latter two discount stores do have some decent displays and fixtures, Ross is more of a bare bones operation-- only having long pipe racks packed with miscellaneous clothing and plain metal shelving with spotty assortments of merchandise. The clothing and home goods at Ross are also of a lower quality, in my opinion.

For those who follow the history of American retailing and who believe the old adage "history repeats itself," this scenario with Ross Stores is reminiscent of what happened with Schottenstein Stores in the 1980s. Schottenstein was a discount store operation based in Columbus OH which bought out ailing regional chains--Halle's in Cleveland, Steinbach in New Jersey, Hochschild Kohn in Baltimore, Crowely's in Detroit, Korvettes on the East Coast. Many locations were liquidated and sold off, while others were converted to their Value City format.

My guess is that Ross would eventually remake the macy stores into the discount format. By converting the regional department stores into macy and eliminating what made these stores special, sales and stock prices have plummeted. By failing to maintain stores plus adding the Backstage and Last Act clearance areas, macy has further cheapened their brand name. There is truly no magic!

Date: Thurs, December 29, 2016, 6:19 pm CT
Posted by: A State Street Spectator,


Date: Wed, December 28, 2016, 9:43 pm CT
Posted by: Anna from South Bend,

Thank you for all the pictures.

Really miss Hudson's and Marshall Field's.

Date: Wed, December 28, 2016, 3:42 pm CT
Posted by: Linda W.,


All those photos are impressive. How can Macy's not listen? Especially when they seem so desperate closing stores.

Date: Tues, December 27, 2016, 9:06 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

We have close to 200 photos of what I estimate to be about 250 people who wanted to be photographed under The Great Clock at State and Washington during seven extended lunch hours this holiday season on November 5, 25, & 26 and December 3, 10, 17, & 23, 2016.

I've finally got the photos available--see below. Each square has a larger counterpart. Upon request via email to me at jjmckay AT me DOT com, I will post the larger, full image. The photos are presented roughly in reverse chronological order,

Thank you to all who supported our campaign under The Great Clock this past holiday season, especially Gloria, Lucie, Judy, Rene, and Marie for efforts under the clock; Gail, Gayle, Alfred, and John. Also not forgetting several of you who prefer to remain anonymous and everyone who has supported us by sharing or "liking" links to our images, posts, and more here and on our other social media channels. And of course all who posed for selfies.


All photos 2016 FieldsFansChicago & Jim McKay. All rights reserved. Permission for publication granted provided there is a photo credit.

Date: Mon, December 26, 2016, 1-:21 am CT
Posted by: Mr. JTS,

Selfridges is now offering a service for international delivery to every country in the world that they ship to for an annual fee of fifty US dollars. I signed up for this service and have acquired many British gifts for Christmas presents. Two orders are basically all it takes to cover the annual fee in itself and there is no minimum purchase threshold.

Chicago desires a high quality retail institution which operates under the same principles that Field's used to.

As the Best Department Store in the World and a history tied to Marshall Field's, this is an opportunity to further the Selfridges Come Home to Chicago/Selfies for Selfridges campaign.

The link to the page for Selfridges Plus is posted below.

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!

Happy Shopping!

Date: Sun, December 25, 2016, 10:04 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Happy Hanukkah! Merry Christmas! Happy Kwanzaa! Four years ago, in 2012, was for various reasons perhaps the most challenging year for those of us who stood out on State Street. FACT: for whatever reason, encouraging us on, we kept spontaneously hearing Luciano Pavarotti singing Ave Maria and The Night That Christ Was Born--car driving by playing it, somebody with a music player walking by, our car driving to State Street, and once even on the subway on our way to stand underneath the clock. It's the music we heard and the beauty we were encouraged by. Go figure. Inspired by this, we got together with some Field's alumni/retirees and put together this message for the season. Not saying it's the best video or anything but we just want to sure our heartfelt feelings of being out there on State Street in the cold for the cause of bringing back Marshall Field and company. This is the preferred version and it should play OK now on any type of computer or device, unlike a few years ago where we had another version which wasn't as nice sounding.) I like a lot of the photos in this slideshow/video because it demonstrates that Marshall Field was great even into its very last year. Are cause it's not just about nostalgia for something 40 or 50 years ago but something that's very contemporary and constantly being reinvented. That was Marshall Field and Company. As Alfred often says, here's to the once & future Marshall Field's.

Date: Sat, December 24, 2016, 9:30 pm CT
Posted by: dave andrews,

TEN YEARS AGO shoppers made their feelings known--they wanted their beloved local department stores. Now after years of lost customers and declining sales, analysts realize the May Company merger and rebranding of stores was a colossal mistake:

Simply closing stores isn't going to solve the problem. Shoppers have no connection to macy. Perhaps if they had come to town, opened their own stores, and competed fairly, macy might have gained some traction by trying to offer a better alternative. Instead they bought out the competition and brought their abrasive New York "better than everywhere else" attitude. Entering a macy store in Baltimore and seeing big pictures of their Herald Square flagship doesn't much matter,

Here's a suggestion--instead of CLOSING stores to regain profitability, how about REOPENING some? Start with the crown jewel Marshall Field's. Don't just put the name on a building filled with macy merchandise and management--bring back what was taken away and watch the customers return. Convert what were the top locations back to Fields! Keep the lower tier stores as macy. Once this catches on in Chicago, restore other beloved nameplates to their respective cities. Operate at least a few of the better stores in each market under the regional names. This would help their online business too--order a bathing suit from Burdines, The Florida Store or Frango mints from Marshall Field's. Then shoppers could have something special again!

Date: Sat, December 24, 2016, 2:08 pm CT
Posted by: dave andrews,

Not a very flattering evaluation of the departing CEO at macy:

Terry Lundgren's "legacy" is equivalent to those of Ron Johnson at JCPenney and Eddie Lampert at Sears. Future business school classes can study how arrogance, indifference to consumer wants and needs, failure to understand their customer base, and lack of market research lead to the near destruction of iconic American retailers.In all three cases the CEOs thought they knew best and failed to provide what the customers wanted. In all three cases, the results have been disastrous--lost jobs, closed stores, lower stock values.

Date: Thurs, December 22, 2016, 6:36 pm CT
Posted by: A State Street Spectator,

Thank you for the beautiful article by Leslie Goddard! I still remember my first trip to Marshall Field's to see Santa when I was 5 years old. For a child it was like the experience of a lifetime. Thank-you to all Field's Fans for your continued efforts to restore the experience of Field's to State Street!





Date: Wed, December 21, 2016, 5:15 pm CT
Posted by: Sandra,

It seems like there is less advertising and attention to the Walnut Room this Christmas season. I wonder if this is because it will be redeveloped as part of the rumored building deal.

Date: Tues, December 20, 2016, 12:00 pm CT
Posted by: David P.,

Growing up in Chicago, very Fond memories of Marshall Field's Chicago - the trip downtown on the el from Jefferson Park, the trip through the underground tunnels and the walkthrough into the store below ground level. The hustle and bustle of the massive store, the very high ceilings, the many eateries ( I think on the 8th floor). The Holiday Decorating and sparing NO Expense. The massive christmas tree, the Walnut Room, Frango Mints, the Holiday windows outside and finally the magical wait and chatter with Santa Clause. Marshall Field's a store like no other in Chicago. It was a very sad day when Macy's purchased Field's and rebranded it as their one of many chain stores. Marshall Field's losing its character, losing its uniqueness that made the store, its "Brand" Great - it WAS Chicago.

Date: Tues, December 20, 2016, 9:33 am CT
Posted by: Jim H.,

I miss heading to the store at the Water Tower Place after Christmas and buying Field Gear clothes at the after Christmas sales.

Date: Tues, December 20, 2016, 7:45 am CT
Posted by: Leslie Goddard,

Thanks Jim! It's an honor and such a lovely time of year to be remembering and celebrating our beloved Field's. Thanks for all that you and Fields Fans Forever do!!

Date: Mon, December 19, 2016, 11:33 pm ET
Posted by: Eric B.,

Here's another look back at Field's and Christmas. Leslie Goddard, author of the book Remembering Marshall Field's, has posted a marvelous essay online at "For Generations of Chicagoans, Marshall Field's Meant Business and Christmas." This brilliant piece discusses how and why Field's holiday traditions evolved into something much more significant than mere retail strategy. It's a must-read for all Field's Fans. The link is below. Bravo, Leslie!!

Date: Mon, December 19, 2016, 7:56 pm CT
Posted by: Marianne,

Wonderful Just love this!

Date: Mon, December 19, 2016, 7:51 pm CT
Posted by: James McKay,

A wonderful new story in a publication worthy of Marshall Field and Company by Leslie Goddard. I'm sure you'll want to read several times and share to your own Facebook pages. Thanks, Leslie.

For Generations of Chicagoans, Marshall Fields Meant Business, and Christmas

The midwestern mainstay transformed commerce into a communal holiday spectacle


Date: Sat, December 17, 2016, 6:54 pm CT
Posted by: Eric B.,

Here is a link to a wonderful story which appeared in Evanston RoundTable. It's about Sallie Posniak, who worked for Marshall Field's Display Department for many years and was ultimately in charge of decorating the Great Tree:

Date: Sat, December 17, 2016, 4:49 pm CT
Posted by: Michael D.,

The print edition of this month's Time Out Chicago has a "Then and Now" story about the Marshall Field and Company Building.

Date: Sat, December 17, 2016, 3:49 pm CT
Posted by: Neil G,

[ Both Marshall Field I and R. H. Macy had sons who led troubled lives.]

Woman Clears Mystery of Marshall Field Jr. Death in November of 1905.



LOS ANGELES, Nov. 22, 1913 The mystery surrounding the death of Marshall Field, Jr., heir to $100,000,000, in Chicago November 23, 1905, was cleared up today, if the confession made by Mrs. Vera Scott, wife of Lloyd D. Scott, a Kansas City musician, can be believed. For eight years Fields death has been unexplained. He was shot, but that is all the public has known.

Besides killing Field, Mrs. Scott confessed that ...

Continues at

Date: Sat, December 17, 2016, 2:04 pm
Posted by: James McKay,

Neither sleet not freezing rain could keep us Field's Fans from being out on State Street today. Even had to squeegee off sleet from the signs.

There were significantly less people out on State Street today than might be expected for the last full Saturday of shopping before Christmas.

While the weather made it more difficult than usual to take photos, We did get ten shots that cane out pretty well and ar forthcoming.

Special thanks to Dianne (who came almost 100 miles to help out) and Ms Moore (embarrassed to say I may have the wrong name but she's from here) who made the afternoon extra special. Also many, many thanks to Gail,Gaylee, John, and of course Alfred for making it possible with their support.

FRIDAY, DECEMBER 23, 2016: Because of the weather and the unusual nature of Christmas Eve falling on a Saturday, we're going to try for one more time out on State Street this Friday afternoon, December 23. Watch this Group for exact details. Hope you can make it out. Thanks for all you do to help bring back Marshall Field and Company.

Date: Fri, December 16, 2016, 4:16 pm CT
Posted by: Carrie H,

I guess I'm a bit of a Field's junkie

I saved a CD from 2001 Fab Fields Mix " Bond " [ It might have been part of atrium opening. ]

Date: Fri, December 16, 2016, 3:29 pm CT
Posted by: Carol H,

Cleaning out the Christmas closet & came across this gem of a shopping bag thinking just how much this cost to make ( the ornament is a clear pane and the harlequin print is on the interior opposite side bag ) [From about 2001 or 2002]

It's a little beat up but I've kept it to store my gift bags all these years

Always unique & classy that Marshall Field & Co.

Date: Thurs, December 15, 2016, 9:38 pm CT
Posted by: Kate,

Really Missing Marshall Field andCompany. Macy's is not the same.

Date: Wed, December 14, 2016, 8:38 am CT
Posted by: Carol H,

Stumbled upon the group when I was trying to research the history of an antique apron from M Fields

Glad to be here !

Date: Sun, December 11, 2016,ق:58 pm CT
Posted by: A State Street Spectator,

Those are great photos from a very cold Saturday. Thank-you for taking the time go go out there!

Date: Sat, December 10, 2016, 2:58 pm
Posted by: James McKay,

It was very cold and windy today from 11:45 am-2 pm but enthusiasm for Field's was again hot. We passed out hundreds of our brand-new 2016 edition of the flyers and almost as many pin-on "Time To Bring Back Marshall Field's" pin-on buttons. Due to the wind and cold, it was a little harder to take photos, but we will have about a dozen different subjects here in today's photos. Thanks to all for the support, especially Gail, Alfred, Gayle, J., And everyone else who stopped by to help, especially the two different annons who helped with holding the signs and passing out leaflets for a while. Please join us next Saturday, December 17, 2016, from at least 11:30 AM to 1 PM when we will repeat again. Thanks for all you do to help bring back Marshall Field and company.


Date: Fri, December 09, 2016, 6:49 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Please join us at State and Washington Streets under the great clock from 11:30 a.m.1 p.m. (and beyond?) this Saturday, December 10th and next Saturday, December 17, 2016. You can join us in distributing pin-on buttons and bookmark flyers in support of our case. There will also be a few protest signs with which people can pose, continuing our Selfies Protest Rally from last years holiday season and this past September. Many end up enjoying the fellowship of meeting other Chicagoans on State Street and wishing everyone a Merry Christmas, Happy Hanukkah, Happy Holidays, and Happy New Year.

Your presence would be an immense help as we hope and work, little by little, to have Marshall Field's restored to State Street in name, ethos, and style.

While it's not required, it is recommended that if you plan to come, please RSVP.Sometimes weather or unforeseen activities on State Street mean we have to relocate nearby where we make our stand for Fields. If we know that you are coming and we have contact info, we can forward any unlikely last minute changes to you. If you have further questions either in advance or even during the 90 minutes we will be on State Street, please email jjmckay at me dot com

Photos from our previous activities on can be found by scrolling down our blog at Although updates have delayed, look for photos and posts from past couple of weekends activities to appear soon. Thank you to all who helped make it a success, especially Lucie, Renee and of course Gloria.

We are also especially thankful for the support of Gail, Gayle, J., and Alfred in providing the pin-on buttons that we distribute on State Street. Thank you so very much.

If you would like to contribute money to help us continue our pin-on buttons this holiday season, please Facebook Mesenger me for details.

Please stay in ouch with our social media outlets (below) for any last-minute announcements or changes to our Saturday activities..

Web Blog/Guestbook:


Twitter: @fieldsfanschgo or

Instagram: Fields Fans Chicago

Best regards and many, many thanks,

Jim McKay

Co-Organizer & Webmaster

jjmckay at me dot com

Date: Thurs, December 08, 2016, 12:17 am ET
Posted by: David,

The recent news of the Meier and Frank Building closing in Portland, which I just go to see for the first time in October, and the Dayton's building in Minneapolis is just so sad. I was able to visit that store a few years ago, and who can forget seeing it every week when we watched the Mary Tyler Moore Show.

Of course this is the Fields blog, and Fields was my favorite, was in Chicago a few weeks ago, and went to Oakbrook and Woodfield, I did buy some Frango's couldn't help myself in the Woodfield "Marketplace" at least it was still there for the moment, although no wine shop, and no green stripes.

Being in retail, the traffic is just not coming, the migration to online is shocking this season.....

I honestly totally believe that if they took State Street and Water Tower and rebranded them Field's again, it would really help, maybe i'm being optimistic, but I think with the retro trends everywhere, they would get some great press out of it...

Wish we were all carrying green bags this season.....

Merry Christmas

Date: Tues, December 6, 2016, 
Posted by: Jacob H,

Does anyone recall the Marklin train layout in the toy department at the State Street store in the early 1980s? I tried finding pictures or video of it, but haven't had any luck. I remember it had catenary lines for power, it was the first time I'd seen such a thing in a model.

Date: Mon, December 5, 2016, 
Posted by: Brooks C,

It was a family tradition of ours to get up early Christmas Eve morning be the first in line to eat at the Walnut room then visit Santa. Even in the winter of '83 when the actual temperature was -3.

Date: Mon, December 4, 2016, 
Posted by: Timothy E,

In the 80's, Santa Bear was called 'Mistletoe Bear'.

Date: Mon December 4, 2016, 
Posted by: Claire O,

The Walnut Room mugs now are just boring. Same old Christmas tree. At least Field's changed it up every year. I have Santabear mugs going back to the early 80's (Thank you, various thrift stores and eBay!!).

Date: Sat, December 3, 2016, 
Posted by: James McKay,

arson's Santa is back on State Street, at least on weekends. Kathryn Bufano, The former exec with many department store chains including Federated/Macy's and Belk became CEO OF Carson's/Bon-Ton. Having grown up in Chicago, she is quoted how much she missed Marshall Field's, suggesting it was a mistake to get rid of it. So it's interesting this year that Carsons is partnering with block 37 to have Santa's Pantry on weekends, competition to Macy's Santaland across street. I wouldn't be surprised if she's disappointed that Bon Ton got rid of Carson's on State Street some years before she arrived on the scene here in Chicago.

Date: Sat, December 3, 2016, 
Posted by: James McKay,

It was very cold and windy today from 11:50 am-2 pm but enthusiasm for Field's was hot. The reaction for bringing back Marshall Field and company to State Street was plain to see. Even more people just insisted on taking a photo of our signs. Photos Forthcoming

Date: Sat, December 3, 2016, 3:05 am CT
Posted by: Michael E.,

Macy's in talks about downtown Minneapolis site; no decision on closing the iconic store

Macys is in talks with a potential developer for its downtown Minneapolis property but has not yet committed to whether it will shutter its store.


Date: Sat, December 3, 2016, 20:55
Posted by: Wendy C,

Christmas means unpacking Walnut Room mugs featuring Santa Bear and the Marshall Field's logo.

Date: Sat, December 3, 2016, 11:22a am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Please join us at State and Washington Streets under the great clock TODAY FROM 11:50 a.m.1:15 p.m. (and beyond?). Sorry this is late notice--weren't sure that would be able to do it today. Please be so kind to hold nostalgic photos another similar posts until after 6 pm today so that we can generate attention on our activities today. Thank you

You can join us in distributing some pin-on buttons and bookmark flyers in support of our case. There will also be a few protest signs with which people can pose, continuing our Selfies Protest Rally from last years holiday season and this past September.

PLEASE NOTE: please do not post any "regrets" about being unable to attend i.e. "wish I could but" type comments until after the event occurs. Such comments before the event will be removed and posted at a later date.

This is an excellent opportunity for us to make our case for Marshall Field's return in front of the media who may stop by, as they did last year.

Your presence would be an immense help as we hope and work, little by little, to have Marshall Field's restored to State Street in name, ethos, and style.

While its not required, it is recommended that if you plan to come, please RSVP. Sometimes weather or unforeseen activities on State Street mean we have to relocate nearby where we make our stand for Fields. If we know that you are coming and we have contact info, we can forward any unlikely last minute changes to you. If you have further questions either in advance or even during the 90 minutes we will be on State Street, please respond to this email, or call AREA CODE THREE ONE TWO dash 927 dash 4424.

Photos from our previous activities on Saturday, November 5, 2016 can be found by scrolling down our blog at Thank you to all who helped make it a success, and especially Lucie and Gloria.

We are also especially thankful for the support of Gail, Gayle, John and Alfred in providing the pin-on buttons that we distribute on State Street. Thank you so very much.

We expect that we will repeat these activities at the time, at least 11:30 a.m.1 p.m. on the first three Saturdays of December, December 10, and 17, 2016, Check out social media outlets (below) for confirmation.

Web Blog/Guestbook:


Twitter: @fieldsfanschgo or

Instagram: Fields Fans Chicago

Best regards and many, many thanks,

Jim McKay

Co-Organizer & Webmaster

AREA CODE THREE ONE TWO dash 927 dash 4424

jjmckay AT me dot com

Date: Fri, December 02, 2016, 4:24 pm CT
Posted by: dave andrews,

"The Magic of macy" makes another iconic flagship disappear:

Beware, Chicago! Notice the list of flagship locations that have closed since macy took over. Shoppers aren't buying what they're selling, so now they liquidate the assets. This scenario is reminiscent of what has happened at Sears. The downward spiral continues.

Date: Fri, December 02, 2016, 4:11 pm CT
Posted by: dave andrews,

Evidently the developers of the shuttered macy in downtown Pittsburgh realize the value of the building's heritage:

Kaufmann's and other regional department stores were part of the fabric of their communities; macy, not so much. If these developers understand the Kaufmann's name still has cachet, why can't the board of directors and executives at Herald Square realize that Marshall Field's would be massively successful even after all these years?

Date: Thurs, December 1, 2016, 9:47 pm CT
Posted by: Mike S., Haddon Heights, NJ,

The thing that really upsets me about Macy's and the possible impending closure of Minneapolis is that they seem to damage everything they touch. I really, really want to shop at Macy's. I want to support them, but I seldom find anything worth buying. If you can believe it I remember there was a time when Macy's actually was an upper middle class department store. But when I go into their stores, they're messy, dirty, you have to hunt down someone to help you and a fair majority of the merchandise is something I could get cheaper at Target. Half of shopping is atmosphere and that is why you walk into places like Nordstrom and Saks and Neimans and you see clean stores and compelling merchandise. Not everyone can afford to shop there and I get that. But that is what made places like Marshall Field's special...the stores were clean, inviting, special and no matter what your budget you could find something. When you walked in there you knew you were in a special place. You want to know why Macy's isn't doing well or why they need to close stores? The answer is simple...they don't listen to their customers. You would think that after the closing of the 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th downtown store they'd take a look at say....gee what are we doing wrong here? It is possible to run a profitable downtown store, but you have to give people a reason to shop there. The merchandise needs to be compelling and fresh and ever changing. I applaud Macy's and their team for their stewardship of the Wanamaker Organ and their commitment to that location, but beyond that, Macy's has downgraded Marshall Fields in Chicago and clearly now they're about to decimate the Minneapolis store. To be honest with you, I'm not sure why they don't use Center City Philadelphia as an example of what Pittsburgh and Minneapolis could have been...a mixed use building with a very profitable Macy's operating on its lower floors. I can understand the need to downsize Minneapolis, but why not renovate it and keep the first 4 or 5 floors open and the auditorium and 12th floor. Fill the remaining place with residential apartments or office space and then those people would probably shop in that very store. Doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure this one out. But the bean counters in Cincinnati will never get it. They don't understand the concept of spending money to make money. It's all about a quick buck. I'm sorry for the people who work in Minneapolis. For me I think this will just strengthen my resolve to support Lord and Taylor, Boscov's and in summation this is a sad day. If I lived in Minnesota I would run to this store to enjoy it this holiday season. I'm hoping they'll still be open into late January so I can fly out and see it one last time. Shame Macy's doesn't realize the gold they have. This will be the end of an sad.

Date: Thurs, December 1, 2016, 8:29 pm
Posted by: J.P.,

Yeah...the slow murder of downtown shopping environments by a visionless, yet once great chain. Between Amazon and the fear of Wall Street, Macy's has chosen the path of no resistance and no desire to re-imagine what it can be. If you can't make it work in a downtown like Minneapolis, then you're not even trying. This is what 35 years of MBA-think has done to once great American businesses.

Date: Thurs, December 1, 2016, 7:41 pm CT
Posted by: Michael R.,


Date: Thurs, December 1, 2016, 4:20 pm CT
Posted by: Jeremy S,

Just as suspected...flagship Minneapolis Macy*s to close...I started my work (first job out of college) with Target Corporation, then Dayton-Hudson Corporation in the buying office on the sixth floor of this building. [ It was also the HQ of Marshall Field's in the 1990s through 2006 ] I still work for Target about 18 years later, just a few blocks down the mall at Target Plaza.

Story That Macy's May Close Former Minneapolis Flagship

Date: Monday, November 28, 2016, 6:48 am CT
Posted by: James McKay,

Leslie Goddard presents in Schaumburg.

Schaumburg event recalls holidays at Marshall Field and Co.

You'd be hard pressed to find any Chicago-area natives over 30 who don't have a holiday memory involving Marshall Field and Co. Those memories were brought

Date: Sat, November 26, 2016, 2:59 pm CT
Posted by: James McKay,

B L A C K . . S A T U R D A Y. Special thanks to Gail, Gayle, Alfred and especially J., Lucie, & Gloria for making today a repeat success of yesterday. Photos will be forthcoming.

Most likely we will be out there again next Saturday, December 3 from 11:30 AM until at least 1 PM.

By the way, I can't emphasize enough how many people just take pictures of us posing for photos.

Date: Sat, November 26, 2016, 10:11 am CT
Posted by: James McKay,

BLACK FRIDAY: Special thanks to everyone who helped make our Black Friday activities on State Street a huge success. I am especially appreciative of Gail, Gayle, and Alfred, Renee, and of course never forgetting Gloria. Our message resonated during the two hours we were out there (from 11:30 AM to 1:45 PM). Photos from the event will be forthcoming. Will be out there again today from at least 11:30 AM until after 1:00 PM.

Date: Thurs, November 24, 2016, 10:14 pm CT
Posted by: Michael D.,


November 23, 2016 By Alex Bean

"Black Friday in Chicago always brings hordes of deal-seekers to downtown State Street shopping district. The term Black Friday arose in the 1980s, but State Street, that great street, has been a shopping mecca since the days of the great department stores. What about the stores of holidays past, the ones that are no longer around?

Starting it all, Field, Leiter, and Co., the predecessor of the legendary Marshall Fields, moved into its marble palace store at State and Washington in 1868. In the century and a half since then, scores of grand department stores and retailers have occupied huge chunks of real estate along the mile of State Street within the Loop.

Back in the day, department stories really had bargain basements and..."


Date: Tues, November 22, 2016,  Updated 11:18 pm CT
Posted by: James McKay,

On our Facebook page there is the whole sequence of store windows by Macy's on State Street for the 2016 holiday season. The first two windows are along Randolph to the corner at State Street and appear to promote holiday fashion. Then along State Street there is the traditional theme of windows. Finally, The corner window at State and Washington is treated as two separate windows, each promoting fashions at Macy's for the holiday season. I would say these are better than some years, perhaps not as good as some other years. The artistry and craft by those who did the windows is great--but please restrain yourself and criticism--you don't know what sort of limited budget these talented people had to work with. That said, I still miss the magical windows of Marshall Field and Company.

Date: Tues, November 22, 2016, 10:35 pm
Posted by: Katie L,

WTTW reminisces about Marshall Field's:

Facebook Membership may be required:

Date: Tues, November 22, 2016, 4:22 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Please join us at State and Washington Streets under the great clock from 11:30 a.m.1 p.m. (and beyond?) this Friday AND Saturday, November 25 & 26, 2016, Black Friday and Saturday". You can join us in distributing some pin-on buttons and bookmark flyers in support of our case. There will also be a few protest signs with which people can pose, continuing our Selfies Protest Rally from last years holiday season and this past September.

PLEASE NOTE: please do not post any "regrets" about being unable to attend i.e. "wish I could but" type comments until after the event occurs. Such comments before the event will be removed and posted at a later date.

This is an excellent opportunity for us to make our case for Marshall Field's return in front of the media who may stop by, as they did last year.

Your presence would be an immense help as we hope and work, little by little, to have Marshall Field's restored to State Street in name, ethos, and style.

While its not required, it is recommended that if you plan to come, please RSVP. Sometimes weather or unforeseen activities on State Street mean we have to relocate nearby where we make our stand for Fields. If we know that you are coming and we have contact info, we can forward any unlikely last minute changes to you. If you have further questions either in advance or even during the 90 minutes we will be on State Street, please respond to this email, or call area code THREE ONE TWO DASH 927 dash 4424.

Photos from our previous activities on Saturday, November 5, 2016 can be found by scrolling down our blog at Thank you to all who helped make it a success, and especially Lucie and Gloria.

We are also especially thankful for the support of Gail, Gayle, and Alfred in providing the pin-on buttons that we distribute on State Street. Thank you so very much.

If you would like to contribute money to help us continue our pin-on buttons this holiday season, please also respond to this email or call AREA CODE THREE ONE TWO dash 927 dash 4424 for details. If we cannot take your call, please leave a message and someone will return your call ASAP.

We expect that we will repeat these activities at the time, at least 11:30 a.m.1 p.m. on the first three Saturdays of December, December 3, 10, and 17, 2016, Check out social media outlets (below) for confirmation.

Web Blog/Guestbook:


Twitter: @fieldsfanschgo or

Instagram: Fields Fans Chicago

Best regards and many, many thanks,

Jim McKay

Co-Organizer & Webmaster

AREA CODE THREE ONE TWO dash 927 dash 4424

jjmckay AT me DOT com

Date: Thurs, November 17, 2016, 10:52 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Just read Jim's link to the article about the holiday windows. How amazing that macy started this tradition in Chicago over 100 years ago!

Date: Thurs, November 17, 2016, 10:47 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Another "expert analysis" on what's wrong at macy:

The big problem is the CEO didn't listen to what the customers wanted--and his arrogance has come back to bite the company where it hurts the most. Wonder if all the "experts" who were so excited that macy*fication could save a few dollars on shopping bags and advertising are now so thrilled that millions have been lost by dwindling sales and profits. How much have sales and stock prices fallen the past few years?

There are macy stores in almost every mall everywhere; the stores truly are nothing special and offer no compelling reason for shoppers to visit.

Date: Thurs, November 17, 2016, 11:46 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

John Wilkinson: Thanks for your post. Two comments. One, Thanksgiving is just one week away--times flies, doesn't it? Two, Macy's says that working on Thanksgiving is voluntary.

Date: Thurs, November 17, 2016, 12:14
Posted by: John Wilkinson ,

The third quarter numbers are in, and they are not encouraging: Macys sales and profits both slid.

Its sales were off 4.2 percent, marking the seventh straight quarterly decline. Its profit of $17 million sounds impressive until we learn that it was $118 million a year ago; shares dropped from 36 cents to a nickel.

The Macys Thanksgiving Day Parade is two weeks from today

Macys is making its workers show up on Thanksgiving. It did so last yearfor the first timebut this year it is opening two hours earlier. This is yet another sign that it is both ethically and financially challenged.

Date: Tues, November 15, 2016, 10:34 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,

NBC also reports on the Cubs logo and lighting the Walnut Room Tree in "Cubs blue."

Date: Mon, November 14, 2016, 9:23 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,

Macy's puts what looks like a Cubs sticker on the replica of the Navy Pier Ferries wheel in it's Holiday store window. This is a news story?

Date: Fri, November 11, 2016, 9:59 pm CT
Posted by: dave andrews,

Not a very positive perspective on the future of macy:

Perhaps--just perhaps--if the CEO of macy had listened to what customers wanted, the company wouldn't be in this predicament. This analysis suggests bringing back much of what has been taken away and which made the regional department stores unique. A cookie cutter store is fine if one is looking for basic items, like towels or socks, and discount prices; this model works for Kohl's and Target but not so much for macy.

We can only hope that common sense prevails and the incoming CEO gives shoppers what they want.

Date: Fri, November 11, 2016, 6:41 am CT
Posted by: Alan W,

[ Macy's is closing the former Meier and Frank flagship that was massively remodeled into a smaller store and hotel complex not too many years ago. May point to reconsideration of the Minneapolis flagship and others.]

Date: Thurs, November 10, 2016, 10:18 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Some notes from the Macy's Inc. conference call; check later today to listen to the actual call and develop your own impressions.

- Despite a drop in sales, it sounds like Macy's, Inc is holding its own, overall. With Marshall Field's State Street in mind, Macy's and Bloomingdale's stores that are geared to tourism performed as well as typical stores. In previous quarters, there were problems due reduced exchange rates with the dollar reducing sales to tourists from international destinations.

- Portland, OR (former Meier and Frank flagship) to close after Christmas.

- Three categories of stores for leveraging real estate value:

1) FLAGSHIPS Specifically, a. NYC Herald Square/34th Street, 2. Union Square (where Mens Store across the street/former Liberty House) will be merged into main flagship; 3. State Street; 4. Minneapolis. They expect to have plans for all four in the coming two years, but 34th Street will take the longest because it is the most complicated.


3) NEW ALLIANCE with Brookfield Properties. Look at using parts or all of current Macy's stores. An example they used is taking a Macy's Furniture store and consolidating it back into a nearby Macy's and redeveloping the furniture store. (Woodfield and Oak Brook in Chicagoland, as well as others, fit this description. They never specifically mentioned Chicagoland stores in this regard.)

During one of the questions, an analyst asked if the Michigan Avenue store might be remodeled to match performance of other Michigan Avenue competitors. Macy's, Inc. CFO Karen Hoguet asked to clarify if he meant State Street because Michigan Avenue already had some remodeling relatively recently. He confirmed Michigan Avenue. Hoguet responded that Michigan Avenue was doing fine. She understandably had a touch of incredulity in her tone and I agree with her. Yes, I think it would be doing better as Field's, but Water Tower performs well, in my humble opinion, better than State Street. It's always busy, closer to hotels, and since the store is only 40 years old, it's a much more efficient building.


To me this makes it more probable that Downtown Minneapolis will close:

Date: Thurs, November 10, 2016, 8:43 am CT
Posted by: mikea,

I was at State Street last week after the Cubs celebration. The store was actually busy, but that was about it . This years decorations keep getting worse and worse. The wonderful Tiffany dome atrium =has cardboard ornaments hanging like K Mart and target would do. The first floor main aisle always with excellent decorations even for 8 years under Macy's are stark and void and just down tight ugly.

They keep cost cutting more and more. They are selling now the nice downtown Portland store that was downsized and renovated. They continue to sell and close profitable stores. They are retreating like Sears, and yet they still continue to make profits.

The only way now to save this great company is for them to be sold or go private. These investor activists all they want is a short term profit and if it means the eventual end of the company so be it.

Don't look for Macy's to spend any money rebranding stores to Field's The only hope for this company is for it to be sold, go private and then focus on its business of retail and not a real estate company.

Date: Thurs, November 10, 2016, 7:27 am CT
Posted by: Dave,

Despite the former Kaufmann's/Macy's in downtown Pittsburgh having closed, civic organizations are trying to keep the store windows and visits with Santa going. Some of the windows will even extend beyond the former department store. Meanwhile, I heard that some of the store plaques from the former Famous-Barr & May Department Stores HQ in St Louis have stolen. The remainder have been removed by the owner to protect them for the time being. When Macy's occupied the store, they covered up the Famous-Barr plaques with Macy's plaques. The Macy's plaques were removed when they left, again exposing the Famous-Barr plaques. Just posting all this here because perhaps it's a suggestion of what could happen if Macy's closes any former Marshall Field and Company stores.

Date: Wed, November 09, 2016, 19:34
Posted by: Jim,

Macy's, Inc will release its 3rd Quarter results tomorrow morning. A conference call will be streamed over the web beginning at 9:00 am Chicago Time. Just follow the links from

There could be some information about the future of the State Street store and others. So stay tuned.

Date: Mon, November 07, 2016, 6:54 pm CT
Posted by: A State Street Spectator,

I was encouraged by all the passersby (including the many Cubs fans) on Saturday who want to see Marshall Field's return to State Street. Those are great selfies!

Date: Sun, November 6, 2016, 5:12 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,


Saturday, November 5, 2016

Thanks to all who made our "Selfies Rally" a success yesterday. We especially thank Gloria, and Lucie for making it all happen!

We were out for about 80 minutes yesterday. the day that the holiday windows and the Great Tree wer unveiled at State Street. We distributed close to 200 bookmark flyers and a few dozen pin-on buttons. About three dozen posed for photos, some of which are posted below.

We look forward to similar activities on on Black Friday as well as on Saturdays after Thanksgiving through December 17, 2016. Please keep in touch with this web site for more details on exact times as they become available.

Here's to the once and future Marshall Field's!

All photos 2016 FieldsFansChicago & Jim McKay Permission for publication granted as long as there is a photo credit.

2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay

Date: Thurs, November 03, 2016, 19:48
Posted by: gle,



GO CUBS! GO FIELD'S! GO CHICAGO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Date: Wed, November 02, 2016, 11:47 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay ,

Apparently activist investor Starboard thinks that they bought into Macy's too soon. This is the group that wanted Macy's to parts of and re-organize its real estate portfolio to make more money for stockholders. Possibilities were and are being considered for a number of stores including Chicago's State Street store.

Date: Wed, November 02, 2016, 11:43 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay ,

Macy's announces three of the upcoming store closures part of a sale or five stores to General Growth. One is a former Dayton's they operated for four years as Marshall Field's in Eau Claire, Wisconsin.

Date: Wed, November 02, 2016, 9:59 am CT
Posted by: Michael,

i definately dont like Macys,..I miss Marshall fields so so much

Date: Wed, November 02, 2016, 1:02 am CT
Posted by: Mommy Doggy,

I hope Field's comes back too...just saw my last (and sad) Marshall F's shopping bag in a stack of gift bags

Date: Tues, November 01, 2016, 7:18 pm CT
Posted by: Judy D,

I live in California....would be there if I could. Wishing for two things......Marshall Field's back on State Street and the Cubbies winnning the World Series.

Date: Tues, November 01, 2016, 6:31 pm CT
Posted by: gle,

Thank you! I look forward to being there this Saturday!

Date: Tues, November 01, 2016, 6:27 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Dear Field's Fans Chicago and other Friends supporting the return of Marshall Fields to State Street.

At noon, this Saturday, November 5, 2016, Macys will unveil the Great Tree in the Walnut Room, the holiday windows, and in-store decor at the State Street store that once was and we hope again will be Marshall Fields.

This is an excellent opportunity for us to make our case for Marshall Field's return in front of the media who may stop by, as they did last year..

Please join us at State and Washington Streets under the great clock from 11:30 a.m.1 p.m. (and beyond?) this Saturday, November 5, 2016. You can join us in distributing some pin-on buttons and bookmark flyers in support of our case. There will also be a few protest signs with which people can pose, continuing our Selfies Protest Rally from last years holiday season and this past September.

Your presence would be an immense help as we hope and work, little by little, to have Marshall Field's restored to State Street in name, ethos, and style.

While its not required, it is recommended that if you plan to come, please RSVP. Sometimes weather or unforeseen activities on State Street mean we have to relocate nearby where we make our stand for Fields. If we know that you are coming and we have contact info, we can forward any unlikely last minute changes to you. If you have further questions either in advance or even during the 90 minutes we will be on State Street, please email jjmckay (AT) me (DOT) com, or call 312.927.4424.

If you would like to contribute money to help us continue our pin-on buttons this holiday season, please also email jjmckay (AT) me (DOT) com or call 312.927.4424 for details. If we cannot take your call, please leave a message and someone will return your call ASAP.

Next week, there will be more details about how you can help bring back Marshall Fields during similar events this holiday season. As always, we ask you that participate at our following social media outlets:

This Web Blog/Guestbook that you are reading:


Twitter: @fieldsfanschgo or

Instagram: Fields Fans Chicago

Best regards and many, many thanks,

Jim McKay

Co-Organizer & Webmaster

jjmckay (AT) me (DOT) com


Date: Sun, October 30, 2016, 8:09 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

I agree with you, Phil. I don't think State Street will close. However, I do think, based on comments made by Alderman Riley last November in the Chicago Sun-Times, that there's the possibility that the store could shrink with even some of the rooms on the first floor of Wabash being repurposed as lobbies or something similar for access to spaces on other floors. Or, as Riley said, it's possible some street level spaces could go to other tenants. Whatever Macy's does, it would have to some degree involve Alderman Riley for his approval and he said he was open.

Date: Fri, October 28, 2016, 02:48
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

I'm still not worried about state street. When Macy's just published their top doors, there was Herald square then state street and then water tower. MINNEAPOLIS store should be really worried. Plus Minneapolis is a crappy market, ralph lauren opened and closed Bloomingdale's, Saks, Neiman's all closed. However, Saks and Neiman's were in that horrid gavidea commons, possibly the dumbest mall ever after chicago place.

Date: Tues, October 25, 2016, 6:06 pm CT
Posted by: Michael D,

From Business insider:

"REI CEO Jerry Stritzke says Macy's decision to open earlier than ever on Thanksgiving reflects poorly on the entire retail industry.

Macy's is one of a few retailers that have revealed their opening hours during the Thanksgiving holiday weekend.

The department-store chain will open at 5 p.m. on Thanksgiving Day to kick off its Black Friday sales.

In an interview with Business Insider, Stritzke called Macy's decision "very disappointing" and said it "misses the point of what Thanksgiving is about."


Date: Tues, October 25, 2016, 3:46 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

The article talks about turning the State Street store into a "mixed use" building.

From Chicago Business Journal, by Lewis Lazare

Macy's on State getting a headstart on annual holiday celebration - Chicago Business Journal

And why shouldn't it? The giant department store chain will begin shuttering scores of stores early next year...

Date: Mon, October 24, 2016, 20:39
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Looks like the 'magic' continues as macy moves to sell its downtown Minneapolis location. Don't believe for a minute that they are going to operate a smaller store. The exact same scenario played out in Pittsburgh. They took what was Kaufmann's most profitable store and ran it into the ground by doing nothing to attract shoppers. Stocking poor quality, overpriced merchandise while cutting staff and building maintenance isn't going draw customers. If Minneapolis is one of their 'flagship' stores, what does the future hold for the Chicago landmark?

Date: Sun, October 23, 2016, 15:20
Posted by: gle,

The Chicago Cubs are headed for the World Series!

Marshall Field's can come back. We hope it won't take as long, but things do come back. GO CUBS! GO FIELD'S! GO CHICAGO!

Date: Sat, October 22, 2016, 02:53
Posted by: Phil Eichlerch,

[ blank post.]

Date: Fri, October 21, 2016, 6:52 pm CT
Posted by: Michael D.,

An update to an old story in the LA Times on former Macy brands:

Miss May Co. and I. Magnin? Newport businessman plans to bring them back

Date: Fri, October 21, 2016, 17:23
Posted by: Jim,

Macy's considers closing downtown Minneapolis store, a Minnesota retail landmark

Macy's is negotiating a sale of its 1-million-square foot complex on Nicollet Mall and its store is in limbo.

Macy's closed similar flagships in Atlanta (two of them, Davisons and Rich's), Pittsburgh, Houston, Filene's in Boston, St Louis, and of course St Paul. No surprise...I suspect that it will likely happen in Minneapolis as well.

Thiis is how the end progresses. Note the comments that incorrectly say that Marshall Field's took over Dayton's. it was the opposite, of course, but then Dayton's converted to the Marshall Field's name.

Date: Wed, October 19, 2016, 9:51 am CT
Posted by: Jim,

The inside cover of the November 2016 Chicago Magazine (a tronc publication) has a full page ad for this year's unveiling of the Great Treen in the Walnut Room at Macy's on State Street. The date will be Saturday, November 5 at noon. That's the Saturday after Halloween, which has been typical in recent years. The ad says that the event will be "starring Aloe Blacc."

Presumably this year's windows will also be unveiled. After the decent job they did on teh flower show last spring, one of their better efforts, I wonder if they will also do a better job on the windows and other in-store decorations as well.

Yes, We will be out there on State Street under the clock from at least 11:30 am to 1:00 pm. More details to follow.

Best regards,


Date: Wed, October 19, 2016, 9:39 am CT
Posted by: Jim,

Chicago Tribune (A tronc publication) article:

Macy's to open an hour earlier on Thanksgiving Day

"Macy's is staying committed to Thanksgiving Day shopping, saying it'll open an hour earlier this year.

The company plans to open at 5 p.m. on Thanksgiving, with most Macy's stores closing at 2 a.m., and then reopening at 5 a.m. Friday. It cited "ongoing customer interest in shopping on Thanksgiving, both at Macy's and at many other retailers."

The department store chain has been open on Thanksgiving evening since 2013, but had remained open through the night."

The Field's Fans Blog has been on hiatus for four weeks, from Wednesday, September 21--Wednesday, October 19, 2016. Thank you for your support and well wishes. You will see some items from this period that were submitted via email or Facebook. Postings during this time period did not appear until about 9:30 am, Chicago Time on Wedneday, October 19, 2016.

Thank you patience!

Date: Wed, October 12, 2016, 
Posted by: gle,




Date: Sun, October 9, 2016, 
Posted by: Judy E,

I MISS Marshall Fields. Every year we say we're going Christmas shopping at Marshall Field's State Street store (just can't bring myself to call is Macy's). Back in 1970 was my first trip to the store where my boyfriends Mom bought my gloves and purse for the prom. And I still have them. The Walnut Room may look the same but is just not the same at Christmas.

Date: Friday, September 30, 2016, 8:29 am CT
Posted to Facebook in September by: Aaron M,

From a link about Field's history, :


Field's retail store opens its bargain basement area.

[<i>While not answered directly, the page further suggests that the bargain basement disappeared in the 1980s, perhaps when the atrium connecting the State Street and Wabash sides was built.</i>]

Date: Thursday, September 29, 2016, 10:19 pm CT
Posted by: Timothy E,

As best I recall, Field's basement was renovated and 're-imagined' as a new home for housewares (from 9), gourmet foods (from 7), and books, stationery, and luggage (3 or 4?) in about 1982.

Date: Monday, September 26, 2016, 9:26 pm CT
Posted by: Vicki B. R.,

I remember it being known as the 'Bargain Basement' in the early 70's.

Date: Monday, September 26, 2016, 3:03 pm CT
Posted by: Michael D.,

When did Marshall Field's open and close it budget store on State Street?

If memory serves me Henry Selfridge came up with the concept and Marshall Field's had the first budget floor. I believe for a time it was called the downstairs store. If I recall correctly it was turned into a housewares floor in the 80s prior to the major renovation in the 90s of the whole store including the enclosure of the atrium. Anyone have any additional information or pictures?

Date: Wed, September 21, 2016, 18:18
Posted by: Pete,

Glad to see the Field's supporters out in full force! AWESOME!

Date: Tues, September 20, 2016, 19:37
Posted by: gle,


Date: Mon, September 19, 2016, 8:12 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,


Friday & Saturday, September 9 & 10, 2016

Marking ten years since that very sad day in Chicago and world history alike, when Marshall Field's was officially converted to Macy's.

Although on short notice, we decided to conduct one of our "Selfie Rallies" as we did last holiday season so as to allow supporters to show up (on very short notice, if at all planned) on a flexible schedule. We all thank Tim, Aaron, Gloria, and Lucie for making it all happen!

We were out for about two hours on Friday and distributed close to 200 bookmark flyers and a few dozen pin-on buttons. While Saturday afternoons in September rarely come close to matching the number of people out on State Street that you find during the holiday season, we did speak with over 250 who received our bookmark flyers. Close to 100 pin-on buttons were also distributed. About three dozen posed for photos, some of which are posted below.

We look forward to similar activities on Saturday afternoons in November and December during the holiday season. Please keep in touch with this web site for more details on exact times as they become available.

Here's to the once and future Marshall Field's!

All photos 2016 FieldsFansChicago & Jim McKay Permission for publication granted as long as there is a photo credit.

2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay
2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay 2016 and Jim McKay

Date: Mon, September 19, 2016, 7:56 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,

From a month ago...story speculating what might happen if the River Oak's Macy's (built as Marshall Field's) closes. This is something that myself, "mikea" and others have discussed in the past, along with the likes of Louis Joliet, Stratford, Spring Hill, and Northbrook and/or Hawthorn.

Date: Fri, September 16, 2016, 10:07 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay ,

Chicagist story that only considers the naming aspect of Field's:

Includes Photos of several Field'sFans.

Date: Wed, September 14, 2016, 6:44 pm CT
Posted by: Tony, Hollywood, California,

Regarding the September 8 Press Release and all the activities:

Keep going James! One day it will return!

Date: Tues, September 13, 2016, 11:30 am CT
Posted by: mikea,

It seems the problems the Macy's is going through will really not end until it is either bought up by another company or goes private.

Investment and wall street analysts keep pushing the company to increase profits even though it is profitable. They want higher profits every quarter . If that means selling and closing stores until Macy's is a online only company than that is what they want. Target was forced to sell their department stores to satisfy investors and wall street analysts.

Right now converting back to regional stores would cost the company millions in new investment in rebranding and hiring more associates, along with increased cost of operations. Theses wall street and investor groups would not tolerate this added expense.

They have some problems that are out of their control

1) weather the last year has not been normal for winter and fall and pring

2) International tourism down due to the dollar

3) The new millennial generation does not shop for clothes and fashion as earlier generations did

4) The rise of outlet /offprice stores and the internet sales

5) Macy's reluctance to change to more different merchandise and localize the stores more to local tastes

The biggest though is the hard push by investor activist groups and wall street for higher profits and lower costs at any cost to the customer/and the overall long term health of the company.

Date: Mon, September 12, 2016, 10:04 pm CT
Posted by: Sara,

Sorry!!!!! The guy just sounds too phony to me. Emotional breakdown? I think he's making it up or exaggerating.

Date: Sun, September 11, 2016, 8:44 am CT
Posted by: gle,

WBBM radio gave Field's Fans some good coverage Saturday September 10, and said our selfies would be posted worldwide. They rebroadcasted a short interview about every hour throughout the night.

Date: Sat, September 10, 2016, 15:00
Posted by: A State Street Spectator,

I enjoyed meeting Field's Fans under the clock yesterday evening to once again rally for the return of Chicago's favorite store. The continued support and comments of passers-by is always encouraging and hits home a point--CUSTOMERS STILL MISS MARSHALL FIELD'S AFTER TEN YEARS! I didn't get any comments like, "Why don't you give if up after all this time?" In fact, a few people who never saw us before told me, "How come it took you ten years to get out here? You should have done it long ago!"

Date: Fri, September 09, 2016, 10:40 pm CT
Posted by: DepartmentStoreTime,

Dear Department Store Lovers: The following words are general thoughts and observations offered with great respect for all people concerned including present Macys management. It is our hope and strong desire that there be a sense of encouragement for everyone involved with shopping and managing these great stores we love including the world class Marshall Field & Company ! We respectfully thank you for reading.

First of all, many thanks to all of the people who have offered respectful and insightful suggestions. The warm,caring ,supportive and graceful expressions of desire to make the full-service department store shine include many great accomplishments put forth thanks to this site. From the foundations of Mr.McKays work to manage this site in a classy way, to the creation of Ms.Gayles beautiful book, to the costume displays and all the goodness put forth in honorable ways that make this site so wonderful. Lets hope that the pathway of this site continues in the classy and warm ways always associated with the shoppers,management and staff that continue to try to keep the great spirit of service,style and sophistication of nameplates alive everywhere ! Thanks to family for keeping up with what news there is here. Respectfully,thank you again.

Today,we mark the tenth anniversary of the merger that created the loss of Marshall Fields and many of the other beloved May Department Stores Company department stores around our nation . We are also noting the THIRTIETH anniversary (the year,not the exact day), of the loss of Bamberger's,as we understand it,one of the most successful divisions of the original R.H.Macy & Company !

We dearly miss the full service department store experience of the fabulous in-store restaurants,and the full compliment of in-store services and departments that we could depend every day. We also remember the time when we could be assisted by merchants, rather than cashiers in-store. It was great to see happy co-workers that approached our sales with a team approach. It was nice to not be hounded about signing up for the an in-store credit card multiple times in a day. In addition, we felt comfortable knowing that the stores were clean,comfortable and most certainly very much an inclusive part of the community.

Incidentally, we saw the loss of Bambergers back then as much more than a nameplate change thirty years ago and thats why we were concerned when the name changes occurred ten years ago today! We were worried that a major change of these stores would lead to the kind of things guests encountered during the Bambergers to Macys change. We experienced the loss of many of the different departments, beloved department store restaurants and most of all, the specialized way of doing business and offering service the Bambergers way had changed. We had always cherished the many co-worker merchants that we knew by name.After Bamberger's,they had to handle the service process differently... In fact, it just seemed that the stores we loved that were known to us as Bambergers were close to our hearts because they offered personalized service and the people worked as a team,like family. We loved the localized management and buying and service offerings. After all, the name Bambergers, although owned by Macys was NOT Macys. It was Bambergers ! We have many specific types of examples but again, our aim is to encourage and show respect to all concerned.

We thought it was amazing that the Bambergers stores that we dearly loved were actually owned (since around 1930 incidentally by MACYS !) Bambergers management were allegedly allowed to run their stores as a subsidiary with offices in the Newark,New Jersey flagship store.The store that began WOR radio by the way !

REGARDING MACYS (pre-1995) We loved the traditions of the downtown store although we did not have a wonderful restaurant like the Marshall Fields Walnut Room, Strawbridge & Clothiers Corinthian Room or the John Wanamaker Crystal Tea Room, we did have restaurants to go to throughout the main store. We also enjoyed the other department such as the leased piano department, culinary department including a butcher shop,bakery and gourmet deparment and while very busy,we were thankful for the traditions !

Essentially, what we are marking here is the tenth anniversary of much more than just a name change. After all what is in a name ? We are marking the change in the very fabric of what these once proud nameplates stood for. It just seemed like we were finding more and more reasons not to shop the stores the way we once did because these stores were not and are not the same stores that promised what so many of us took for granted in a department store. Now, ten years later,further complicating some of our stores on the East Coast possibly throughout the country are having their square footage reduced by the addition of Macys discounting concept called Macys Backstage. Considering that there was a fabulous store in the New York/New Jersey area called Sterns,the discount department store with a family flavor and allegedly Federateds division of the year just before it was closed, we cant understand it and would love to better understand what happened considering that Century 21 is in the former flagship of Sterns in New Jersey. What do you think of this development?

Now the positive: We believe in this day of shopping changes and the millennial desire for experiences that Macys Inc. is ahead of the game when it comes to bringing these back into the store. While we know that this department store group offers the kind of things like fireworks,restaurants in some stores ,flower shows and other types of promotions, isnt it true that the biggest thing that these stores have going for them are the multi-generational respected nameplates and their traditions that were a beloved part of their cities. Macys Inc. should be applauded for maintaining the Walnut Room in Chicago, Oak Room in Minneapolis, and most certainly the Wanamaker organ & the light show in Philadelphia. We believe that the restaurant across from the pipe organ should be reopened along with many other full-service restaurants throughout the country be re-opened !

Here is a question.Thinking back,it looked like more people were not marking time with a tap dance or a box step when watching the coverage on the news on this day 10 years ago.Were they ? Let's hope that will be the year of re-dedication to the local department store traditions of America starting with one of the greatest known throughout the world...the amazing and legendary Marshall Field's !

By the way, although Macys has embraced the Thanksgiving Day Parade, it is actually a Bambergers innovation.

We find it interesting that people may not know that it was actually Bamberger's that started the annual Thanksgiving Day parade in Newark,New Jersey ! (Source:

The legacy of the local department stores that mean so much to multiple generations of families EXPERIENCES & TRADITIONS that are valued not only in the pocketbook but in the heart ! We hope that the future brings great excitement and experiences to look forward to.Cordially,with respect,we thank you.

Date: Fri, September 09, 2016, 3:18 pm CT
Posted by: Field's Fan,

Mentions Field's Fans.

Marshall Field's Lives On At Macy's, 10 Years After The Big Name Change

Date: Fri, September 09, 2016, 00:27
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

The incoming macy CEO has a challenging task ahead of him:

Mr Gennette would be wise to undo some of the changes made by his arrogant predecessor. Bringing in Starbucks isn't going to help. Perhaps restoring some of the beloved regional stores with their traditions, marketing and merchandising. Do what department stores did back in the day to attract customers--make themselves a destination. The ill-conceived plan to force a coast-to-coast cookie cutter store into numerous regions has been an abject failure. Here's a suggestion, Mr Gennette--give the customers what THEY want, and it's painfully obvious they DON'T want macy!

Perhaps someone could write a book on "The Misadventures of Macy" which would document how one person could be the single handed cause of the closure of hundreds of department stores, the loss of thousands of jobs, the cost of millions of dollars in tax revenue, and the destruction of popular shopping venues. In retrospect, his legacy will be the massive destruction of iconic department stores across the nation. In so many cities, the local stores were part of the history and culture. Looking at recent news articles and reader comments, the New York store featured in a vintage holiday movie hasn't been a success in other markets as attested by its continuing decline in market share. His grand vision of saving a few dollars on shopping bags has been decimated by losing billions in sales and in falling stock prices.

Good luck and best wishes to Mr Gennette! If he truly wants to "save the company," he should restore what was so callously thrown away.

Date: Fri, September 8, 2016, 11:05 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Although the list of store closings has not been announced, this mall operator is seeking replacements for macy locations:

Online shopping has hurt traditional retailers, but macy does nothing to attract shoppers. One wonders if the "genius" hadn't converted all the popular regional stores (including those owned by Federated) into macy if so many store closings and major job losses would have been necessary.

Date: Thurs, September 08, 2016, 11:33 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

(See you Friday after work or Saturday Noon/Early Afternoon)


(CHICAGO-September 8, 2016)

Fields Fans Chicago Mark 10 Years Since Marshall Fields Became Macys With Selfies Rally Supporting Fields Return

When: Fri, 9.9.2016, 46 pm AND
Sat, 9.10.2016, Noon2:30 pm

Where: Under the Great Marshall Field Clock, State & Washington Streets.

For more information:
Phone: Jim McKay, (Area Code Three One Two) Nine Two Seven -Four Four Two Four
Email: jjmckay AT
Instagram: FieldsFansChicago
Twitter: @FieldsFansChgo


WHAT: The grass roots group, FieldsFansChicago will mark the 10th anniversary of the loss of Chicagos Marshall Fields with a Selfies Rally to support the return of the internationally renowned emporium experience.

WHAT WILL HAPPEN: All who support the return of Marshall Field and Company are encouraged to stop by under the Great Marshall Fields Clock at State and Washington and pose for a selfie holding a protest sign supporting Fields return. These selfies will be posted to our world-wide social media channels.

Past Selfies Rallies supporting the return of Marshall Fields featured hundreds underneath the Great Clock at State and Washington at holidays and also at civic events such as the Chicago St Patricks Day Parades and Chicago Pride Parade. Last holidays Selfies Rally for Fields featured over 120 selfies featuring over 200 participants and received global response. Please see

WHO IS FIELD'S FANS CHICAGO? Fields Fans Chicago is a grass roots organization supporting the return of Marshall Field and Company to Chicagos State Street. Just some of its activities include

- SPEAK AT MACYS MEETINGS: Since 2008, making the case for Marshall Fields Return to Macys stockholders, directors, CEO, and senior execs in Cincinnati at the conclusion of each annual meeting.

- FLYER & BUTTON DISTRIBUTION: Since 2006, distribution of over 175,000 bookmark flyers and 145,000 pin on buttons supporter the return of Marshall Fields to State Street.

- RALLIES featuring up to 400 participants on State Street.

MEDIA COVERAGE REPRESENTING TOURISTS, SHOPPERS featured in over 1,000 publications--BBC World Service, Chicago Tribune, Chicago Sun-Times, US Network News Coverage on CBS News, ABC News, New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, all Chicago local news shows, and many others world-wide.

2,000 SURVEYED on the street from 2009-2012. 4 of 5 prefer Marshall Field's.

Jim McKay is the primary spokesperson for Fields Fans Chicago and an expert on the switch from Marshall Field's to Macy. McKay has over 25 years experience in Design, Architectural, Community Affairs, branding, and retail consulting. He has taught at major universities including University of Illinois, UIC, and Illinois Institute of Technology.

FieldsFansChicago is solely responsible for the content of this press release. It is not connected with nor endorsed by Marshall Fields, Macy's, Inc., or others.



Date: Mon, September 05, 2016, 10:45 pm CT
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

We can all speculate which stores Macy's will close. I doubt many if any wI'll be former Field's locations. Field's owned all their stores except Mayfair, river oaks and water tower. That counts for alot. If you own the real estate, stores think twice before closing. Even laggard stores like spring hill are owned and that mall is under a 45 million dollar rehab.

Field's was Co developer of water tower, so they probably hAve a gazillion lease.

Date: Thurs, September 01, 2016, 2:25 pm CT
Posted by: inetryconydot,

Hi to all visitors forum. I want to share with you the latest news about MTV Video Music Awards.

Since MTV revived its highest honor the Michael Jackson Video Vanguard Award at the networks annual Video Music Awards in 2011, it has gone to Britney Spears, Justin Timberlake, Beyonce and Kanye West, a lineup of artists who, from the beginning of their careers, understood the power of a well-executed music video.

Thats partly because of their ages: Like MTV, Ms. Spears, Mr. Timberlake and Beyonce were born in 1981, and Mr. West was born in 1977. Theyre old enough to have lived through the era in which MTV dominance was integral to a pop stars ascendance. Even if the channels relationship with music was in decline during the peak of their own careers, they understood its legacy, and executed top-notch videos accordingly.

Please move topic if forums this was not chosen correctly.

Date: Tues, August 30, 2016, 5:57 pm CT
Posted by: Ken A,

short, but interesting story about Macy's, and it's market share in the St. Louis Metro area. What's noteworthy here is he fact that the article reports that Dillard's and Nordstrom gained in this market while Macy's has lost share. I say this as back in 1984 one of they key reasons why ADG sold Stix,Baer and Fuller, to Dillards was their loss of market share to Famous-Barr.

Date: Tues, August 30, 2016, 5:54 pm CT
Posted by: A Few Links,'s original report:

Macys recently announced its decision to close nearly 100 stores across the United States, suggesting that the still-growing influence of e-commerce is lessening the need for a strong brick and mortar presence. The company did not indicate which stores it would be closing, stating that the company would announce its decisions at a later date. We at 1010data didnt want to wait so, using our Local Market Intelligence (LMI) product, we examined where Macys business has declined the most and, if possible, attempted to understand some of the drivers behind their decline.


More stories


Here's when we'll know which Macy's stores are closing

Aug 30, 2016, 3:01pm EDT

Andy Brownfield


Cincinnati Business Courier


Shoppers, investors and people who follow the Cincinnati-based retail giant Macy's Inc. will have to wait until after the 2016 holiday shopping season to find out if their local stores are closing.


Are these the cities where Macy's is closing stores?

Aug 25, 2016, 12:58pm EDT

Andy Brownfield


Cincinnati Business Courier


Full Article


Macys is closing 100 stores: Does yours stand a chance?


Macy's stores near Detroit: Are they among most likely to close in U.S.?

Date: Sat, August 27, 2016, 10:12 pm CT
Posted by: John Brocato,

I am not surprised about the sales decline in St. Louis. At first I was impressed with Macy's when they took over from Famous-Barr. However, they have let their stores go downhill the past five years, most notably downsizing and then closing the downtown store. Macy's has also closed three other stores in the St. Louis suburbs.

Last Christmas season the Macy's stores did not feel festive. They have overdone the "Letters to Santa" campaign and need a fresh theme.

I really hope Chicago finds a way to get Marshall Field's back. Well-run downtown department stores are a treasure.

Date: Sat, August 27, 2016, 7:47 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Simply closing stores isn't going to solve all the problems at macy.

Date: Sat, August 27, 2016, 16:32
Posted by: Jim McKay ,


The Nordstrom opening does not figure into the report that said Macy's sales drop 14%. 14% is between 2014 and 2015. Nordstrom did not open until last fall 2015.

Date: Sat, August 27, 2016, 2:55 pm
Posted by: Mary,

Macy's opened a second Milwaukee store over four years ago at Southdale. Mayfair Macy's is no doubt impacted by Nordstrom which is actually already open, not under construction as Phil indicated. As in Chicago, a certain segment of Marshall Field shoppers, not to mention staff, have moved to Nordstrom. On top of that, both Macy's competes with Boston Store locations that were recently remodeled. Boston Store is the brand Carson's parent Bon Ton used in Milwaukee. Bon Ton is co-headquartered in Milwaukee. Hometown store. I'm sure those two competitors have taken market from Macy's, but if any store closes, I would expect the new one and not Mayfair to close.

Date: Fri, August 26, 2016, 11:48 pm Ct
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

Biggest Macy's decrease is milwaukee, that would be Field's at Mayfair, Field's did not have any other stores there. Ma fair was one of Field's top doors. Nordstrom is now building a huge store there. Macy's junk doesn't cut it.

Date: Thurs, August 25, 2016, 4:36 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Shopping at macy is likely to get more confusing and frustrating:

I just dont understand this at all. So Backstage is part of a macy store but has its own entrance doors and buying team. Last Act is located in a macy store but is just marked down regular merchandise from the store, different than regular "clearance" merchandise but adjacent to it. Will their numerous coupons be accepted at Backstage, or will they provide different promotions? Shoppers are already upset that coupons are accepted on clearance items but not on Last Act. To make room for Backstage, macy will have to cut back on its regular stock items. With all the discount and clearance sections, how does macy think it's going to promote itself as a "premium" department store? Will better merchandise lines want to be associated with a discounter?

Somehow this will play out like the fiasco at JCPenney where the store lost its way and shoppers moved on. The complex pricing games and unfamiliar merchandise pushed JCP toward bankruptcy. I also think it's insulting to other regions of the country when macy picked the names "Last Act" and "Backstage" which are clearly references to New York.

Memo to macy: Clearly your grand plan to bring convert all the regional department stores to an outpost of New York has been an epic fail. The rest of the nation is NOT in love with or impressed by your New York "magic." Give the shoppers what THEY want!

Date: Wed, August 24, 2016, 6:56 pm CT
Posted by: Pete,

Another analyst has its own study on where Macy's may be closing.

Macy's is closing 100 stores here's where they will likely shut down

Milwaukee, Detroit, Pittsburgh, and St. Louis are among those with the steepest decline in sales in the past couple years. There's a map. The green areas seem to be doing best if I'm reading that right. Chicago was yellow which I think means so so.

Date: Tues, August 23, 2016, 6:07 pm CT
Posted by: jai skot,

here's a thought -

perhaps an appeal to "raised in Evanston" Jeremy Piven to consider reviving his PBS 'Mister Selfridge' in a PREquel, going back to the Marshall Field 'roots', which then might in turn garner enough interest that the Weston Family Group that restored Selfridges might be enticed to do the same for Field's

Date: Tues, August 23, 2016, 5:21 pm CT
Posted by: jai skot,

went on line to do my periodic search trying to track down any lead that might take me to a magic place where some possible substitute for any of what were Marshall Field's unique comestibles available on the 7th floor Food Court - might yet be found.

and happened to come across this web-site.

spent more time than I had reading posts triggering a plethora of fond memories.

not one to usually succumb to such nostalgia, but as most here would no doubt agree, Marshall Fields 'the special exception' to most rules.

Already a loyal Fields advocate for years, was so taken aback my first trip to London, and stepping into Selfridges, the imposing columns so familiar, as was so much else; my initial reaction having been one of: 'oh, THIS must be where Field's got it's ideas and inspiration,' that is until the greater shock reading on one of the larger posters in their own restaurant area, that it had been the other way round, and Harry Selfridges had been a Marshall Field's man first.

so many posts here with individuals waxing nostalgic about the 'bygone days' harking back to the '60s but not even including THE FAIR, or mention of STOP&SHOP, the up-scale neighbour of HILMANS, the former having the most exotic items that one would have had to go to London or Paris to find.

... the bygone era when Field's still had their 3rd floor "waiting room",

where among other long since obsolete services, one could find BLANK checks from ANY of the cities banks, 'just in case' one had run out or left their own at home ... this was also a period when even I thought a favourite high school teacher unbelievably 'old fashioned' when she declined an invitation to join my friends & I for lunch at the Walnut Room because [ wait for it ] she had not brought a pair of gloves with her that day ... we might not be flying round in Jetson space-mobiles, but could we possibly be anymore removed from a past which this old man's mind still is not THAT long ago.

Date: Thurs, August 18, 2016, 10:49 am CT
Posted by: Jim,

What's fascinating about Macy's top 150 doors list is, according to this document, these 150 stores account for about 50% of all of Macy's sales.

James McKay Ernesto: Regarding Northbrook vs Hawthorn or any stores, there's also the consideration of the terms of the leases. In general, one store might be busier but the other may sell fewer but more expensive items. Generally, I hear Northbrook is a more prestigious "A-list" mall while Hawthorne is viewed as "B-tier." More complicated is that Field's fit in well with the class of other stores at Northbrook while Macy's is more in line with the class of stores at Hawthorn. That's a factor why JCP didn't do so well and moved out of Northbrook. I wouldn't be surprised if one of the Macy's closes. That said, I would say that River Oaks, Joliet, Stratford, Spring HIll and the furniture stores near Oak Brook and Woodfield are most vulnerable to closing. Then again, the two furniture stores could be viewed like mattress stores--and heaven knows how all those Mattress Firms co-exist successfully, yet Mattress Firm recently said in the Tribune recently that they do.

Date: Thurs, August 18, 2016, 10:09 am CT
Posted by: Ernesto C.,

It's also good to take a look at stores where Macy's has just given up, stores either slated by corporate for an upcoming closure or lease to expire or just not maintained well.... The 2 stores that come to mind are Stratford and Northbrook. If you go to these locations compared to other better kept stores like Hawthorn or Orland, I think the writing's on the wall for some of these stores, not to mention being in malls that are struggling doesn't help. Sad to see Northbrook in the condition it's in, it was a beautiful store when it opened.

Date: Wed, August 17, 2016, 11:44 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,


Back in May 2015, after some announcements by Macy's, Inc., myself and others discussed their new concept of "top 150 doors"

Thanks to Ken Allen [ on one of Facebook's historic department stores groups ] who unearthed amongst all the material on Macy's website a list of what these "top 150 doors" are. You will note of former Chicagoland Marshall Fields locations that State Street and Water Tower are in the top tier of the top 150, or "Platinun". Platinum doors are there most profitable stores. Oak Brook is a "Market Leader" which is the next tier of the 150. Then under the category of "other top doors" are Old Orchard and Woodfield. The PDF that is linked below describes the categories a better than I informally have. As I noted last week after the conference calls, these are among the stores I would be shocked if they closed. (Of course, some of you know that I once worked for a discount department store chain and one of their top 10 stores--one of my stores--had to close for very unusual reasons.).

Date: Wed, August 17, 2016, 6:21 pm CT
Posted by: gle,

PBS "Chicago Tonight" discussed Macy's possible store closings on August 16. Neil Stern from the retail consulting firm of McMillan Doolittle said likely Macy's will want to get through the holidays and then announce which stores will close. Host Eddie Arruza asked if it was a mistake for Macy's to overtake some of the very legendary department stores. Stern replied that Macy's was growing, but "Now I think they are stuck with a bland sort of centralized kind of store at a time when you want to be more unique." He added, "So that Marshall Field's asset probably would be very valuable to them now to bring back some of the things that Marshall Field's did well, which was a unique store, unique experience, great customer service. I think Macy's has lost that along the way." Stern pointed out that his firm has worked with Mariano's, which has added piano bars etc. in an effort to get people to leave their computers and come into the store.

It seems like people are noticing what customers have been trying to say for 10 years.

Date: Tue, August 16, 2016, 9:09 pm CT
Posted by: Sara B.,

This guy always seems to have an excuse. That probably goes for bringing back Marshall Field and Company.
The Eternal Optimism of Macy's CEO, Year After Year, Is Really Hard to Watch

Date: Sun, August 14, 2016, 7:30 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Here's what Macy's has to do with the stores it isn't closing

Rosenthal seems cautious in mentioning Field's, but good article. Please leave comments afterwards if you have the Tribune login. It helps our cause.

Date: Sun, August 14, 2016, 7:16 am CT
Posted by: David D.,

It is fascinating to watch Macy's most recent announcement about store closings and the strong reaction in the media to them. Focusing on cutting costs through store closings will leave a structure of fixed costs spread across less stores overall.

In other news my tribute page to Marshall Field is now up and running!

Date: Sun, August 14, 2016, 10:33 am CT
Posted by: Michael R.,

Interesting read.
Store Wars
Over the next three years, New York City’s vaunted department stores are reimagining themselves for the future of luxury shopping—and will soon face stiff competition from a couple of out-of-towners: Neiman Marcus and Nordstrom WSJ.COM|BY CHRISTINA BINKLEY

Date: Sat, August 13, 2016, 12:03 pm CT
Posted by: Steve Ginardi,

Below was my comment on the CNBC site regarding the closing of the 100 Macy's stores.

"Keeping local department store brands along with their quality service and merchandise (eg. Marshall Fields in Chicago) instead of re-branding and dumbing down everything to Macy's, would have averted much of the damage that has occurred to Macy's over the past 10 years! A Macy's "everywhere" does not make for a unique shopping experience!"

You can help Field's return by leaving your own comments after the article,

Date: Fri, August 12, 2016, 12:42 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Glenn H.

Thanks for the correction. I did a little digging and found that that the building that currently houses the Macy's Men's Store was constructed in 1974 as the San Francisco flagship of Hawaii-based Liberty House. Liberty House had previously acquired J. Magnin. Perhaps you are saying that the site was previously a J. Magnin store. In 1984, Liberty House closed the store as it retreated from the West Coast to concentrate on the Pacific. Macy's ended up purchasing it and putting the men's departments there, much in the same way as Field's had moved its men's departments to the southwest corner of Washington and Wabash. Now, as Field's had done several decades ago, Macy's is bringing the Men's departments back into the main Union Square store which incorporates I. Magnin's 1940's flagship. Here's a link to a photo of when the Macy's Mens Store at Union Square was Liberty House and another as it is recently.



Again, thank you.

Date: Fri, August 12, 2016, 11:56 am CT
Posted by: GlennH,

Jim, slight correction regarding your Aug 11th post. The SF Union Square stand-alone Men's Store in negotiation for sale is not the former I Magnin flagship, but rather the former Joseph Magnin store (easily confused, but different establishments).

The former Joseph Magnin (currently Macy's Men's Store annex) is at 120 Stockton---across the street eastward from the main store. The former I Magnin flagship is north of the main store, at the corner of Stockton & Geary--facing Union Square. There is no space between the latter two structures, and I believe when Macy's purchased I Magnin, they installed doorways between the two.

Date: Thurs, August 11, 2016, 4:52 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Latest Tribune article with comments by Macy's Andrea Schwartz. Be sure to leave comments after the article if you are able. It helps.
Macy's to Close 100 Stores

Date: Thurs, August 11, 2016, 3:47 pm CT
Posted by: Paully,

Extensive story on Field's Fans the stores closures at Chicagoist website. We represent our cause well!
Macy's Is Closing 100 Stores. Where Does That Leave Marshall Field's Loyalists?

Date: Thurs, August 11, 2016, 12:40 pm CT
Posted by: Erick Johnson,

Lundgren's retail philosphy of bigger is better is shrinking and failing. I miss Marshall Fields. I'm crossing my fingers that Macy's new CEO will reverse Lundgren's decision and bring back this retail icon.

Date: Thurs, August 11, 2016, 12:00
Posted by: John,

It even made the news in England. I am disgusted this man has lasted so long in retail. I think what he did was just as stupid as the marriage between Sears and Kmart. His arrogance, which you can tell he has a great deal of even from pictures, shows he should have been put out to pasture a while ago. Something tells me the board at Macy's is terrified of him.

Date: Thurs, August 11, 2016, 11:08
Posted by: Mikea,

Heard the news about the store closings. The main problem is what this will do to the malls, the communities where these stores are located. I know especially in CA there are way to many stores close together. I expect a number of Bloomingdales will close too.

I expect Spring Hill, Stratford River Oaks and maybe Joliet will close in this area. Spring Hill Stratford, and River Oaks have been loosing tenents and those malls are going down fast. I would not be surprised if the Bloomingdale's at Medinah and Old Orchard close too.

The rise of Amazon and the less shopping mentality of the younger generation is to blame. I expect more store closing s from Bon-Ton, Nordstrom, Kohls, Dillards, Sears and JC Penney. I just don't know what to expect in the future , if we are going to be a generation that justs sits at home ordering everything online from our computers. The job losses is my biggest concern along with the loss of sales tax revenue for the cities and the states.

Companies have a responsibility to the communitites they serve and I guess Macy's justs does not care at all.

Date: Thurs, August 11, 2016, 8:19 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Be sure to comment after ALL of the articles that you will see today before your comment here by mentioning Marshall Field's. Here you preach to the choir.
Macy's to Close About 15% of Stores, Cut Jobs
Macy's also intends to sell the Union Sqaure Men's Store. The Men's Store at Union Square is adjacent to the San Francisco flagship that once was the I. Magnin flagship. It's sort of like the separate Marshall Field's Mens Store at Washington and Wabash.

Closing 10-20 stores after Christmas is no big deal; closing 100 or 15% of their stores is a big deal. No specific locations yet but I'd expect that Louis Joliet, Spring Hill, Stratford, and Hawthorn, along with Oak Brook Furniture and Woodfield Furniture are among those vulnerable.

Nothing about State Street was mentioned but they will have their conference call at 9 am Chicago time, accessible at under the ivestors relations section.

Jim McKay


jjmckay AT me DOT com

Date: Wed, August 03, 2016, 5:31 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Macy's will have a new Chief Legal Officier, Elisa Garcia. She replaces legal officier Dennis Broderick who was with Federated since 1990. Broderick was CLO for Federated's acquisition of R.H. Macy and Co. in 1994 as well as when May Department Stores and Marshall Field's were acquired 11 years ago. So it's a change of the guard.

Garcia comes from Office Depot where she has been since 2007. Before that, she was with Domino's Pizza for seven years.

The official press release can be found at:

Date: Wed, August 03, 2016, 11:04 am CT
Posted by: Mike R., Macy's, Kohl's, Nordstrom shares fall
Shares of Macy's Inc., Nordstrom Inc. and Kohl's Corp. fell on Tuesday after reports about weak summer sales reignited fears of a department-store slump.

Macy’s, the biggest department-store company, suffered a sales downturn in July, following improving trends in late May and June, Cleveland Research said in a note.


Date: Tues, August 02, 2016, 11:29 pm CT
Posted by: Anna P,

I guess Macy's no longer has Glamorama. Instead it seems they have something called Fashion's Front Row, now based in NYC. Glamorama used to be a lot of fun in the Twin Cities and in Chicago. Too bad. Remember when the B-52s headlined?

Date: Sun, July 31, 2016,  9:03 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Mark M.: just do a search for branded items at macys . com if you're interested in seeing certain store names--but of course I do not endorse buying them. I believe that you are a fan of Hudson's. Remember that Hudson's, and Dayton's, and certain related intellectual property including branding associated with those two still belong to Target Corporation. That's why and still take you to For reasons that I won't go into, there's other store names that are also not owned by Macy's even though one would think they would be. So except for discussing the fate of the Hudson's Veterans plaque that Macy's inherited when they acquired Northland, I don't think Macy's mentions Hudsons at all. Target remains the curator of Hudson's history.

Date: Sun, July 31, 2016,  2:11 am CT
Posted by: Mark M.,

Jim McKay: I can't find the Heritage brands section on

Date: Sat, July 30, 2016, 7:23 am CT
Posted by: Field's Watcher,

Hedge fund takes loss by exiting Macy's after 2016 guidance aka projections of success are reduced.

Date: Thurs, July 28, 2016, 6:18 pm CT
Posted by: Gabriel M.,

[Regarding Jim McKay's post about Retro Department Stores/Strategic Marks and Macy's:]

This is one of the greatest events in recent American retail history. I was very happy that day.

It will never be the same without the original, historic downtown stores. Unfortunately, unlike State Street, they can't be brought back. The flagships of these chains have now been repurposed.

Mall stores aren't special in any sense.

Date: Thurs, July 28, 2016, 6:16 pm CT
Posted by: Gabriel M.,

Regarding Retro Department Stores, it will never be the same without the original, historic downtown stores. Unfortunately, unlike State Street, they can't be brought back. The flagships of these chains have now been repurposed.

Mall stores aren't special in any sense.

Date: Thurs, July 28, 2016, 5:57 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

As proud curators of the Marshall Field's legacy they outsourced the MF&Co archives to the Chicago History Museum--that's what proud curators do?

Date: Thurs, July 28, 2016, 5:53 pm CT
Posted by: Michael D.,

In the Pedway, [there's an exhibit of American Victorial Stained Glass co-spoonsored by the Smith Museum of Stained Glass Windows, Chicago Cultural Mile Association.] Information posters say, "A proud curator of Marshall Field's legacy, Macy's..."

Date: Thurs, July 28, 2016, 5:50 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Regarding the settlement between Macy's, Inc. and Strategic Marks, it looks like things are now final and in full gear.

Strategic Marks’ now only shows the names as agreed in the settlement: Jordan Marsh, Bullock's, Robinsons, I. Magnin & Co., Joseph Magnin, Bamberger's, Foley's, and May Company. They are selling T-shirts with logos for these stores. They have also removed some other names that they used to show on the site but apparently are with Macy's.

Meanwhile, it appears that the "Heritage Brands" section of no longer offers the t-shirts and bags that they used to offer for these names. However, they still have the t-shirts, names and bags for Marshall Field's, Filene's, etc. that they have had going back for at least four years.

Date: Thurs, July 28, 2016, 5:27 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

It's been a few months since I last looked at Macy's site for its tourist stores, but it seems to have some updates. They now do mention Marshal Field's in at least three places but they still seem overall to be reluctant to mention Marshall Field's. The three places they mention Field's is including the "Marshall Field and Company" plaque with the exterior great columns on State Street; a claim that at State Street, some harken back to Marshall Field's days by calling Macy's "Santaland" "Cozy Cloud" (they left out "cottage"; and they tell how Marshall Field commissioned the clocks because people were leaving notes in the cracks of the windows, I assume to confirm meeting up. (I wonder if who ever wrote this realizes that the clock Marshall Field commissioned is not the two that have been there the past hundred years.)

Macy's Chicago State Street Visitors Site

On the one hand, it's a touch better than a few years ago when about the only time they mentioned Marshall Field's was to say that the founder didn't want to build the Burnham Fountain that was eventually added in the 1990s.

The description also drops a line that there is also another Macy's on Michigan Avenue. (Since anyone I know who still shops Macy's just goes there for stuff rather than experience, I guess that it's State Street and the birthplace of the modern department store doesn't really matter since those types just want "stuff"!

On the other hand, the descriptions of other tourist Macy's stores aren’t afraid to mention predecessors. Philadelphia Center City isn't shy at all about mentioning Wanamaker's and discussing it's history, although it's worded such that you would think the store's design by Daniel Turnham was the first of its kind when in fact, it's mostly a clone of Burnham's design originated at Marshall Field's on State Street.

For Boston, they mention that the store used to be the Jordan Marsh flagship.

For Union Square (San Francisco) they mention how the store originated for just 19 years as O'Connor, Moffat, and Company and was converted to Macy's. They also discuss how it expanded in the former I.Magnin flagship, a brand which R.H. Macy & Co. folded.

Again, the bottom line is that on State Street is so much more valuable when it's run as Marshall Field's to the point it's an international destination. What a shame. Perhaps, though, it's not treated as badly as downtown Minneapolis. The former Dayton's flagship isn’t even listed on Macy's tourist page.

Date: Wed, July 27, 2016, 8:01 pm CT
Posted by: Marcia Long,

It's been a few years but I wanted to see if you all were still here. Keep it up!

Date: Mon, July 25, 2016, 9:03 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

A co-worker and some of her friends recently vacationed in New York City. They saw some Broadway shows, did some sightseeing and spend some time shopping. I asked her if they visited the flagship Herald Square macy. She replied, "Of course NOT. Nobody wanted to go to macy. That store is nothing special any more since it's everywhere."

This is just an example of six women tourists who had no interest in what was once a NYC icon. How many THOUSANDS of tourists have no interest in visiting other department stores that were once destinations in their respective cities? Clearly macy is no longer an attraction to domestic or international tourists; in addition to destroying the value of beloved regional stores, macy diluted its own reputation.

Date: Sun, July 24, 2016, 12:40 pm CT
Posted by: gle,

I loved the experience of Marshall Field's, and I'm not Millennial. I always walked through the store, just to be there, even if I didn't think I needed something at the time. Field's was an experience, Selfridge's is an experience and now Mariano's is an experience. Hey, bring on the experience. Bring back Field's!

Date: Sat, July 23, 2016, 12:21 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Millennials only want to spend money on one thing — and it's killing Macy's

"Macy's has a problem: It's not a laser-tag center or a Cheesecake Factory.Millennials prefer to spend their money on experiences, not the apparel that is Macy's bread and butter. "


Millennials will spend money on an experience? Golly! That's what Marshall Field's was know for world-wide--being Chicgao's number three destination and a world-class experiential emporium. Moreover, look at all of our many, many photos and you see Millennials who are holding signs to bring back Marshall Field's. What a waste not restore such a unique experience that only Macy's or someone who knew what they were doing with a top stochholder asset could have. Screams "Exclusive experience that Millennials want!"

Date: Fri, July 22, 2016, 8:29 am CT
Posted by: Holly J.,

Macy's is now hoping artificial intelligence and talking to one's smartphone will revive sales. Hey! How about bringing back Marshall Field's!? That would be so easy and so successful! Apparently ten locations are part of the trial. None are former Marshall Field's.

Macy's New Answers App Powered by IBM's Watson

The Macy's (NYSE: M) customer service person who answers your next question for the retailer may not in fact be human. The company has begun testing "Macy's On Call," a tool that allows customers ...

Macy's to offer customers artificial intelligence-powered help at Mall of Georgia, Lenox Square

Date: Wed, July 20, 2016, 8:01 pm CT
Posted by: Field's Watcher,

Macy's will announce its 2nd quarter 2016 results on Thursday, August 11th at 9 a.m. Chicago time. There is a web cast where you can listen for free. Follow the links to the "Investors" section at the black-colored navigation at Macy's corporate site at, not

Macy's, Inc. is formerly Federated Department Stores, founded in the late 1920s. Bloomingdale's is its oldest current brand dating almost back to the founding. Macy's, Inc., nee Federated, has only owned Macy's brand since 1994.

Date: Wed, July 20, 2016, 3:07 am CT
Posted by: Karen Thompson,

We miss Marshall Field's. It's sad to see the home of such a beautiful, amazing place filled by a vanilla store. What a mistake!!!

Date: Mon, July 18, 2016, 1:43 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Oh, seems that macy is looking to create more "shareholder value" by selling off yet another iconic downtown location:

Is The Downtown Macy's Building Portland's Next?

Consumers are abandoning shopping malls and there is a trend toward invigorating downtown areas, yet macy isn't capitalizing on this trend by making their downtown stores a destination for millenials who are bored with malls. The old school merchants realized that shopping had to be entertainment to draw consumers; macy offers mostly acres of women's apparel which can be found anywhere. Sales and stock values decline because macy is not an attraction.

Watch out, Chicago! macy knows they can "increase shareholder value" by selling off prime real estate, and they have a track record of running a store into the ground, declaring it unprofitable then making a nice profit from its closure and sale.

Date: Thurs, July 14, 2016, 3:50 am CT
Posted by: Gail White,

That is a good article, Dave.

I fear that Macy's will do the same eventually with State St. Marshall Field's. I think The current CEO doesn't want to change the store because any big shift looks like he failed. Of course, he did. But I worry once there is the new CEO in place in the next year, he won't care what happens because the massive screwup won't be blamed on him but the CEO of the past 10 years.

I also think that guy from Target who then went to Apple stores and then to JCPenney was unfairly derided. He was right about all the stupid business with couponing and never ending sales. In fact, I recall that Macy's tried to do the same thing about nine years ago, but people wouldn't listen. The JCPenney guy should have done it much, much, much more slowly. The problem with department stores right now is that they've cut back their service so much that they have effectively become not much more than a discount store with a few shops you would find at the mall like LensCrafters at Macy's.

I also disagree with Phillip. There are contemporary businesses do well and are consistent with Marshall Field's because they offer good service. Mariano's is indeed a good example. So is Wegman's on the East Coast. I had put Von Maur also in the same category. I don't think everybody who was working at State street 25 to 30 years ago needs to come back. Just a handful. That's very realistic. I also get tired of Pondens saying that Marshall Field can't come back. It's a great, world-class brand. The scenario that MikeA describes, his point of view, is that of a Macy's bean counter. The bean counter mentality is what is killing department stores.


Date: Wed, July 13, 2016, 10:01 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Another analysis on how macy has lost its "magic":

Let's all hope the new executive will realize that macy*fication of the nation's department stores was an ill-advised, irreversible mistake and that the ONLY way the company will survive is to GIVE THE SHOPPERS WHAT THEY WANT--and it ISN'T macy!

Date: Wed, July 13, 2016, 9:51 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

To mikea:

The downtown Pittsburgh macy store was the top moneymaker in the Kaufmann's chain; macy deliberately ran the store into the ground then sold the building off because they claimed the store wasn't profitable.

Downtown is growing with new apartment buildings and offices under construction. The city is sponsoring numerous activities to attract people and a well managed department store, stocked with merchandise to meet the needs of downtown workers and residents, would be very successful. macy had no interest in making the store successful. Truth be told, macy isn't very popular in Pittsburgh because the market already has much better discount and clearance stores.

Date: Wed, July 13, 2016, 9:36 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

The constant discounting and continuous sales at macy have hurt sales at better department stores like Nordstrom:

Because of all the discounts, many premium brands have lost their status appeal and shoppers are not willing to pay full price. Michael Kors is one brand that has been hurt because macy discounts have cheapened its image.

The macy*fication has been a epic fail. The initial profitability was based on cutbacks in staffing and services, was later sustained by substitution of lower quality merchandise then was followed by extreme discounting. Sales and stock prices continue to plummet as macy fails to draw any interest from consumers. Their weekly One Day Sales and TV ads screaming out prices aren't working.

Date: Wed, July 13, 2016, 9:34 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

The constant discounting and continuous sales at macy have hurt sales at better department stores like Nordstrom:

Because of all the discounts, many premium brands have lost their status appeal and shoppers are not willing to pay full price. Michael Kors is one brand that has been hurt because macy discounts have cheapened its image.

The macy*fication has been a epic fail. The initial profitability was based on cutbacks in staffing and services, was later sustained by substitution of lower quality merchandise then was followed by extreme discounting. Sales and stock prices continue to plummet as macy fails to draw any interest from consumers. Their weekly One Day Sales and TV ads screaming out prices aren't working.

Date: Mon, July 11, 2016, 1:16 pm CT
Posted by: mikea,

Just got back from a CUbs weekend in Pittsburgh. They had their bicentennial going on with great fireworks. Downtown was lively and full. It is horrible how Macy's for a one time short term profit closed the entire downtown store and thumbing their nose on the city of Pittsburgh.

Most locals are not happy with what they did. Reading that analysts want Macy's to sell and lease back their stores which would prompt many more closings and job losses.

Also the story of the Muslim woman detained and charged $500.00 to go home for doing nothing wrong is criminal. Macy's security staff should be prosecuted for these false arrests and detentions.

Profiling innocent people is really good PR. Maybe the new chief will shake things up!!!

Date: Sun, July 10, 2016, 11:41 pm CT
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

Jim and others

There are so many things that you have taken out of context or mistated. However, you do not understand fields had rafts of buyers beyond modern standards. They had women with mild mental issues knitting zandra Rhodes sweaters, buckets of women k nitting for the country shop. I'm not wishing the buyers come back to 30 years ago, just that fields had buyers that would be really hard to duplicate. That said, without the continued tradition,it will go away

I guess I'm stupid, but I don't get your nasty comments Pete, I'm just a fourth generation fields shopper, not a bitter employee.

Date: Sat, July 09, 2016, 6:56 pm CT
Posted by: Paula ,

I've driven by several shopping centers recently noticed that both TJ Maxx and Marshalls are right nearby or even across the street from each other. Why couldn't have Macy's existed with Marshall Field and Company?

Date: Fri, July 08, 2016, 6:51 pm CT
Posted by: An observant shopper,

In response to Jim's July 4 comments about Mariano's newer employees: I live around the corner from the Ravenswood Mariano's. Many of its employees are so young they could never have worked at Dominick's, but do a bang-up good job. Someone has trained them well. That store is THE place to be in the neighborhood, and I believe that could still happen with Field's on State Street.

Date: Fri, July 08, 2016, 6:38 pm CT
Posted by: gle,

I am shocked by the "Cincinnati Business Courier" article mentioned in the July 1 post by Joan S. about Macy's detaining and fining suspected shoplifters. We all know Macy's is hard up for cash, but this is so disgusting I wouldn't even imagine it of them if the facts weren't right there for all to read.

Date: Tues, July 05, 2016, 1:11 pm CT
Posted by: mikea,

To Pete and Phil's comments. Yes the Fields that most want here comes from the Batus era, which is like a Bloomingdale's. Maybe Macy's could convert the Bloomingdale's' stores to the Field's name and have Bloomingdale's run those stores.

It would be extremely expensive to start a whole new division with merchandising, advertising. The problem that people here are not addressing is the changing retail climate especially with the millenials.

Not only is Macy's Inc having a slowdown in sales, but Nordstrom, Neiman Marcus, Dillard's, Bon-Ton. Millenials don't shop as previous generations did. They want experiences not fashion and style. Also the rise of online Amazon and now Jet is taking away from brick and mortar stores in all sectors. A sad reality the great stores and shopping experiences of the past is becoming harder to duplicate and run in this ever changing environment.

Date: Monday, July 04, 2016, 12:57 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Phillip and Pete: Yes, some contingency of former Field's staff returning is essential to the success to reborn Field's, and yes, Phillip, I'm not only well aware of that, I've heard from more than a few who have retired from Field's, perhaps under Dayton-Hudson, Target, May or Federated. They are at our events and volunteer to me that they would be back in a second. (Not that each and everyone will actually come back.) But certainly DO hope that all the staff from Field's circa 1989 DO NOT return. I would hate to walk into State Street after a return and find it was stuck in a past time warp. Field's at it's best has a good dose of the "next up and coming thing." Yes, some institutional history is needed but there's also new blood that's needed. And I'm sure those who left would come back with new experiences to contribute. One weakness about Field's is that many of their employees are so perfectionistic that they are cynical to the point that they don't see how even Field's on a bad or mediocre day was still in many ways better than Macy's.

Back to my precedence with Mariano's, which is basically Dominick's reincarnated 12-17 years later. Yes, there are some former Dominick's people in key positions who've helped revive what was lost. But the success is also due to new people as well.

Like Pete, I felt offended with the suggestion that myself and others are naive. Not so.

Best, Jim

Date: Monday, July 4, 2016  CT
Posted by:

Happy Fourth of July!

Date: Sun, July 2, 2016, 10:28 pm CT
Posted by: Gail White,

Story says clutter a reason people are staying away from Macy's and some others. Uses Herald Square as an example.

Date: Sat, July 01, 2016, 10:26 pm CT
Posted by: Joan S.,

Scary Stuff! Who knew this could happen when I went in Macy's, although I guess I'm reading this as only happening in NY. Did Field's ever do this? Does any Chicagoland retailer do this?

Judge: Macy's must stop jailing shoplifters

Date: Fri, July 01, 2016, 12:22 am ET
Posted by: Pete,

Phillip I'm not sure who to think is clueless, but I think the talent is out there. For starters, Selfridge's and Hudson Bay have been mentioned as potential stewards of Marshall Field and Company. I can't believe they wouldn't have talent to select some of the unique things. I also know that there are other retired former buyers we would love to come back for a second stint, perhaps as a late career capstone or encore after moving on after the Dayton's-Target and Macy's take over. I know my neighbor is one of those former buyers who used to be at State Street and would love to come out of retirement. To say nobody in Chicago has that sort of talent is quite insulting, although I hope they would have some in touch with current Chicago tastes rather than the tastes that prevailed under BATUS ownership. You sound perhaps as if you either work for Macy's or are a bitter Field's employee let go by Target. Sure, there will be challenges but I think so many talented people including buyers would want to see Field's come back and would except the challenge. Your comments are harsh and rude so you must not be one of them.

Date: Thurs, June 30, 2016, 8:30 pm CT
Posted by: Phil Eichler,

While Staff Is One issue, MoSt Of YOU are clueless that fields had massive buying groups to bring really unique products into the stores. Target killed that. The fields most of you remember is a shadow of fields under Phil Miller and batus . That will be really hard to bring back, if ever.

Date: Wed, June 29, 2016, 19:12
Posted by: gle,


Date: Wed, June 29, 2016, 11:04 am CT
Posted by: Sara ,

Thank you for representing us. I especially love the photos of the couples.


Date: Wed, June 29, 2016, 9:56 am CT
Posted by: Gina,

What a great show of support for Marshall Field's to come back. I know of no one who like's Macy's better. Ditto for Bloomingdale's.


Date: Tues, June 28, 2016, 6:31 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Thanks to all who offered support, took photos and posed for photos at Sunday's Chicago Pride Parade. We were positively received. I didn't hear a negative word from the crowd. The photos below or ones similar to them were also posted to our Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram pages.

Keep in mind that those who posed for the photos approached us about taking a photo. Because of different security blockages, we were only able to walk about 60% of the route, from Montrose to Belmont/Halsted with a couple of drop-in points beyond. We also walked on the sidewalk BEHIND the crowd--so 90% of the attendees were looking at parade and away from us. With those disadvantages, about 40 people approached us to be photographed for the photos you see below.

Also: About 30 Bloomingdale's employees did walk in the parade. We didn't see them last year. They all wore very tasteful black t-shirts with a rainbow "pride" logos. Unlike some previous years (like 2008) where it seemed in our opinion to be a Macy's ad first, this seemed to be more about Bloomingdale's letting their employees show their pride. That we can respect. So we did not walk the route with them as we did with Macy's like in 2008 or other years. (Again, for those who don't know, Bloomingdale's is part of Macy's and, as historically a competitor to Field's, some experts think that Field's was discontinued to help Bloomingdale's.)

Scenes from the 2016
Chicago Pride Parade

Signs calling for the restoration of Marshall Field's were walked up and down the 2.5 mile parade route. While there were thousands of cheers, the following are among those who called us back to have their pic taken with our sign and say, more than ever, Chicago wants its Marshall Field's!

©2016 ©2016 ©2016
©2016 ©2016 ©2016
©2016 ©2016 ©2016
©2016 ©2016 ©2016
©2016 ©2016 ©2016
©2016 ©2016 6.30.2016 ©
©2016 ©2016 ©2016

Date: Tues, June 28, 2016, 5:36 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

In response to Mark and James K's conversation from Saturday asking is it too late to get back Field's-quality assistance? Thanks for your patience. There are several examples but the two that stand out as having significant parallels are Seflridges and Dominick's/Safeway/Mariano's.

But first, don't you think there would be so much buzz about Field's return that some of the best would want to come and work there?

In the case of Selfridges, a little over 20 years ago, it was moribund and dowdy. No pizzazz and considered not unlike some of the middle of the road stores run by BONT or perhaps today's Lord and Taylor. Selfridges changed hands twice in the past 20 or so years but especially under Toronoto's Weston family, it's become the premier department store in the world--voted as such even by its peers. And this forum, we've beaten to death the historic connections between Selfridges and Marshall Field's, as well as Chicago and the Westons.

Dominick's never had the world-class rep, history and impact of Field's, but it was a beloved grocery store of loyal Chicagoland shoppers. When it was purchased by Safeway in 1998, it had almost the same market share as Jewel (28% vs 32%) with only two-thirds the stores of Jewel-Osco. Dominick DiMateo, Jr. died and eventually they sold out to Safeway who in turn fired the Dominick's management. The stores were converted in Safeway in virtually every way EXCEPT name. The stores fell to 10% market share. (This is why I'm glad that Macy's did change the name--can you imagine if they changed everything to the way it is but left the Marshall Field's name? Exiled to a Wisconsin grocer for several years because of non-compete agreements, the former Dominick's management started a new chain in 2010. No, they weren't able to use the Dominick's name, but in most every other way, the stores--named Mariano's for the former Dominick DiMateo, Jr. President who started it--were a 2010s version of what Dominick's would have been had it not become Safeway. Mariano's rise is considered a reason for at least half of Safeway's/Dominick's slip to 10%. Today, Mariano's is nationally recognized in the industry as a peer of Wegmann's and Harris Teeter. Yes, there have been a couple of hiccups--but none that are comparable to being reasons for not bringing back Field's. One is that Mariano's was only 20% of the it's parent company's stores. The other 80% of the stores, located in Wisconsin and Minnesota had a long history of problems. So the parent company, Roundy's, was bought out by Kroger. Kroger is pretty much leaving the Mariano's stores alone while providing the capital to convert 12 former Dominick's fully into Mariano's. (They are starting with the Park Ridge store.) So yes, the parent company did get bought out; however, had Mariano's not been created, Roundy's would have gone out of business rather than be sold. Related to this is a few growing pains Mariano's had when it suddenly was able to purchase a dozen former Dominick's stores, almost doubling the size of the chain. I understand that the problem is they had to hire hundreds of new employees--Mariano's isn't staffed by the same union while Jewel and Dominick's were. So it's taken time to get the employees up to speed to provide quality help.

Staffing could be a real problem at reborn Field's if they brought it back to all 60+ locations nor should it. But I don't see that. What I do see is it at least returning to State Street. Beyond that and less likely, it would be great if they could return to a handful of classic, A-list mall locations like Old Orchard, Oak Brook and Mayfair. Personally, I think Macy's should fold Bloomingdale's in Chicagoland and convert the Michigan Avenue store to Macy's while restoring Field's to Water Tower Place. It's amazing that Macy's spends so much in news advertising on Bloomingdale's in Chicago for what are basically two locations -- Old Orchard and Michigan Avenue/Medinah.

Date: Sun, June 26, 2016, 4:066 pm CT
Posted by: Lucie D.,

Commenting on the many photos posted to Field's social media outlets on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram from the Chicago Pride Parade:

Thanks to everyone of you who stopped by and had a photo taken, thanks Jim for your hard work. ." where there is a will" (many wills) "there will be a way"...........

Date: Sat, June 25, 2016, 11:01 am CT
Posted by: Jim,

We'll be out along the Chicago Pride Parade route tomorrow. Look for us and our signs if you want a "Time to Bring Back Marshall Field's", "Selfridges Come Home To Chicago: The DNA of Marshall Field's" or both.

Date: Sat, June 25, 2016, 9:07 am CT
Posted by: Jim,

James McKay Mark M., James K.: good points about staffing--those are the kind of questions to ask. There's actually current precedence of retailers that basically went away and is now being reincarnated with overwhelming success acclaim: they are doing tremendously (Selfridges and Mariano's). (More explained above on Tuesday, June 28, 2016.)

Date: Sat, June 25, 2016, 2:54 am CT
Posted by: Mark K.,

I think the answer is— you go back to a very old fashioned concept and train them. It’s like the front of the house staff in a fine restaurant— they are knowledgable, skilled, and choreographed. And it doesn’t happen by accident. But a return to that kind of service might just catch on.

Date: Sat, June 25, 2016, 1:27 am CT
Posted by: Mark M.,

Much as I hope for a new Fields, how do you staff it? It's not just the building or even the merchandise, it's the people. It's that "How may I help you?" attitude AND the ability to actually help. There was a time, when other old-line retailers were closing, that you could have hired 30 year veterans of Magnin's or Bonwit's or specialty retailers like Mark Cross, but those people are retired now. You can poach a few from Tiffany and Saks....maybe Nordstrom and a few Oak St. stores, but those won't even give you department heads. I'm just terrified that it's too late.......and that makes me very sad.

(See above for Jim McKay response on Tuesday, June 28, 2016.)

Date: Fri, June 24, 2016, 6:40 pm CT
Posted by: gle,

Lundgren's pending departure is a LONG OVERDUE relief, but I wonder what the next one will be like and what he's been trained to do. I can't picture Lundgren letting go without somehow making sure things remain his way. I would rather see Selfridge's take the helm. The Galen Weston family has a better track record.

I do love the "Tribune" headline, "MACY'S CEO WHO KILLED MARSHALL FIELD'S TO STEP DOWN NEXT YEAR." I guess the newspapers don't have to be nice to him any more.

Date: Sat, June 25, 2016, 11:24 am CT
Posted by: James K.,

Life is all about embracing heritage and identity at one and the same time as "re-inventing" oneself. It would seem like now is the time to stir things up and make things interesting with a return of Fields that signifies identity, heritage, and reinventing! Jeff Gennette-- just think-- you could start off as a hero. Picturing it now-- "Excuse me-- could you direct me to the department that carries cajones!?"

Date: Fri, June 24, 2016,  11:12 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Macy's New Chief Aims to Liven Up Department-Store Chain
Company veteran Jeff Gennette to draw on Macy's heritage as "entertainment brand" amid retailing upheaval
As a WSJ subscriber, I was able to comment as follows at the end of the article.
Marshall Field's was a world-wide attraction when it was Marshall Field's. Now not so much. He could score a bases-loaded home run if he brought back Marshall Field's. People overwhelmingly want it back and it was a trade name that SEC 10 K filings at the time of the merger showed was valued as the same or even more than Macy's/Bloomingdale's and more than all the rest of May Dept Stores' tradenames combined.

In these joint interviews of the past 24-hours, Terry Lundgren comes off like a helicopter parent. He needs to give Gennette his space to be his own guy. I understand an orderly transition but this transition is so slo mo (started in 2014, complete in 2017-18?) that it comes off as if Gennette can't be trusted. Then again, Terry Lundgren designed his wife's wedding dress and set up much of the rest without letting her see much of anything until the wedding. (See WSJ, 7/17/2006.)

Date: Fri, June 24, 2016,  10:20 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

New Macy's CEO: Here Is My Vision

Some quotes:
Lundgren: I have been the CEO for 13 years, by the time I turn it over to Jeff next year it will be 14 years and I will be 65 years old. How many CEOs of Fortune 500 companies do you know that have been around as long as I have? I would say very, very few. I have had a phenomenal experience and run here, in particular the five years prior to this past one, but really all throughout my career.

I'm feeling great about my ability right now to hand over the reins to Jeff in the first quarter. It honestly will go down as one of my greatest accomplishments in being able to give the CEO title to Jeff and do it in such an orderly way.

We planned this for two years when we made Jeff the president of the company. It was all part of our succession plan.


Gennette: We are philosophically very similar, which serves us well. Whatever gaps Terry and I have in our individual portfolios we surround ourselves with talent to cover that. Neither Terry nor I operate from a position of arrogant thinking. So, I know what my shortfalls are, and I have a deep respect for the talent that I can assemble.

I have had the pleasure of serving with Terry and the talent he has assembled. So I look at him as a role model.

Date: Fri, June 24, 2016,  9:02 am CT
Posted by: M.N.,

Hate Lundgren. What he did to Marshall Field's will go down in retailing history as arrogant and stupid.

Date: Fri, June 24, 2016,  3:52 am CT
Posted by: Susan C.,

Regarding the post on the former Marshall Field's locations in Evanston and Oak Park, I go to the Evanston Panera Bread in the former Field's all the time. I told the employee's once I worked there when it was Marshall Field's. The employee's wanted to know a few things about the building and what departments were in the location the bread shop[ is. they said the City of Evanston would not let them make changes to some of the inside of the building because of the landmark status.

Date: Thurs, June 23, 2016, 10:54 pm CT
Posted by: Susan B., Atlanta,

Regarding Tribune article, Wow... what a dweeb
Nasty, Brutish & Short: Federated C.E.O. Has Carefully Cultivated Image As...
Or is he just an ass, because that's what he sounds like to us. Thank God The Post has reprinted this article, which first appeared last week in the Wall Street Journal. When we saw it then, we could not believe it--or that it profiles the C.E.O. of a company based in Cincinnati.


Okay. We don't care if you are the C.E.O. of a department store, anal-retentive, and a clothes horse. The groom does not get to pick what the bride gets to wear, and have it be a surprise. It just doesn't work that way. And what kind of self-respecting woman would farm out ALL of the wedding planning--even down to the design of the wedding dress--to her fiance? Can't she figure out how to dress herself?

The whole piece is lengthy, and the entire thing is worth reading. Throughout it, though, we are struck by one thought: He probably thinks this is really good PR! How could he have no idea how awful this makes him sound? (Continues at link above)

Date: Thurs, June 23, 2016, 10:27 pm CT
Posted by: Marty B.,

Re: Tribune Article, Terry Lundgren destroyed two brands.

Date: Thurs, June 23, 2016, 6:01 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Dead on headline: if you can, please go to the Chicago Tribune website and leave comments after the article.

Chicago Tribune

Date: Thurs, June 23, 2016, 4:30 pm CT
Posted by: Pete,

Story about the new CEOs plans. Nothing specific about Marshall Field and company.

Date: Thurs, June 23, 2016, 4:10 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Bank of America aims to open in Marshall Field's building

Water Tower Realty, owner of the historic Marshall Field's building at 1144 Lake St., was recently given a variance from Oak Park's zoning code to lease the rear half to...
The building's near-twin in Evanston currently features a similar bank operated by Citibank as well as a Panera bread store and restaurant. When I drive by, I often fantasize how cool it would be for Marshall Field and Company to return and open a holiday pop up in the store. I still miss it as borders books. In reality, this is a much better proposal then the Sleepys mattress store that was proposed and rejected two or three years ago.

Date: Thurs, June 23, 2016, 1:47 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Perhaps this long overdue departure will be the turning point in giving shoppers what they want.

Date: Thurs, June 23, 2016, 10:53 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Thanks Phil...Amazing the amount of retweets and other media attention. Showed up as an urgent alert from on my smartphone, on par with supreme court decisions announced today.

As mentioned, Terry Lundgren will still be Executive Chairman which I don't think they previously have had. I'm not sure how independent Gennette is from Mr, Lundgren but I think he must be pretty well connected else he wouldn't have been groomed for the job.

Here are a few more links. Please add your own reader comments if you can.


Wall Street Journal

American Business Journals

Forbes (by former Macy's exec Walter Loeb)

Walter Loeb writes:

"Jeff Gennette will succeed Terry Lundgren as CEO of Macy's M +3.23% in the first quarter of 2017, the retailer announced Thursday morning. It will be a seamless transition. The move has been widely expected since Gennette’s appointment as president of Macy’s in 2014. The 64-year-old Lundgren will continue as executive chairman of the company."

"Gennnette, 55, who will join the board of Macy’s today, is a consummate merchant who will undoubtedly add his vision for growth to the enterprise. Over the past two years, he has developed as a skilled retail operator, rounding out his experience to service customers. He has been with Macy’s for 33 years and grew through the ranks in several key areas."

"I expect changes after Gennette takes over. They will not be sudden, but evolutionary as new ideas to stimulate growth will be developed. Current efforts to reduce costs and make the company leaner are likely to pay off in better earnings next year. However, I expect merchandise innovation and a clear vision for growth through strategic acquisitions. Some real estate is likely to be divested and more stores are likely to be closed."


Date: Thurs, June 23, 2016, 8:41 am CT
Posted by: Philip Eichler ,

Macy's announced this morning that Terry Lundgren will step down in 2017, but will remain with the company.

Date: Mon, June 18, 2016, 2:01 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Bloomingdale's/Macy's will again be in this year's Pride Parade. VOLUNTEERS NEEDED AT THIS SUNDAY'S CHICAGO PRIDE PARADE! WILL YOU HELP FIELD'S? AS USUAL PLEASE DO NOT POST REGRETS UNTIL AFTER THE EVENT (ie please do not post "I can't come because...") Such comments will be removed. Here are some shots of FieldsFansChicago at Chicago Pride Parades past including last year, our signs, 2008 (Macy's float behind the sign) 2010 and 2011. One year, Gail H. flew in from far away to help.

Macy's has skipped some years while others they have sponsored others' floats. A couple of years ago Bloomingdale's was in the parade. Last year Bloomingdale's was listed but apparently did not participate. This year, Macy's/Bloomingdale's will have their float under the Bloomingdale's banner. We have signs, fliers, buttons to pass out--ever -- Please contact me via email jjmckay -AT- or by leaving a message at 312.662.8980 if you can help get the message about Marshall Field's out. Thanks!
2008 Chicago Pride Parade ©2008
2010 Chicago Pride Parade ©2010
2011 Chicago Pride Parade ©2011

Scenes from the 2015
Chicago Pride Parade

Signs calling for the restoration of Marshall Field's were walked up and down the 2.5 mile parade route. While there were thousands of cheers, the following are among those who called us back to have their pic taken with our sign and say, more than ever, Chicago wants its Marshall Field's!

©2015 ©2015 ©2015
©2015 ©2015 ©2015
©2015 ©2015 ©2015
©2015 ©2015 ©2015
©2015 ©2015 ©2015
©2015 ©2015 6.30.2015 ©
©2015 ©2015 ©2015

Date: Mon, June 18, 2016, 11:58 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

As its sales continue to plummet, macy can please its shareholders by selling off valuable real estate:
During the past few months, macy has been shuttering desirable downtown store locations and selling the buildings. In the case of Pittsburgh, the most profitable department store in the Kaufmann's chain was allowed to deteriorate and was not marketed to attract customers; macy had no desire for the store to succeed. Money from the sale of the property could compensate for declining sales.

Note the list of their most valuable, desirable properties. The former Marshall Field's building would certainly be attractive to developers! The current store could be downsized (like Brooklyn) or sold off. The executives at macy clearly don't show much interest in providing a dynamic retail environment, and the situation is very similar to what has happened at Sears.

Date: Mon, June 18, 2016, 11:36 am CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

The lack of customer "experience" and bargain store atmosphere is causing macy to lose its once lucrative cosmetics business:
Recent articles have noted that better brands like Michael Kors and Coach plan to discontinue selling their wares at macy because their image is destroyed by the store's constant discounting.

Shoppers are looking for something other than One Day Sales and multiple coupons. There are plenty of stores like TJMaxx, Marshall's and Ross that do a great job as clearance/discount shopping venues. Shoppers did NOT need another bargain bin!

Maybe, just maybe, if macy would give customers what they want...

Date: Sunday, June 19, 2016  CT
Posted by: gle,


Date: Sat, June 18, 2016, 8:29 pm CT
Posted by: Sara G.,

Walked through the store that used to be the great Marshall Field and Company on State Street a few days ago.

The store looks so tired. So sad that Macy's doesn't see the jewel they have in Marshall Field's.

Date: Fri, June 17, 2016, 9:17 pm CT
Posted by: Kathryn S.,

Field's return would mean enjoying a nice drink in the tea room! :) Ahhh

Date: Wed, June 15, 2016, 9:19 am CT
Posted by: Anna N.,

Field's was more than just a store. It was part of Chicago's history, a part of the city's spirit. A major piece of Christmas magic was staring wide eyed at the beautiful displays and lights, the music of the season in the store, and a MF Christmas bear under the tree. Christmas was never the same without Field's. My hope is that someday my children will know the magic and spirit that was and is Marshall Field's. -A.N.

Date: Tues, June 14, 2016, 12:33 pm CT
Posted by: Patt P,

Field's on state street was such a special place for our family. We were farmers from Alpha and Galesburg Illinois and every year, we would take the train to Chicago the day after Thanksgiving to look at the windows at Field's, shop at Field's and have tea in the walnut room. Gramma Beulah, our mother, Agnes, and my two sister and I. It was a long day, we left around 6 in the morning and didn't get back on until very late. We would spend all day there. We looked at everything, and mother let us each buy a few things. We got to pick out an ornament for the Christmas tree. I still have the ornaments, and until a few years ago, some red stretch pants I got in 1963. We would eat supper in the cafeteria, and buy chocolate, Frangos, of course.

I loved the huge rest room on the 7th floor, all the wood doors, and I swear it had a bathtub in it. It was towards the front of the rest room and I always wondered about it. I never saw anyone use it, but it fascinated me. The room has been updated now, of course.

Date: Tues, June 14, 2016, 11:52 pm CT
Posted by: A.M.P.,


Today I saw a lady with a Forever Fields button on her jacket. I loved Marshall Fields from the time I was a little girl. It was always a special trip to go downtown (from Beverly on the southside) to Marshall Fields, but it was magical at Christmas time.

Every year we went to see the windows and my dad would read aloud the narrative at each window--long after we could all read ourselves--it was a tradition. They were always beautiful. We have noted that Macy's is more of an advertisement.

Then we would go see the tree with Mr. Mistletoe (I'm not sure I remember his name) on the top. We didn't usually eat in the Walnut room because there were too many very hungry boys in my family. They would have needed two Walnut Room meals! In college I worked on State Street and frequently spent my paychecks at Field's on my lunch hour.

Date: Mon, June 13, 2016, 7:02 pm CT
Posted by: gle,

I watched the final episode of PBS' "Mr. Selfridge" with trepidation. I had already read Lindy Woodhead's and Gayle Soucek's bios of Selfridge and knew full well how it ended. I was relieved that the show handled things gracefully, and only took the drama to the point where Mr. Selfridge left the store for the last time. The employees, who knew he had been sacked, applauded and thanked him for all he had done for the store and for their careers. He thanked them for their part in building Selfridge's and told them to hang in there and keep up the good work. He sadly said he wished he could not be there to share it with them in the future. (The story also hinted that he and Mae would be married. Mae did not exist in real life.)

In spite of personal difficulties, Selfridge did accomplish much that lasts today. I am glad the series treated him well and emphasized the success.

I did not like the "Tribune" article and wrote to tell them. I don't think they know as much of the subject matter as they claim.

Date: Sun, June 12, 2016, 9:10 am CT
Posted by: Jim,

Chicago Tribune's Sunday flashback section page has awful story of Mr. Selfridge's years in Chicago.
Please leave comments after the stories--the "comments" button is towards the bottom of the piece. Furthermore, you can help by sending letters to the editor of the Chicago Tribune can be sent to Be sure to include your name, city, state and phone number, along with the phrase, "FOR PUBLICATION."

[Thanks to those who reported the problem with posting and the Greek text while the blog was unavailable.]

Date: Fri, May 27, 2016, 5:39 pm CT
Posted by: gle,

GOOD WORK AND THANKS JIM AND OTHERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Date: Wed, May 25, 2016, 5:38 pm CT
Posted by: James K.,

Bravo James McKay (and comrades) and thank you! Just a thought-- would there be any structure through which to purchase stock in the new Field's. Could there be some sort of stock offering contingent on the restoration of the Fields name, brand, image. They might be surprised at how many would buy in. This is also such an opportune time to harken all the way back to Selfridge's-- there is a window of opportunity with the conclusion of the PBS Masterpiece Theater series.

Date: Wed, May 25, 2016, 12:28 am CT
Posted by: M.N.,

Re Stockholders Meeting: You represent the thousands who want Field's to return. Well done!

Date: Tues, May 24, 2016, 9:34 pm CT
Posted by: Jim H.,

The Business Insider article posted 3 hours ago misses mark. The lack of shoppers is not about "price." It is also not about "presentation." Those factors may be necessary in retail, but if exceptional product quality and the customer service are absent, why bother at all. If I want TJ MAXX bargain bin garbage, I will go there instead of Macy's. I used to have wonderful Field Gear clothes and a corresponding fashion adviser. I want them back, Macy's.

Date: Tues, May 24, 2016, 6:47 pm CT
Posted by: Hector M. via Michael R.,

Business Insider:
"We went to Macy's and saw why the brand is a disaster
Macy's sales have been plummeting. The company might blame the lack of seasonal weather, but that's clearly not the only reason."

Date: Tues, May 24, 2016, 6:56 am CT
Posted by: Ami M.,

Pray for Marshall Fields to return!

Date: Mon, May 23, 2016, 11:31 pm CT
Posted by: Tim E.,

Well done; very impressive.

Date: Mon, May 23, 2016, 8:50 pm CT
Posted by: Alfred I.,

BRAVO, James and companions!!!

Date: Mon, May 23, 2016, 6:57 pm CT
Posted by: Natalie T.,

Thank you for all your hard work and dedication!!

Date: Mon, May 23, 2016, 5:55 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

And now here's the "More later..." in follow up to my photo post on Friday, May 20, 2016.

After the meeting (and talking with some stockholders and unidentified suits on the street in front of the headquarters) Frank said, ""Field's is coming back!" I wouldn't say it's a slam dunk, and since even Field's never remained the same, it would be different, but I came away from the annual meeting feeling more hopeful.

The stockholders meeting was filled to capacity with people standing, unlike some previous years when there were plenty of empty seats. Macy's, Inc. (Macy's/Bloomingdale's/Bluemercury) CEO and Chairman Terry Lundgen gave a presentation that seemed longer than usual. A lot of it reiterated the recent problems that have beset Macy's as well as other retailers as well as much of their recent plans for reviving business.

An exception was that three long-time directors are retiring including the chief legal officier as well as two directors who have been with Federated/Bloomingdale's before it acquired R.H. Macy & Co. out of bankruptcy. Is this a change of the old guard?

At the formal conclusion of the meeting, any stockholder can address the audience or ask questions for a couple of minutes. Interaction between myself and Mr. Lundgren was cordial. As proof of continued value of Field's brand, I announced how over 120 photos of about 200 supporters were taken over several hours on Saturday afternoons during the holidays and posted here and at our website. ( See ) I also pointed out how the value of the Field's tradenames were listed higher in SEC 10K forms than all other May Department Stores combined and the Field's tradename/brand is most valuable when attached to the State Street store. I also pointed out that while Macy's may be jumping on the TJ Maxx/off-price store bandwagon (a prominent part of Mr. Lundgren's presentation), the reality is that the off-price store as founded by a young Harry Selfridge in the basement of Marshall Field and Company is the original. (Isn't Bluemercury just a reincarnation of the comprehensive services offered by Marshall Fields back in the day?) If Macy's were to restore Field's and the "bargain basement," they could actually point out that THEY started the off-price movement--not the likes of TJ Maxx. There are a few other details, but I made a special point of addressing any activist investors who may have been in the audience that as real estate, the State Street store is still by far most valuable when it is operated in name and ethos as Field's.

Afterwards, in the meeting and on the street, there were those who were clearly more than customers or passersby on the street--who agreed with what I had said. One insisted on posing for a selfie outside with our signs. (Sorry, I don't feel comfortable getting too specific on social media.)

So I hope I represented our collective views as much as possible. Thank you for reading this and offering input. Private responses with suggestions can be sent to jjmckay AT

Date: Fri, May 20, 2016, 6:47 pm CT
Posted by: Alfred I.,

Thanks a zillion, James and all!

Date: Fri, May 20, 2016, 3:13 pm CT
Posted by: Gabriel M.,

Thank you so much for all you have done.

Date: Fri, May 20, 2016, 12.25 pm CT
Posted by: Jeane W.,

Thank you for taking your time to do this!

Date: Fri, May 20, 2016, 11:17 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Once again Marshall Field supporters attended the stockholders annual meeting in Cincinnati of Macy's/Bloomingdale's. Thanks to Frank who made it possible and a special thank you to Bernice (age 87) who came all the way from Chicago to support the return of Marshall Field's. More later…

Date: Thurs, May 19, 2016, 7:41 am CT
Posted by: gle,

Once again I voted against all of Macy's directors on the ballot for the annual shareholder meeting to be held Friday May 20. A BIG thanks to those able to attend these meetings in person and represent the Field's cause. The fact that we continue to have someone show up says a lot.

I read the headlines and would so much love to see the Selfridge's group acquire the State Street store. They seem to be the people who know how to turn a department store around in today's economy.

Date: Tues, May 17, 2016, 11:06
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Buckle Your Seatbelt: Macy's Is In For A Rough Ride
May 17, 2016 10:48 AM
My response:

A whole other angle on the real estate is in Chicago where the historic Marshall Field's Building could see immense value unlocked and MAXIMIZED if it were sold to likes of Canada/London's Selfridges Group or Canada's Hudson Bay. There's a grass roots campaign by customers.

Press Release

Photos of over 200 customers picketing for something like this to happen:

Date: Mon, May 16, 2016, 4:39 pm CT
Posted by: Pete,

It's down to the final episodes of Mr. Selfridge. You can watch online at Everyone knows the man had a sad ending but the store went on to its future and current greatness!

Date: Sat, May 14, 2016, 12:01 pm CT
Posted by: Observer,

Macy's doesn't seem as busy as when it was Marshall Field's. So Sad.....:-(

Date: Fri, May 13, 2016, 9:22 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

We have several family weddings in the upcoming months and it's a problem WHERE to find special, unique gifts. Up until the macy*fication, there were stores which offered items sure to be appreciated and treasured.

My cousin and his fiancee were deciding on stores for their bridal registry. They went to macy and were not impressed with the home store merchandise; they found that macy carried much of the same goods found at JCPenney and Kohl's but macy goods were priced higher than their competitors. They felt that the macy "exclusive, celebrity" home wares were nothing they would want. Another relative is so upset at the loss of Hudson's/ Marshall Field's that she specifically stated she DID NOT want a gift or gift card from macy.

Memo to macy buyers-- there are millenials who value quality over "celebrity" names.

Date: Thurs, May 12, 2016, 11:17 pm ET
Posted by: mikea,

It was a disappointing quarter for Macy's and Nordstrom, Kohl.s, Dillard's as of today.

Macy's does need to make their stores more special again. They need to capitalize more on special and unique departments especially in their large flagship and platinum stores. The old answer of selling soft goods where profit is high is not working in today's retail environment. Customers today are choosing internet shopping, and spending more of their income in other categories than shopping at the mall.

Auto sales, housing, home improvement, travel, and entertainment.

Look at how crowded airports, hotels and entertainment venues are.

It is becoming not only a problem for Macy's, but for all traditional brick and mortar department stores. Even Neiman Marcus had a bad quarter during the holiday season. Interesting to watch as Neimans and the other retailers report their quarterly earnings.

Hopefully the sad reality does not mean massive store and mall closings, leaving thousand unemployed and vacant buildings and lowered sales tax revenue for states and cities. Retailers like Amamzon not only hurt traditional stores, but cities and states, since they do not charge sales tax.

Date: Thurs, May 12, 2016, 10:00 pm CT
Posted by: Pete,

Hello friends! It's been a while since I've posted. The news these past few days is really something, isn't it?

I don't think department stores are dead like some supposed experts are saying. Rather, I think they're trying to be too much in the gutter with the likes of Walmart and Target, TJ Maxx, Ross, and so forth.

What needs to happen, is not what happened 10 years ago when all those stores became Macy's. Instead, they need to be special and unique. The State Street store will always be Marshall Field and Company. Macy's really needs to capitalize on a few very key stores. I read where they were talking about their top 150 stores. So maybe they keep 300 of them at most. But let the most special of these stores like State Street become special again. Right now there's no reason for people to make a special trip. That is why Selfridge's does so well in England. They only have four stores for the entire country! Macy's should do the same for a number of specialized chains. Let Marshall Field and Company be the first to come back in a couple of key locations.


Date: Thurs, May 12, 2016, 2:20 pm CT
Posted by: Kim Johnson,

We miss Marshall Field's A LOT!

Macy's, PLease bring it back!

Date: Thurs, May 12, 2016, 5:49 am CT
Posted by: Stephanie LaPierre,

It will be interesting to see what happens with Macy's in the next few months. If they have another bad quarter, I don't think one from his long for this world as Macy's head. But if he goes, I worry what will happen to Marshall Fields former stores. It could be even worse.

Date: Wed, May 11, 2016, 20:40
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Interesting analysis explaining how macy "is becoming the new Sears";_ylt=A0LEVy8tzzNXNyQA0J9XNyoA;_ylu=X3oDMTEyaHZjYzhtBGNvbG8DYmYxBHBvcwMxBHZ0aWQDQjE4NzlfMQRzZWMDc2M-
All of the mistakes made by macy have been discussed in this fields fans blog, but evidently the powers that be at macy know better. Stock prices were propped up by cutting back on services, personnel and other expenditures. Now there is nothing left to cut. Many wonderful stores were run into the ground, shoppers have been disappointed and have moved on. Is macy a better store with high end merchandise, a mid level store with constant promotions, or a discount store? Confused customers don't know what a macy is.

Date: Wed, May 11, 2016, 7:28 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

More bad press for macy:
Bottom line --there is NO compelling reason to shop these stores. By taking over the regional department stores and reducing them to the lowest common denominator in merchandising, getting rid of special services, community events and popular restaurants, trying to be both upscale and discount, constantly running One Day Sales and flooding customers' mailboxes with coupons that don't work on anything, macy is desperately trying to find its niche.

Haven't they figured out that slapping red stars and pictures of the Herald Square flagship all over a store isn't going to attract customers? Not everyone is infatuated with "Noo Yawk" and "celebrity" merchandise. Quite frankly a clothing line associated with two somewhat past their prime musicians and home wares associated with a daytime gossip show hostess who has widely publicized personal relationship problems aren't all that much of an attraction.

Maybe try quality merchandise, good value and service, clean and attractive stores--just for starters.

Date: Wed, May 11, 2016, 6:40 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,

There are hundreds of stories on Macy's shortcomings today, but this one stands out because the author sees Macy's as ripe for takeover. I responded--and hope you do too--by commenting that people in Chicago would love to see Macy's Marshall Field's assets taken over by Canada's Selfridges Group or Hudson Bay.

Macy's posted terrible results this morning, lowering FY2016 forecasts.Everything thinks nothing can get better for the retail space.We're buyers on this dip.
There are so many other articles on this. Here's a page from Yahoo! Business that has links to the latest headlines about Macy's problems. I've been responding to as many of these as possible in the same vein as my response to the WSJ story from yesterday that I posted below. Please do the same and respond in the comments section as well. It helps our cause. Many of the people who read these mainstream news articles erroneously think Marshall Field's went Chapter 7 bankrupt and Macy's saved it.
M Headlines | Macy's Inc Common Stock Stock - Yahoo! Finance
Find out the latest news headlines for Macy's Inc Common Stock (M).

Date: Wed, May 11, 2016, 11:38 am CT
Posted by: Steve G,

Macy's dismal results bring back memories of the financial crisis
During the first quarter, Macy's comparable sales fell 5.6 percent. That represents…

Date: Wed, May 11, 2016, 11:31 am CT
Posted by:
Michael R.,

In the article it says "The blunt truth is that Macy’s does not give consumers a reason to visit its stores," Neil Saunders, CEO of retail consulting firm Conlumino, wrote in a note to clients Wednesday. "In many locations shops are simply not up to par: they are poorly merchandised, hard to shop, lack any inspiration, and have fairly mediocre customer service. Some of this is about a lack of capital investment, but some is about a lack of basic shop-keeping standards." They have let the stores go right down the tank like Sears did.
Macy's is officially becoming the new Sears
The issues plaguing Macy's are the same ones that have brought Sears close to extinction.

Date: Wed, May 11, 2016, 9:13 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Some notes from this morning's Macy's Q1 2016 Conference Call with Macy's CFO Karen Hoguet: Click here to see full transcripts available from Seeking Alpha Note their terms etc.

Date: Tues, May 10, 2016,  4:50 pm CT
Posted by: Lucie,

Regarding Jim's post of photos from the holiday season, darn nice looking bunch of people in that picture - we are going to keep trying, thanks to all who participated.

Date: Tues, May 10, 2016, 3:37 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,

Jake: I hear it all the time and I'm sure they do mourn as does Atlanta, Boston, L.A., D.C., St Louis, Houston, Dallas,... I could go and on...but the thing is, according to Macy's/Federated's/MayCo's own SEC 10 K Filings showed that FIeld's was worth more than all the other MayCo brands ( Kaufmann's, Lord & Taylor, ten more...) COMBINED! when it was taken over. It was even worth more than Federated's brands at the time. That's why there is so much more attention to Field's. It was more than regional--it was an international store and Chicago's best brand. Period.

Date: Tues, May 10, 2016, 3:26 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,

This is how it was last holiday season. Macy's won't listen. So we're hoping Selfridges will find a way...

Date: Tues, May 10, 2016, 3:19 pm CT
Posted by: Jake Stewart,

Don't think for minute that Pittsburghers don't mourn for their Kaufmann's every time they're forced to step into a Macy's. The Big Store downtown ran itself. It's only through Macy's mismanagement that it turned into a shell of its former self before being closed and sold.

Date: Tues, May 10, 2016, 3:13 pm CT
Posted by: M.N.,

Jim, I could not agree more. Some have stopped going to the protests because it's like screaming down an empty canyon; but if you ask any Chicagoan, they want their Marshall Field's back. Field's was an icon, and it was born in our city. If you were born in Chicago, it was part of your heritage - every birthday, every holiday, and everyone's go-to for everyday. Other department stores in other cities paled in comparison because of its high standards and overall excellence. You'd have to be crazy to not want to get that back!

Date: Tues, May 10, 2016, 3:04 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Macy’s Stock Is Cheap for a Reason

Macy’s fiscal first-quarter results will likely reflect the difficult environment facing traditional department-store operators

My response:

"Customers steadily continue to plead and picket--yes, picket as recently as last holiday season--for Macy's to restore Marshall Field's as a brand and ethos at its State Street Chicago flagship. Here's something customers overwhelmingly want and Macy's remains steadfast in not giving it to them. No one's been asking for all the Dayton's and Hudson's stores to become Field's again, just State Street, maybe a few other key locations. When they had Marshall Field's, they had something more than a store--a cultural institution and emporium with the fierce loyalty of an international customer base, amazingly unique compared to the many Macy's and worth the trip instead of going to Amazon. The Field's tradename was worth more than all the other May Dept. Store Co. tradenames combined. By not giving customers what they want, it's no wonder Macy's is troubled and that can be attributed to its long entrenched management."

Date: Mon, May 09, 2016, 5:08 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Macy's, Inc., parent of Macy's, Bloomingdale's, and Bluemercury, will have its first quarter conference call this Wednesday at 8:00 a.m., Chicago time.

This may be interesting because Macy's will announce other initiatives which could range to special sales or even redevelopment plans for the State Street store. Macy's, Inc. stock has again dropped below $40, significantly less than it was 9-12 months ago, when it peaked at over $70 per share.

Even if you can't listen, be sure to check back here on developments and opportunities to comment on any news that they might have.

To listen to the conference call, follow the links from the Macy's, Inc. corporate page to the special link at investor relations.

Date: Sun, May 08, 2016, 6:56 pm CT
Posted by: Rory S.,

It's Mother's Day. Happy Mother's Day! Missing Marshall Field's because it reminded me of my mother. Still devastating that it is gone.

Date: Sun, May 08, 2016, 6:39 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Congratulations to Ralph Hughes who has retired from Macy's as the vice president of government and public relations for Macy's. Mr. Hughes has had many roles at Marshall Field's, most notably at the State Street store, and then stayed on when it became Macy's. Before Marshall Field's, Mr. Hughes was an executive with Atlanta-based Rich's before Federated/Macy's converted it to Macy's.

Mr. Hughes was honored at the 100 Black Men Gala last night. Mr. Hughes has been a dedicated force behind that non-for-profit mentorship organization for many years.

Here's one media preview of the event which was also mentioned on one of the local newscasts:

Date: Fri, May 06, 2016, 7:59 pm CT
Posted by: Long Time Shopper, NYC,

Terry Lundgren's mentor recently spoke his mind about retail at a NYC gathering and people listened. Allen Questrom led Federated out of bankruptcy and then acquired Macy's out of bankruptcy in the 1990s. Then he rescued J.C.Penney in 2000s before it fell apart again five years ago. While I don't think Questrom would ever say anything bad about Lundgren, he had an awful lot to say about department stores. Some of his talk piqued me to think of how Field's return would fit his bill.

Date: Thurs, May 05, 2016, 6:39 pm CT
Posted by: Ann K.,

Hi Field's Fans! Still hopeful for Field's!?

At first a new Harris Poll Rankings makes it look like Macy's is leading the pack of department store brands.. It ranks above Kohl's and Penney's. Then look closer. Nordstrom and higher-end department stores are ranked separately. Field's would never be in the mid-range group. It would be in the better tier with Nordstrom.

Sad about Field's.

Date: Tues, May 03, 2016, 8:26 pm CT
Posted by: Karen I.,

I pass through State Street often. While I don't buy, it's shocking how dead the store is. I don't think the store is long for this world. Very sad. It could be an international destination as Marshall Field's. Would Macy's even let it return?

Date: Mon, May 02, 2016, 10:34 pm CT
Posted by: Lisa Matthews,

We miss Marshall Field's and hope that one day it will come back. Hopefully sooner rather than later.

Please keep trying.

Lisa Matthews

Date: Sun, May 01, 2016, 12:09 pm CT
Posted by: Eric B.,

Below is a link to some photos I took of the State Street store and the flower show last month.

Date: Sun, May 01, 2016, 9:49 pm CT
Posted by: Rosemary,

Jeremy Pven is on WTTW channel 11 right now talking about the background of the Mr. Selfridge show. He says that the series is an homage to Marshall Field & Co. in Chicago where he shopped as a boy. It's very clear he's very appreciative of Marshall Field and Company.

Date: Sun, May 01, 2016, 12:13 am CT
Posted by: Marty B,

Just finishing up a week in Paris, where the department stores are packed. Excitement from basement to the top floor. Oh, how I miss Marshall Field's!

Date: Sat, April 30, 2016, 11:16 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,

Story on Macy's Terry Lundgren

Date: Thurs, April 28, 2016, 7:16 pm CT
Posted by: A Field's Webwatcher,

I am glad to see this website back up again! Keep up the good work for Field's!

Date: Tues, April 26, 2016, 10:47 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Coach, the purveyor of luxury handbags and shoes, plans to discontinue selling its goods at certain department stores because excessive discounting and promotions:
Clearly the misadventures into the land of discounting have been an epic fail for macy. The constant barrage of coupons, the weekly One Day Sale with the lowest price of the day, and the gaudy TV commercials screaming out discount prices evidently haven't been a successful strategy as macy sales and stock prices continue to plummet.

Wonder if the money macy saved on purchasing shopping bags has been enough to compensate for lost sales? It would be interesting to compare sales at stores before and after they were macy*fied. How about a comparison of top tier credit card holders before and after? Many of the better brands fled the former Marshall Field's and other regional stores when they were converted to macy; we can safely assume many remaining quality brands will soon be departing macy.

Date: Tuesday, April 26, 2016, 5:56 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Thank you for your patience. The ability to post new items to this blog has been out of service over the past couple of weeks. It is now functioning again. Below, you will find a few highlights selected from recent posts to our Facebook page.

Thank you to those who brought the matter to my attention, and, most of all, thanks to all for the mutual support in our case. Looking forward to what you have to say.

Best regards,

Jim McKay

Date: Thursday, April 21, 2016, 3:35 pm CT
Posted to Facebook by: Jim McKay,

Macy's, Inc.'s (formerly Federated Department Stores) annual stock holders meeting will be held on Friday, May 20, 2016 at Macy's, Inc. headquarters in Cincinnati. Anyone who owns a share of Macy's, Inc. stock as of the close of business on March 24, 2016 is eligible to attend. Stockholders who have represented the views of FieldsFansChicago have attended every year beginning in 2008. Upon conclusion of the meeting, stockholders have an opportunity to briefly address the Chairman and CEO, Terry J. Lundgren, board of directors, senior management, media guests, and fellow stockholders in attendance.

More than simply stating a desire for FIeld's return, each year since 2008, facts and hard numbers, along with pointed questions have made the case for Field's return. This year may be very heated because of the dramatic drop in Macy's, Inc. stock and the activist stockholders. Please contact me if you plan to go and make the case for Marshall Field's .[ The latest SEC 10K filing, along with other supplementary materials, can be found at Macy's, Inc.'s Investor Relations web pages at You need to prove that you are a stockholder before you are allowed entry by providing a government-issued ID and proof of stock ownership, such as the original ballot, stock statements showing ownership as of March 24, 2016, etc.

Date: Thursday, April 21, 2016, 3:11 pm CT
Posted to Facebook by: Jim McKay,

[ A recent post to a web site featuring historical Chicago photos reminded me of a lesser known, temporary location of Field & Leiter at Adams and Michigan, currently site of the Art Institute of Chicago.]

After Field and Leiter rebuilt as a result of the great Chicago Fire of 1871, their store burned again in 1873. For Christmas that year, Field's reopened in the Interstate Exposition Building [on the east side of Michigan at Adams]. Later Field's had a location on Wabash, about where Carson's used to be until 2007. [Obviously,] Field and Leiter returned to State and Washington.

Date: Monday, April 18, 2016, 5:56 pm CT
Posted to Facebook by: Barbara J.,

As a former Field's salesgirl in the 70's, I still have a hole in my heart from the loss of this store.

Date: Sat, April 09, 2016, 6:54 pm
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Interesting that Mr Lundgren was one of TWO CEOs singled out because job performance did not justify lavish compensation:
Although stock prices and sales continue to plummet, the CEO slashes thousands of jobs to keep his own outrageous salary intact; fewer employees result in reduced customer services; customers who can't find what they want are going elsewhere, resulting in even lower sales. Mr Lundgren's grand plan to save a few bucks on shopping bags and localized merchandising has been a dismal failure.

There is no "excitement" about shopping because there is a macy everywhere. Having a nationwide chain works for CVS, JCPenney or Walgreens because those are more utilitarian stores and shoppers go there mostly for practical items. Instead of generating a "WOW!" macy generates a "meh." Totally agree with suggestions by mikea and that changes must be made.

Date: Wed, April 06, 2016, 12:08 pm CT
Posted by: mikea,

Macy's dismal results last year and continued cost cutting reflects more on the nature of retail in the last year than anything else.

Their their quality over the last five years has gone down and they need to make their better stores more special returning in store resteraunts more special events, more merchandise categories to include larger home stores electronics departments from outside vendors and even in store grocery. Their focusing on clothing is not working.

Customers today are not shopping for apparel as much as they did years ago. People are spending more on home, travel dining and entertainment along with autos.

Their competitors also had a bad year. Neiman's lost money in the last quarter, Nordstrom, down, Dillard's and bon-Ton down. In Fact Bon_ton is in such bad shape they have a freeze on wages and are not even contributing to retirement accounts this year. Jc Penney did better, but they are still rebounding from almost on the road to closure. Off price continues to do well as customers look for more value then ever before.

Date: Tues, April 05, 2016, 7:36 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Two articles in the past few days about Field's.

One article in the Chicago Tribune is by Rick Kogan, who like me, did think this year's Macy's flower show at State Street was really good. IMHO, the best since the store became Macy's.

He did mention us in negative way. I'm a huge fan of Mr. Kogan and hope someday he interviews myself or one of our regulars. (Mr. Kogan's father was co-author of "Give The Lady What She Wants" which was published in the early 1950s when Kogan was a lad.

The story is at

In another story featured in The Daily Herald, Author Leslie Goddard discussed her book on Marshall Field's at the Bartlett Library. That story related why so many miss Marshall Field's.

It can be found at

Please leave comments after both stories--the "comments" button is really buried towards the bottom of the Kogan piece. urthermore, letters to the editor of the Chicago Tribune can be sent to Be sure to include your name, city, state and phone number, along with the phrase, "FOR PUBLICATION."

Date: Sat, April 02, 2016, 12:38 am ET
Posted by: Eric Bronsky,

While downtown this past week, I took a deep breath and scooted up to the 9th floor to view Macy’s Flower Show. Afterwards, searching online, I found this site:

This is a wonderful behind-the-scenes account of Marshall Field’s 2001 Flower Show at both the Water Tower and State Street stores. The color photography is excellent. Macy’s 2016 Flower Show was surely a commendable effort … but these photos and the accompanying story suggest that more time, effort, care, and creativity went into Field’s flower shows.

-- Eric

Date: Fri, April 01, 2016, 8:15 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Evidently Mr Lundgren's brilliant "strategy" of reducing quality department stores to the lowest common denominator has proven to be a dismal failure as sales and stock prices continue to plummet. The macy management was able to show a profit for many years by steadily cutting back staffing, services, quality, assortments and other amenities. The management was not growing the business, just cutting expenses. It reached the tipping point when macy cut so much, there was no reason for shoppers to even bother going there.

Sadly macy is following the same destructive path taken by the CEO of Sears. Take a solid, profitable business, invest no money in upgrading or innovating, don't listen to what the customers want, get rid of popular brand names, cut back on staff who know the business, sell off assets to keep afloat. Then muddle the vision of who you are--better quality store or discounter or whatever.

JCPenney has been doing better once the management focused on who they are--a mid market, family oriented, value priced department store. The previous CEO tried to make them something they weren't, and almost forced the company into bankruptcy.

The venture into discounting will be another epic fail. Why is this macy filled with brand name, full price merchandise while their other store is a big clearance center? They can't be both without further diluting their brand name and alienating customers.

Date: Fri, April 1, 2016, 1:55 pm CT
FB Posted by: M.N.,

[Macy's is] Deservedly doomed!

Date: Fri, April 1, 2016, 8:48 am CT
FB Posted by: Mike W.,

[Macy's is] non-responsive to their markets. Doomed !

Date: Thurs, March 31, 2016, 4:44 pm CT
FB Posted by: Aaron M.,

Stock dropped 47%!? They are ripe for takeover.

Date: Wed, March 30, 2016, 8:39 pm CT
FB Posted by: Marissa P.,

If they would have kept all of the Marshall Field's they probably would have been better off. As a Michigander, when Hudson's became Marshall Field's it was okay because the quality, service, etc. was very similar. When they became Macy's it was horrible! I miss those stores terribly.

Date: Wed, March 30, 2016, 7:47 pm CT
FB Posted by: M.Z.,

Let's take a moment to consider the fact that Macy's has failed. Whatever move they make next can't change that. They thought they would come in, take over an iconic department store and grow their dowdy empire, and it didn't work. And it is my strong conviction that they would be in a far different place in Chicago if they had kept the Marshall Field's brand and standards. I hope they regret all the stupid, egotistical, short-sighted decisions they made.

Date: Wed, March 30, 2016, 4:02 pm CT
FB Posted by: Jeanie W.,

True. Would like to be a fly on the wall in the next board meeting. This can't go unanswered.
According to at least one analyst report, April - July is the optimum time for Macy's be acquired or merged--not that it is required to happen. New owners could mean not only no Lundgren, nor anyone groomed to follow in his footsteps of not bringing back Field's. However, a new owner could be worse.

Date: Wed, March 30, 2016, 3:39 pm CT
FB Posted by: Jeanie W.,

Interesting. I wonder what their next move will be...

Date: Wed, March 30, 2016, 3:19 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Quite a few stories about this today. The stockholders meeting is Friday, May 20, 2016 in Cinci.
Macy's brass sees incentive bonuses cut to zero after weak year

The largest U.S. department store company made the move after missing revenue and expense targets in 2015.

Date: Tues, March 29, 2016, 10:46 pm CT
Posted by: M.N.,

Big congratulations to the amazing Gayle.

Date: Tues, March 29, 2016, 6:37 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Thursday, April 7, 2016. This will be somewhat similar to our talk from October 30, 2014 in case you missed it.

Author Gayle Soucek discusses "Mr. Selfridge in Chicago: Marshall Field's, the Windy City & the...

Join us as author Gayle Soucek discusses her new book titled Mr. Selfridge in Chicago¦


Date: Sun, March 27, 2016, 8:23 pm CT
Posted by: Correction,

Actually, Mr Selfridge starts at 9 pm on channel 11.

Date: Sun, March 27, 2016, 6:43 pm CY
Posted by: State Street Watcher,

Don't forget that the fourth and final season of Masterpiece Classic: Mr Selfridge begins tonight at 8 pm on Chicago's WTTW Channel 11 prime.

Date: Sun, March 27, 2016, 4:22 pm CT
Posted by: mikea,


It seems that the flower show on 9 has caused some problems for Macys. Watering the flowers last Sunday night, some large mistake was made that the area on 9 flooded. The water seeped into the Wabash elevators shutting them down. Also the water damaged about 60,000 worth of fine rugs on 8.

In another note the mens store will be taking over the entire 2nd floor as M style lab will be moving upstairs. Interesting to see if they open a backstage store on State Street.

Date: Sat, March 26, 2016, 5:06 pm CT
FB Posted by: Charles S.,

Re: Macy's Flower Show at State Street: So the flower show is held where the housewares department used to be?

Date: Wed, March 23, 2016, 12:50 pm CT
Posted by: kitty,

Hi All,

I have three beautiful mid-century coats that were custom made at Marshall Field. I tried to donate them to the Chicago History Museum, but they do not need more clothes. I was referred to Columbia School of Fashion, but they have never returned my calls.

I am relocating to Florida in a couple of weeks and want to ensure that my Nana's coats find a place of honor, representing both Marshall Field and Chicago. Does anyone have any suggestions/recommendations I can effect before my early April departure?

Thank you!


Kitty Shelley
PHONE: 773-844-1111
EMAIL: kitty AT kspartnerships DOT com

Date: Tues, March 22, 2016, 11:09 pm CT
FB Posted by: Tina T.,

Re: Macy's Flower Show at State Street: Beautiful but they could have put more effort into the Walnut Room.

Date: Tues, March 22, 2016, 10:36 pm CT
FB Posted by: Ruth W.,

Re: Macy's Flower Show at State Street: I agree , a worthy effort this year!

Date: Tues, March 22, 2016, 8:56 pm CT
FB Posted by: Ruth W.,

Re: Macy's Flower Show at State Street:

Date: Tues, March 22, 2016, 8:56 pm CT
FB Posted by: Ruth W.,

Re: Macy's Flower Show at State Street: I will NEVER shop at Macys

Date: Tues, March 22, 2016, 8:25 pm CT
FB Posted by: Jim H.,

Nice flowers [in this year's Macy's Flower Show at State Street]. How do Macy's executives feel given that so many tens of thousands of people remained turned off by Macy's getting rid of Marshall Field's - Even after all these years.

Date: Tues, March 22, 2016, 8:18 pm CT
FB Posted by: Jim McKay,

I checked out this year's Macy's flower show. For those who are not familiar, it's different from the days when Marshall Field's and Dayton's had them. They no longer have flowers throughout the store but instead they concentrate them in one area. In doing this, they no longer have to keep the store very cold. I suppose there's conflicting opinions as to whether the flowers all around the store or concentrated is better, but that's how it is now. In the case of State Street, the show is located on 9 at Randolph/Wabash. In recent years, I've been disappointed in the Macy's flower show. It was maybe a couple of years ago when I thought the flower show was typical of nothing more than a very large Jewel-Osco floral department. Nothing too unusual--some tulips, azaleas, and other flowers one might see for sale at Jewel-Osco at Easter time. This year they went all out and did a great job in my opinion. I have also attended this year's Chicago Flower and Garden show and it was comparable in quality. My understanding is that very similar shows are being offered also at other Macy's stores including Herald Square in New York City, City Centre in Philadelphia, the former Dayton's flagship in Minneapolis, and at Union Square in San Francisco. So I have to give credit where credit is due--and I have to say they did a good job this year. That said, I can't help but wonder how many tens or hundreds of thousands are so turned off by Macy's getting rid of Marshall Field's, that they won't even give chance to this rare time when does something well.

Date: Tues, March 22, 2016, 6:27 pm CT
Posted by: Jim,

Thanks, Field's Watcher. Also a story from
Macy's Is Getting Serious About Making Money Off Its Real Estate

Date: Tues, March 22, 2016, 10:01 am CT
Posted by: Field's Watcher,

Story about Macy's adding a successful, relatively young real estate expert to its board of directors to assist with monetizing the real estate at flasghip stores like State Street.

Macy's appoints real estate expert to its board

Date: Mon, March 21, 2016, 4:42 pm CT
Posted by: Carol B.,

Just wanted you to know that I converted my "Forever Marshall Field" button into a Christmas ornament. It was the highlight of my Christmas party.

Carol B.

Date: Sun, March 20, 2016, 1:28 pm CT
Posted by: Anna H.,

Full page ads in today's newspapers for the Macy's flower show at State Street on the 9th floor. Apparently they are also giving bags away to shoppers. I'm not sure if it's the same Macy's bags that on 7 or if these are different. They need to do promotions to get people in the store. As Field's, Field's was the promotion!

Date: Fri, March 18, 2016, 6:07 pm CT
Posted by: Richard in Houston,

I have been talking with the CEO of Strategic Marks for years and was very pleased with the outcome of the negotiations with Macy's since Foley's was part of the agreement. Houstonians, as well as those in other market's Foley's had expanded to in the Southwest, miss them terribly. They were much more than a store, just like the other regionals were to their communities. I did find it telling that Marshall Field's was brought up in much of the media when the announcement was made. It shows how they were indeed a nationally/internationally known brand with an exceptional reputation. My hope is that Selfridges will be the white knight (or Lundgren's successor) and bring Marshall Field's back to its rightful place in Chicago.

Date: Fri, March 18, 2016, 4:57 pm CT
Posted by: Field's Watcher,

Macy's hiring expert to deal with real estate

Date: Thurs, March 17, 2016, 7:24 pm CT
Posted by: gle,



Date: Tue, March 15, 2016, 12:11 am CT
FB Posted by: Michael D.,

40 years ago today, Field's opened at Orland Square. It became Macy's ten years ago.

Date: Mon, March 14, 2016, 7:15 am CT
Posted by: Susan NY,

I hate to say it, but "pretty much" is still not Field's....that's why it is so compelling to fight for it, whole-hog. As another post-er observed......corporate greed and general homogenization have drained away even the context in which Field's stood out. I suppose it will require a very courageous entrepreneur who knows what he is doing to make it work. Anyone out there with the brilliance Marshall Field had?

Date: Sun, March 13, 2016, 3:29 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Jim H: Exactly. As we've been saying, if Macy's won't restore Marshall Field's, then our plan B is to have Selfridges return to Chicago after 112 years, much as Mariano's is the reincarnation of Dominick's. At least we'd have a Marshall Field's-quality store with strong connections to the experience that Mr. Selfridge helped pioneer at Field's 120 years ago. Field's has rebuilt its flagship after other disasters. In such case, a "Selfridges Chicago" would be a spiritual resurrection of Field's, just as many agree that Mariano's is pretty much a spiritual resurrection of Dominick's.

Date: Sat, March 12, 2016, 2:37 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

This is from today St. Patrick's Day Parade I'm Columbus Drive in Grant Park. It was way too crowded and too loud for me to push buttons are leaflets, let alone hold one of our giant signs. Wall-to-wall people. Zero inches between people. So for the 30 minutes I was out there, I can promote, except to wear a button. Every single person in this photo approached me because I was wearing a Marshall Field button, because I approach them. Also keep in mind that I was about 30 feet BEHIND the center of attention, the parade. Imagine the response if there was something about Marshall Field's in the parade. The crowd would go nuts.

Date: Thurs, March 11, 2016, 7:21 am CT
FB Posted by: David P.,

I Loved Marshall Fields - Merchandise Quality - TOPS and it WAS Chicago!!

Date: Fri, March 11, 2016, 5:28 am CT
FB Posted by: Jim M.,

Patent expert Ira S. Sacks, @irassacsm, tweeted @FieldsFansChgo:
@FieldsFansChgo Macy's seeks sanctions, asserting Ds claim of victory violates conf provision of settlement K.
Just my take: As far as I know, Mr. Sacks has no partiality to liking either Field's, Macy's, or Bloomingdale's, nor Strategic Marks, for that matter. He just seems to be very interested for obvious professional reasons.

Date: Thurs, March 10, 2016, 4:12 pm CT
FB Posted by: Jim H.,

Jim McKay: [Regarding your post about Safeway, Dominick's, and Mariano's:] A business plan for Selfridges to pursue?

Date: Thurs, March 10, 2016, 17:55
FB Posted by: Jim McKay,

Mike: I agree with your implication that if Macy's had a better store than Marshall Field's, we wouldn't be out there protesting, attending stockholder meetings, having other events, etc. As a corollary, look how Safeway kept the Dominick's brand but otherwise converted the store to Safeway. The final nail in Safeway's coffin was when the Dominick's execs had their noncompete agreements expire and those executives opened stores under the Mariano's banner that are vastly superior to Safeway's version of Dominicks, and moreover, are a contemporary version of what Dominick's was before Safeway took over.

Date: Thurs, March 10, 2016, 3:48 pm CT
FB Posted by: Mike S.,

Marshall Field's was the last full line, old fashioned dept. Store left in the US. I'll never get over this. I used to travel from NJ to Chicago at least once a year to shop there. I would have been able to give Macy's a pass on this if they filled the store with quality merchandise and actually cleaned and maintained the store. Just makes me sick to walk in there to know what it was like under Marshall Fields. All of the other stores that Macy's took over lost their identity years ago, but not Marshall Fields. Macy's Inc could be raking in the money with 3 separate divisions: Macy's, Bloomingdale's and Marshall Field's, but with everything else in this country it is all about the bottom line. Shame Target sold them in the first place. I'm just glad I got to experience it.

Date: Thurs, March 10, 2016, 
FB Posted by: Jim McKay,

David P., Regarding your list of now non-extant State Street and Chicago stores: Marshall Field's is an exception to all the rest in many ways. For starters, unlike all the others, they didn't "go under" financially. Moreover, it defined State Street and was its most international destination. Save for CD Peacock, Carson, Pirie, Scott & Co., the Palmer House and one or two others, most all the other businesses were locally known but had relatively little international attention.

Date: Thurs, March 10, 2016, 1:02 pm
FB Posted by: David P.,

remember when State Street was truly a Great Street - remembering Sears, Carson Pierre Scott, Lyttons, Goldblatt''s ( I occasionally worked there ) - and their bargain basement and Marshall Fields. The buildings were massive, and during the holidays it were magical with their animated figurines. The hustle and bustle of the city. I was born in 1960 - an era like no other: forgotten Chicago....How many locations from that era do you remember? Goldblatt's, I used to worker there ( many years) and during the holidays my grandparents used to buy their live Christmas trees there. Weibolts, Zayre ( Christmas eve shopping there ) , Community Department store - Clark and Belmont, AT&T Phone Center Stores - I worked there "for" years, Avondale Saving and Loan - Milwaukee and Avondale ( my mom used to work there) Montgomery Wards, Woolworths ( and eating at their diner), Aunt Jemima Restaurants, Lyttons - upscale clothing, and ........all just a memory, as through out the rest of USA, colors of individualism and mom and pa shops smothered by corporate greed - Just some kodachrome memories that have been muted in my today's bland existence.

Date: Thurs, March 10, 2016, 10:35 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

I had occasion to be in the store this morning. (I'm referring to the State Street Macy's that used to be Marshall Field and Company.) Again, they have the Easter candy displays in the usual spots, except Frango's, including Cheggs, have been given a more prominent spot on the first floor where the visitors center used to be. They've also added "R. H. Macy and Co."- branded fudge eggs that are not the same, but awfully similar looking to Frango Cheggs. Who knows if they plan to replace the Frango Cheggs or if Macy's just plans to supplement them with the R.H. Macy & Co. brand which is probably chainwide.

The "Macy's Chicago" and "Marshall Field and Company" handbags and similar items have been removed from the Choose Chicago visitor center on the lower level to the center of Seven and also Walbash/Washington, which I've started to refer to lately as the Selfridge part of the building. They have a lot more Macy's Chicago items then they do Marshall Field items.

Also: They have redone the Culinary Council wall on seven. It used to be a lot more in Marshall Field green. Now it's done in Macy's red with more Macy's-like graphics.

Date: Mon, March 07, 2016, 4:55 pm Ct
Posted by: Steve Henrichs,

Aside from Marshall Field's, I'd love to picket Macy's CEO for also helping Donald Trump build his image by selling his goods in Macy's stores as if Trump were amusing. Lundgren seems amoral. To me it's as if he will sell anything as long as it has basic legality and makes money. He could care if something hurts society by killing Marshall Field's or promoting The Donald.

Date: Mon, March 07, 2016, 14:50
Posted by: David, ,

Just read that Macy's head Terry Lundgren is in town for the International Home + Housewares show at Navy Pier. Lundgren is one of two honorees for their annual charity gala, It's Smart to Have a Heart. The other honoree is Lester Gribetz,president of Lenox and a former Bloomingdale's employee.

The gala is TONIGHT at Navy Pier starts at 6 pm. Marshall Field's fans should show up at the west entrance to the pier at 4/4:30 pm to protest for Marshall Field's. That's when everyone arrives and will see it. Short notice but if you are in the area, you should be able to make it.

Date: Sun, March 06, 2016, 1:55 pm CT
Posted by: gle,

I saw all those beautiful "Selfies for Selfridge's" photos and am not surprised at the number of them. I still get comments on my Field's button and in some of the most unexpected places. I was trying to cross a street downtown in Chicago during one of our recent windstorms. A person noticed my button and asked about it. I did my best to explain to her while we were trying to make it though the intersection without being blown over.

I would love to see a white night come and grab the store away from Macy's, but don't know if Strategic Marks was really the best person for the job. The news articles sound like he is content to just move on without it. I would rather see Selfridge's get it.

Date: Fri, March 04, 2016, 11:23 am CT
Posted by: Sharon Hollinger,

Macy's did the wrong thing in taking out Marshall Field's. If they had bought Carson's and changed them to Macy's, I don't think people would have minded. Carson's was Bergner's since 1990s and their logos even look close enough. What a mistake by Macy's.

Date: Fri, March 04, 2016, 10:01 am CT
Posted by: Scot,

Hi! Another story and the name they focus on is Marshall Field's:

NEWS Macy's Keeps Marshall Field's, Loses Various Legacy Store Brands

Date: Wed, March 2, 2016, 6:39 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Referencing Dave Andrew's post from last night aboutthe Cincinnati Business Journal's coverage of the trademark case, it's interesting how all these out of town articles focus on how Macy's is keeping Marshall Field's. You'd expect St Louis Post DIspatch to feature Robinson-May's potential return since it was based there or Cincinnati would recall its stores lost to Macy's--but they headline Marshall Field's. Indeed, another example of how Field's was more valuable and stood out as a national (and international) brand.
Macy's loses legacy department store brands, keeps Marshall Field's, in settlement - Cincinnati Business Journal.
Cincinnati-based Macy's Inc. is losing some of its legacy department store brands but retaining some big names in a settlement with a California-based company.

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 8:23 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Another article about the settlement between macy and Strategic Marks concerning legacy department store names:
The headline specifically states that macy "keeps Marshall Field's" while relinquishing other nameplates. Perhaps the implication is that macy realizes Field's is too valuable to give up; if that is indeed the case, then why aren't they bringing it back so they can reap some of the value? Also noted they are retaining Lazarus and Kaufmann's--could it be that macy is also a flop in Columbus and Pittsburgh.

bamberger*s was a very nice regional department store chain serving New Jersey with some stores in the Baltimore and Philly areas. It was a sister store to the "real" R.H. Macy and offered quality merchandise and good value. That being said, there probably hasn't been a groundswell of demand to bring back bamberger*s.

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 6:18 pm CT
Posted by: Ami M.,

Keep the faith! Someday our Marshall Fields will come home.

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 3:55 pm CT
Posted by: Natalie R.,

Just doesn't make sense! Almost mean!

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 3:47 pm CT
Posted by: Tamara M.,

In reply to Natalie's last post: So no one else can use [the Marshall Field's name] to compete with Macy's.

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 3:27 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Macy's keeps Marshall Field's name in court settlement over dormant brands
"Macy's, which retired the Marshall Field's name a decade ago, will keep the rights to the beloved Chicago brand as part of a court settlement reached with a…"
Please contribute your own comments beneath the as you are moved and as you have content access. Furthermore, letters to the editor of the Chicago Tribune can be sent to Be sure to include your name, city, state and phone number, along with the phrase, "FOR PUBLICATION."

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 3:23 pm CT
Posted by: Natalie R.,

Why [does Macy's] even want it?!

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 3:20 pm CT
Posted by: McKay,

Macy's keeps Marshall Field's name in fight over dormant brands
The California man wanted to revive name of defunct retailer
Field's is the headline even though the Robinson-May brand had a much, much more significant connection to St Louis.

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 12:45 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Timothy: That's a good way to look at this. Moreover, I'm sure you are like me--you hope or and even feel confidence that Lundgren's successor already recognizes restoring Field's in ethos, culture and name, even before this. Before this suit arose, Macy's spokespeople have responded to our protest rallies in publications like the Chicago Tribune that Macy's had no plans to restore Marshall Field's.

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 12:27 pm CT
Posted by: Timothy E.,

If these 're-launches' go well (and I pray that they do), then Lundgren's successor might - just might - see the wisdom in this, and seek to do something similar with the Field's name and concept.

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 11:26 am CT
Posted by: M.N.,

Wish we were in the "second lease" category. (sigh)

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 11:15 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

The New York Post
California company to revive shelved department stores

At least half a dozen defunct department stores will get a second lease on life. A six-year legal battle between Macy's -- which owns more than 20 trademarks for departed chains, including Marshall...

Date: Tues, March 1, 2016, 7:02 am CT
Posted by: Susan NY,

I think they are only imaginative enough to be dog-in-the-manger. They don't wannabe Marshall Field's and they don't want anyone else to go there either. At this point, they have a long track record of mediocrity— it would be a shame to spoil it now.

Date: Mon, February 29, 2016, 10:50 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

So macy must allow Strategic Marks to use SOME discontinued department store names. Interesting which iconic name is conspicuously missing from this list:
Why didn't macy release ALL the historic nameplates? Perhaps they are retaining the top tier names and are planning to bring them back. Could they have figured out that shoppers are bored with seeing the macy name everywhere and that the value of their own brand has been diluted. Did they finally realize travelers and tourists did NOT see macy as a destination since it's no longer unique to New York--and NO visitor to Chicago, Philly, Atlanta, Miami or other metro area will seek out a macy. Maybe they realize it was a poor business decision to homogenize the shopping experience by having a macy store at every shopping mall everywhere--and they finally see the value of giving the customers what they want.

Date: Sat, February 27, 2016, 8:50 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Newport man wins brands for 7 department stores
The long-disappeared Jordan Marsh blueberry muffins may be making a comeback. And customers could soon be shopping for apparel and goods from department stores such as Bullocks, I-Magnin’s and the May Co.

Date: Fri, February 26, 2016, 11:18 am CT
Posted by: Susan NY,

This says a lot about what is not any more, even if it never was, exactly, but almost....

Date: Tues, February 23, 2016, 9:55 pm CT
Posted by: Chris R.,

Macy's flower show is cosponsored by Krazy Glue? Seriously? And Macy's says they haven't taken what was once Marshall Field's down market.

The current flower show at State Street is an offshoot of what was at Minneapolis. However, Macy's has had flower shows at Union Square and Herald Square for years. Longer then Dayton's. Not that Marshall Field's hasn't had flower shows before Dayton's.

Date: Tues, February 23, 2016, 6:05 pm CT
Posted by: Susan C.,

The Flower Show actually started under the Dayton Hudson's era. this is something that was done at their stores first. correct me if I am wrong.

Date: Tues, February 23, 2016, 4:52 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Chicago Magazine has an ad for Macy's spring flower show. This year, it overlaps/competes one day with the Chicago flower and Garden show at Navy Pier, running from March 20 through April 3 on the 9th floor as in recent years.

Date: Tues, February 23, 2016, 8:12 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

This morning was Macy's Q4 2015 and year-end conference call with analyst questions. I was expecting something about State Street and the real estate monetization. However, Macy's, Inc's CFO, Karen Hoguet, just said that Macy's has received great interest redevelopment/real estate transactions for their flagship stores (like State Street), but it's still premature to announce things. Not good news, not had.

Date: Sat, February 20, 2016, 10:18 am CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Has anyone else noticed that macy is cutting back on the depth and breadth of merchandise? At a large former Lazarus in Columbus, the china and crystal selections have been drastically cut back. The linen department has shelving units filled with lots of the same items instead of a variety of merchandise. Display tables and racks have been moved farther apart.

Glass shelves covered in dust. Worn flooring and faded walls. So sad when one thinks of how well stocked and beautifully maintained the Lazarus stores always were. Kohl's and Meijer (a regional discount chain) have more attractive facilities.

Date: Sat, February 20, 2016, 9:05 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Again macy management has proven they don't know what they are doing. Sections of final clearance merchandise were labeled Backstage in January; these sections have now been re-labeled as Last Act! in their stores. Why the name change--and what about the expense to make this change?

Signs near the Last Act! sections carry the disclaimer "Extra Discounts Do Not Apply" in small print at the bottom. This system is going to be very confusing for all the bargain shoppers at macy, especially since the Last Act! sections are adjacent to "regular" clearance merchandise. This may play out like the pricing fiasco at JCPenney, which almost ran that company into bankruptcy. Regular clearance: coupons can be used. Final clearance: coupons cannot be used. Perhaps putting all the final clearance items into one section of the store (like the old fashion bargain basements) would have made more sense. This scenario is going to offer the full price items, sale items, regular clearance items and final clearance items in close proximity. Merchandise will be misplaced, customers will be confused, and pricing errors and disagreements will be commonplace.

They just don't get it.

Date: Wed, February 17, 2016, (;22 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

Macy's, Inc., parent company of Macy's, Bloomingdale's, and Bluemercury stores and formerly known as Federated Department Stores, Inc., will have its Q4 2015 Macy's, Inc. Earnings Conference Call on Tuesday, February 23, 2016 at 8 am Chicago time. Assuming that there will be a link at

Date: Tues, February 16, 2016, 10:25 pm CT
Posted by: Edie Smith,

We miss Marshall Fields a great deal. We hope it comes back someday. We also have tried Macy's and it's not as good.

Date: Sun, February 14, 2016, 18:56
Posted by: Mary McCormack ,

I was thinking about Marshall Field's today and found this page. Our family just doesn't shop at Macy's. We tried to like it and we genuinely gave the brand a chance. It has been a disappointment from the beginning. We shopped at Field's a lot, furniture, clothes, housewares, gifts(bought nearly every shower present here!!!!). The Macy's service is poor and quality of products are questionable. The State St. store is a mess. My husband and I went to see the windows at Christmas and the grillwork above the doors is filthy and filled with trash and dust. It's so disheartening. Marshall Field's was probably considered a "tired" brand by the Macy's executives but this change has been a disaster for them and for the Marshall Field's customer. I know that keeping the name wouldn't change any of the "real" problems that department stores,in general, are facing. But that's what makes one wonder why they would take a terrific brand name like Marshall Field's and risk changing it to Macy's.

Date: Thurs, February 11, 2016, 7:32 am CT
Posted by: Susan NY,

The Wonder of It All:

Why does brilliant Macy's need a "lifeline" unless it made a relentless succession of what many consider mind-boggling, dreadful, foolish decisions where they had a Golden Opportunity?

What good is a "lifeline" to Macy's, dying of its own determined folly? Its track record suggests it undoubtedly will maintain its blockheaded-ness unaltered during a would-be recovery.

Why would anyone expect Macy's to get the restaurant part right anyway?

Besides, where Field's is concerned, there is a pronounced malevolent streak showing through: Macy's has been pleased to see Cinderella in rags and ashes. This self-indulgence has been paid for with mortal damage rippling through the entire Macy structure-- a lot needs fixing and an irresistible restaurant won't divert attention from the plywood and duct tape paving the way to fine dining.

Maybe it was not enough to declare the edifice at 111 N State a National Historic Landmark. The goings-on within the remarkable building were part of the deal, the two were yin and yang. Maybe it is time to formally acknowledge that the merchandising operation was a conceptual national historic landmark as well, given its great influence on retailing as a whole.

Poor, abused Cinderella did manage to escape the cinders.............

Date: Wed, February 10, 2016, 9:56 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Hello, State Street Sam

Your post is absolutely on point! Clearly the macy management personnel don't know what they are doing. On the same day they announce the closing of a long serving restaurant in suburban Detroit, they decide that food services will be a lifeline. A similar article appeared in Yahoo Finance:
I only visited Chicago once in the late 1980s but I did spend an entire day exploring Marshall Field's--and there was definitely enough to fill an entire day with shopping and snacking! I do have several Field's cookbooks and I often ordered Frango and other excellent food products. Field's was a destination for Chicago visitors and a source for unique items through their catalogs.

I visited the Herald Square macy several years ago and their food offerings featured a McDonald's! Some symbolism there perhaps.

Date: Wed, February 10, 2016, 6:43 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

The Wall Street Journal has a story about Barneys return to its Downtown Manhattan flagship after 22 years.

This demonstrates that a great emporium can come back. Barney's return after 22 years gives great hope to the multitudes who overwhelmingly want to see Chicago's international emporium Marshall Field's resurrected for the 21st century on State Street . In retail, anything can happen!


Barneys Returns Downtown
Once a hub for Manhattan luminaries like Iman and David Bowie, and a base for a generation of international designers, including Christian Louboutin and Giorgio Armani, the Barneys flagship reopens this month at its original Manhattan…


Date: Wed, February 10, 2016, 5:58 pm CT
Posted by: State Street Sam,

Dear Dave Andrews,

What irony! Your post reminded me of another story I just saw about how Macy's should be attracting customers by focusing on their restaurants. They help make the stores social destinations. The author cites the new 6th floor restaurant at 34th Street NYC. As far as I'm concerned, that is based on all the restaurants at Marshall Field's.

Headline: Could restaurants be Macy's lifeline?

Date: Wed, February 10, 2016, 3:03 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

Seems like macy is doing its best to get rid of amenities which would attract customers:

Shoppers have increasingly FEWER reasons to even bother going there.

Date: Mon, February 08, 2016, 6:39 pm CT
Posted by: An Observer,


Date: Mon, February 08, 2016, 4:26 pm CT
Posted by: Dave Andrews,

So why is macy fighting so hard to prevent another business from using the department store names it eliminated? Wasn't macy a more powerful name because of the vintage holiday movie? Weren't shoppers supposed to feel the "excitement" of having a New York name in their dismal lives?

I would venture to say if a retailer would operate JUST ONE store in each major market under the iconic names, stocked with quality merchandise and staffed by well-trained employees, shoppers would make the operation an unqualified success! Imagine ONE Burdine's, Filene's, The Broadway, Kaufmann's, Strawbridge's, Marshall Field's. Each would truly be a tourist destination since it was unique and special! There is only ONE Harrod's and it is a major attraction for visitors.

One reason cited by macy for poor sales was lack of tourist trade. Wonder if they are afraid that a one-of-a-kind department store in a major city (or suburb thereof) with a beloved name offering quality and service would further erode their sales?

Date: Sun, February 07, 2016, 1:52 pm CT
Posted by: Paula Wesson,

Ever since Macy's took over Marshall Field and Company, we now call the stores "Messy's."

And of course now we don't shop there.

Date: Thurs, February 04, 2016, 9:40 pm
Posted by: Jim McKay,

WTTW11's "Ask Geoffrey" feature covers Marshall Field's Cloud Room at Midway as well as sculpture that was there and where it went. A menu from the Cloud Room is displayed in the video.

Date: Thurs, February 04, 2016, 9:28 pm
Posted by: Jim McKay,

It gets more complicated. Apparently there's more to come...the reader comments after should also be considered. Please contribute your own comments as you are moved. Furthermore, letters to the editor of the Chicago Tribune can be sent to Be sure to include your name, city, state and phone number, along with the phrase, "FOR PUBLICATION."
Macy's protects Marshall Field's name in court

Macy's might have ditched the Marshall Field 's name a decade ago after it bought the storied Chicago department store chain, but that doesn't mean the retailer wants anyone else to use the moniker, either.

Consider this story and then think if instead Macy's focussed on keeping and building the Marshall Field's brand back ten years ago.

Date: Thurs, February 04, 2016,  7:58 pm
Posted by: gle,

A battle was lost but not the war.

Date: Thurs, February 04, 2016, 4:26 pm
Posted by: Dave Andrews ,

It seems macy is simply "rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic" instead of addressing the real problems:
Macy's Management Shakeup
Clearly they still don't get it.

Date: Wed, February 3, 2016, 7:38 pm CT
FB Posted by: Joseph D.,


Date: Wed, February 3, 2016, 7:24 pm CT
FB Posted by: Alfred I.,

Re: "Macy's Gets Win on "Heritage" Department Store Names":

Not necessarily sad--food for thought, and further action. Macy's is wasting the goodwill value of these trademarks it does not use for actual stores.

Date: Wed, February 3, 2016, 7:20 pm CT
FB Posted by: Jeannie W.,

Re: "Macy's Gets Win on "Heritage" Department Store Names":

This is sad

Date: Wed, February 3, 2016, 7:16 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay,

"Macy's Gets Win on "Heritage" Department Store Names"

Date: Tues, February 2, 2016, 9:03 am CT
FB Posted by: Michael D.,

Found the Dillard's "heritage" tote bags on awebsite via Google!

Date: Tues, February 2, 2016, 7:02 am CT
FB Posted by: Gabriel M.,

Dillard's is now offering "Heritage" tote bags, just like Macy's. Apparently, they feel they also may need to offer something with the trademarks of the stores that they got rid of over the years. There are tote bags for Higbee's, Bacon's, D.H. Holmes, Gayfers, and Maison Blanche.

Click here to view items from before February 1, 2016


Standard disclaimer: This is a non-profit, non-commercial, non-sponsored site developed with the sole intention of focusing on what Marshall Field’s has meant to Chicagoans or anyone who lo ve this great Chicago institution. The views and opinions expressed on these pages are solely those of the authors listed and do not necessaarily represent thos e who operate this site. This site is NOT affiliated in any way with Marshall Field's, the May Department Stores Company, Federated Department Stores, Macy's, Inc., Selfridges Group, Hudson's Bay, or ©2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017 All Rights Reserved.

email the webmaster <>